Whichisoneofthethings I thinkmakes a mockeryofantireligioustheoriesthatareevenquitesophisticated, say, likeFreud's, becauseFreudthoughtofreligionas a a zawishfulfillment, essentiallyandandalsomarkswhothoughtaboutreligionastheopiateofthemasses.
It's ifthoseweretrue.
Itseemstomethatthere'd be a lotmorewishand a lotlessreality, a lotlessstark, harshreality.
Youknow, thefirstthingthatAbrahamencountersisah, famine, andthenhehastohidehiswifeandthenhehebasicallyjourneysinto a tyranny.
Soclearlytheimproperwaytoengageis, I think, mostclearlydelineatedintheCainandAbelstoryandwithCaneexemplifyingtheinappropriatewaytoengagewiththeworld.
Andthat's toengagewiththeworldin a bitter, jealousandresentfulmanner.
Now, oneofthethingsthat I reallylikedaboutCainandAbelstoryandthatthemeRikerscontinuallywiththewiththedualityofthebrothersrightthere's there's constantconflictbetween a perspectivethat's essentiallylikeKeynesandandtheandtheoppositeperspective, whichallwhich I'llgettoin a minute.
ButCainseesthattheworldis a very, ahtragicplaceandthattherewardsaredistributedunfairlyandthattherearepeoplewhodobetterandpeoplewhodoworse.
Andas a consequenceofthat, hebecomesbitterandresentfulandcursesGod.
Andsothat's oneofthethings I reallylikeandwasmoresurprisedaboutwiththeOldTestamentstoriesisthatthesepeopleareverycomplexlivesandtheymakeverymajormoralerrorsbyanyone's standardAndyetifandyettheoverallmessageisstillhopefulandthemessagethatrunscontrarytothemessageofevilsaythatmessageofgoodissomethinglike, Well, there's a lotofemphasisonfaith, right?
Andthat's a toughone, becausecynicspeoplewhoarecynicalaboutreligiousstructuresliketothinkoffaithasthewillingnesstodemolishyourintellectintheserviceofsuperstition.
And, well, there's somethingtobesaidforthatperspective, butnot a lot, becausetherealityismuchmoresophisticated.
Partofthefaiththat's thatisbeinginsisteduponintheOldTestamentissomethinglike, and I'm speakingpsychologicallyhereagainthatit's usefultopauseit.
Ah, hiHi.
Goodday, Matt.
ItsoAnd I reallythinkthat's practicallyusefultotheresearchwe'vedonewithThefutureauthoringprogram, forexample, indicatesprettyclearlythatifyougetpeopletoconceptualizeanidealand a balancedideal, youknow, sowhathewantforyourfamily, whatdoyouwantforyourcareer?
Ifyoureallythinkthatthroughandyoucomeupwithanintegratedidealandyouputitaboveyouassomethingtoreachfor, thenyou'remorecommittedtotheworldin a positiveway, andyou'relesstormentedbyanxietyanduncertainty.
Youcanmake a rationalcaseforadoptingthatstrategyinthat, youknow, youcansay, Well, there's noevidenceforfor a transcendentmoralityorforanultimatemeaning.
Andyoucankindofseeinyourownlifewhenyou'reon a productivepath.
It's sortofinnoblesandenlightensyouor a destructivepath.
And I thinkit's kindofusefultothinkthatmaybethedichotomybetweenthosetwopathsmightberiel, youknow, andbecausethatalsoallowsyoutogivecredencetoyourintuitionsaboutthatsortofthing.
But I don't anyways.
I don't thinkit's unreasonabletopauseitthatsinceyou'realiveadoptingthehighestpossibleregardforthefactthatyou'realiveandthatyou'resurroundedbyothercreaturesthatarealive, I justcan't seehowthatcouldpossiblybeconstruedas a losingstrategy.
Andsothat's thefirst.
Sothat's somethinglikefaith, right?
It's faithit's not.
It's notonlyfaithinyourbeing, butitsfaithinbeingassuch, andthefaithwouldbesomethinglikeifyoucouldorient, you'rebeingproperlythenmaybethatwouldorientyouwithbeingassuch, andyouneverknow, Like, I mean, itmightbetrue.
There's noreasontoassumethatitwouldn't betrue.
I mean, evenifyoujusttake a strictbiologicalperspectiveonthisandthinkaboutusistheproductof 3.5 1,000,000,000 yearsofevolution.
I mean, wehavestruggledoverallthosebillionsofyearstobealiveandtomatchourselveswithrealityandsocause.
Andsoit's notlikeyou'reofferedinstantaneousfinalredemptionIfyoumoveoutforthrightlyintotheworld, establish a faithfulrelationshipwithbeinganattempttoconductyourselfwithintegrity.
Butthenthere's anideathatthere's a realmoutsideofthatwhichis a well, it's aninterestingidea.
It's verysophisticatedidea, I think, ratherthan a simpleidea, it's it's difficulttoknowwhattomakeofit, butitdoesn't reallymatterbecause I thinkregardlessofwhatyourattitudeistowardsthosesortsofthingsintellectually, youstillendupinthesamepositionasJacob, forallintentsandpurposes, practicallyspeaking, because I don't thinkthatthere's anyonewhoatsomepointintheirlife, orperhapseveneveryday, doesn't atsomelevelwrestlewithGodandyoucouldjustcallitwhilethenatureofreality.
I supposeifyouwanttobe, say, reductionistIQaboutit, but I don't thinkitmakesanydifference.
Andsothere's a hinttherethatifyouwanttobe a fullfledgedperson, thatyouhavetomanifest a verylargenumberoftraits.
Andso I wanttogointothatideabit.
Thefirstthing I wanttotalkaboutissomeofthethingsthatwe'velearnedaboutwhathappenstoyouwhenyougoto a newenvironment.
No, there's thisideainverydeepideainclinicalpsychology, a fundamentalidea, whichisthatifsomeone's anxiousaboutsomething, whatyoudoisyou, andit's gettingintheirway.
It's a specialkindofmemory, andyou'repracticingthat.
Sothat's buildingnewskillsforyou.
Andthenbylisteningtothepersonandwatchingyourselfinteract, you'realsogeneratingnewnewabstractinformationthattheneighborsyoutoconceptualizetheworldin a differentway.
Yougettowatchhowtheirhowtheyexpressthemselves, andyougather a corpusofknowledgethatchangesthewayyouperceivethatbroadensyouas a socialagent.
Okay, sothat's twoformsofknowledge.
Butthenthere's 1/3 1 whichisreallyinteresting, whichisthatyouknow, youhave a lotofbiologicalpotential, andit's hardtoknowwhatpotentialis.
Butpartofitisthatyou'recapableofgeneratingproteinsthatyouhaven't beengenerating, soyoushouldgetrightonthat, bytheway, so, Butwhat?
Thewaythatworksinpartisthatifyouputyourselfin a radicallynewsituation, thenyourbrainthattherearegeneticswitchesthatturnonbecauseofthedemandsofthenewsituationthatcodefornewproteins.
ThosearethesamequestionandthehandherewithJosephiswhileyoushouldwear a coatofmanycolors, whichmeansthatyoushouldbeabletogohaveah, drinkinthepubwiththeguyswhoare, youknow, drywallingyouryourhouse.
Andyoushouldbeabletohave a sophisticatedconversationwithsomeonewho's moreeducatedinanabstractwayandthatmaybeyoushouldbeequallycomfortableinbothsituations.
Right?
Becauseyoumightthink, well, there's more.
Oneoftheindicationsthatthere's moretoyouisthatyoucouldbeputmoreplacesandfunctionproperly, andthatwouldbe a goodthinggameat, becausehere's theotherissueisthatyouknowperfectlywellthatthefundamentaltragediesoflifeandyourexposuretomalevolenceinthecourseofthatlife.
Sothosebeingtheworstthings, there's not a lotyoucandototoalterthatfundamentally, becausetheirconditionsofexistence, you'regoingtobesubjecttoyourvulnerability, andyou'regonnabesubjecttomalevolence, That's that.
Sowe'vetalked a littlebit, I think, inthisinthisseriesaboutPinocchio.
Butifwehaven't, itdoesn't matter.
Um, yousee, there's JiminyCricketattheopeningofthePinocchiomovie, pointingto a starwhichisroughlytheNativityStarforallintentsandpurposes.
Andit's a it's a symbolicindicatorofsomethingdiamondlikeandpureright, glimmeringinthedarknessthat's transcendentandabovethehorizonuponwhichtofixyoureyes.
Butthere's nowayyoucanknowthatwithoutdoingitsoAndunlessyouthinkyou'vedone a particularlystellarjobofthat, thenyouhavenoreasontodoubtitspotentialvalidity.
OK, soyouseethestar, thestarRikersas a motifinPinocchio, andoneofthemoreinterestingelementsofithereisthatwhenGiaPetawantstotransformhispuppet, a marionettewho's beingplayedbyforcesthatoperatebehindthescenes, whichisreallygooddefinitionofthepersonafrom a unioneffectiverightandalsosomethingindicativeofsomethinglikeit.
Ideologicalorconceptualpossession.
Japan.
Oh, who's a goodguy?
Ispositive, Fatherfigurereallyliftshis, eventhoughhe's a patriarchalfigure, rightand a verycompetentone.
Hestillevenliveshiseyesuptosomethingthattranscendshismotive, beingpositiveasitis, andwishesthathiscreationwouldundertakethekindoftransformationthatwouldmakeitautonomousandfullyfunctionalas a moralagent.
Nostrings, right?
Sothat's veryinteresting, I think.
Soldier, it's andsaidthesalvationofmankindliesonlyinmakingeverythingtheconcernofallThat's a prettydecentstar, likeGoldLightwouldsay.
AndsowhathappensinthePinocchiostory?
IsthatbecauseAnd I thinkthisis a symbolicrepresentativeofwhat I justdescribedyou, thathappensat a geneticlevelifyouputyourselfinnewsituations.
That's thebluefairyintheInthePinocchiostory, andthat's seemstometobe a symbolicrepresentationofwhathappensbiologicallywhen, whenyousetthegoalproperly, getyourculturebehindyouandmoveintotheworldisthatthere's a biologicaltransformationthatoccurstheconsequenceofthatwhichmeansthat a bunchofyouthathasn't beenturnedonturnson, and I guessonequestionwouldbeisWhatwouldyoubelikeifyouturnedoneverythinginsideofyouthatcouldbeturnedon?
Andyounghadthisideathatyouhad a potentialfutureself, whichwouldbeinpotentialeverythingthatyoucouldbeandthatitmanifestsitselfmomenttomomentinyourpresentlifebymakingyouinterestedinthings.
Someofit's a consequenceoftheirownmoralinadequacy.
Sothey'refools.
AndbutButthethingthat's sointerestingisthatdespitethefactthatthey'refools, they'restillsupposedtogoontheadventureandthatthey'recapableoflearningenoughas a consequenceofmovingforwardontheadventuresothattheystraightenthemselvesoutacrosstime.
What's coolaboutit, though, I think, isthatasyouprogress, thedegreeofovershootingstartstodeclinerightandthatweknowthatthere's nothinghypotheticalaboutthat.
Asyoulearn a newskill, likeeventoplayplay a songonthepiano, forexample, youovershootmadly, youmakingallsortsofmistakestobeginwith, andthenthemistakestheydisappear.
There's a greatTedtalk.
I thinkitwasaboutSkye.
A setup a reallyadvancedcomputationalrecordingsysteminhishomeandrecordedeverysingleutterancehisyoungchildmadewhilelearningtospeak.