Andit's thatyoucannotcannotgetgoodpublicpolicywithout a goodpublictobite.
Anditseemsnowwedon't havedebatesanymore.
Wejusthaveabusiveemotionalmudslinging.
Sothat's thesortofthebackgroundthing.
Butthenwecometothisincredibleopportunitytodaytoengagewiththesetwogentlemenand I wantedtogettheballrollingbytalkingabout a numberofissues, firstly, personalresponsibility.
Then I'd liketomoveontofreedom.
Whatisit?
Becauseit's notlicense.
It's notwhatsomanypeoplethinkitistoday.
Andhowdowemakeitwork?
I didn't wanttotalkaboutcouragebecausewe'regonnaneed a lotofitgoingforwardandyou'regoingtohear a lotordsee, demonstratedsomerealcourage, I thinkhereandwhatwe'regoingtotalkaboutandwhatyou'regoingtohear, whatyou'regoingtowitnessthen a bitaboutsocialmediaandhowwemakeitallworkandthenit's overtoyou.
Welivein a nicewhenitseemsthatthere's a crisisoftrustinourculture.
Well, I certainlywantsomeonelookingintoyouraffairs, but I don't wantanybodylookingintomine.
Well, goodluckwiththatbecause, youknow, tothedegreethat I havesomeoneelectsomeonetolookintoyouraffairstherebloodywell, goingtobelookingintomineaswell.
Andthatjustdoesn't strikemeas a particularlypositivedevelopmentpracticallybecause I don't believeit'llwork.
I don't thinksurveillancestatesdomakepeoplemorehonest.
I thinkalltheevidenceistheopposite.
Andthen I wouldsayfromtheindividualperspective, it's like I believethatthefundamentalwhatwegotfundamentallyrightintheWest, becausethereis a numberofthingswegotfundamentallyright, eventhoughwedon't liketoadmitthatanymoreisthattheultimatemoralresponsibilityforthestatereliesonyou.
Okay, sothat's a decisionthatwe'vemadeintheWest, thateachperson, regardlessoftheirflaws, ischaracterizedby a valueandintrinsicvaluethat's sodeepandsoprofoundthattheveryregulationofthestateitselfrestsontheirshoulders.
Andthat's reallysomething.
That's that's whyyouhavetherighttovote.
Andthat's worththinkingabout.
Thefirstquestionis, Well, doyouthinkthat's a goodideaornot?
I dobelievethatweare, infactsovereignindividuals, andthen, well, let's assumethatyoubelievethatwearebecausethealternativeissomesortofautocracy, right?
It's somesortoftyranny.
It's it's theit's theparsingoffofthatsovereigntyto a bureaucracyortosomearbitraryformofleadership.
That's justthat's thetyrannythatwe'vestruggledagainstintheWestsuccessfullyfor I wouldsay, inonewayoranotherfor, forfor a numberofthousandsofyearsandwith a substantialamountofsuccesstodrawDaveintothis.
Wemetin L.
A.
A coupleofyearsagooverbreakfast.
Dave, you're a greatdefenderofculturetonow.
Whenwemet, itwasveryinteresting.
Yousetoutthereasonsin a wayformetothinkhe's a cardcarryingprogressive.
Andthenyousaidon I'm guymarriedman, andthenyouwentontosay, and I thankGodeveryday.
I liveinChristianAmericaand I thought, That's a surpriseturningtheconversation.
Andwehad a fantasticbreakfasttalkingaboutit, yourdefenderofculturenow, orofourculturalrootsat a timewhentheWestseemstobeitsownworstenemyanddoesn't believeinitsculturalrates.
Andandactuallythatquestioniswhat I believeistheanswerthereis.
Therehasbeen a completeobliterationforyoungpeopletounderstandwhatbeinganindividualis, what, being a personthatownsyourownmind, thatdecidestogetoutthereandlivethelifethey'resupposedtolivethatdoesn't wanttotakefromsomebodyandgivetosomebodyelseorjusttakeforthemselves.
So, toyourquestion, because I amanindividual, thatiswhatledmeherethatthat's, I think, whatledyoutowannahavebreakfastwithmeinLosAngelesthatthedifferenceistheimmutablecharacteristicsthatweeitherhaveincommonorseparateus, whetherit's sexualityorgenderorskincolorarecompletelyirrelevant.
Ifwereallywanttobe a societythatistrulyfreethattrulyrespectseachother, itmakesnodifference.
I mean, I dowhen I gotocolleges, I usuallyjustsingleoutsomebodyinthecrowd, andit's like, Howsadwoulditbeif I justlookedatyou?
And I waslike, Oh, well, you're a whiteguy.
Youlooklikeyou'reinyourearlytwenties, asifthatwouldgivemeanyinclinationthat I wouldhaveanyinsightintowhatyouthinkorhowyoushouldthink, actuallyisthebetterpointbecauseyoushouldthinkwhateveryouthinkandhopefullybewillingtohavethatexchangeofideas.
So I'm veryappreciativethat I livein a Christiancountry, becausethesimplefactis, whilethemediawillimplythatyouknow, everydaythere's anotherstoryonhowevilChristianwhitepeoplearesomethinglikethat.
Andbytheway I seethatspreadingallovertheworldaswell.
I mean, there's there's a weirdthinggoingonwiththemediawhere I thoughtitwasreallyAmerican, crumblingofthemedia.
Butnow I seeitallovertheplace.
Um, I liveinthefreestcountryinthehistoryoftheworld, period.
I mean, wewon't havethisforeverandthatthat's verycleartome.
And I wouldjustaddthisthatDouglasMurraywho I'm sureyou'refamiliarwithintheUKUm, he's alsogay, and I andhe's a brilliantthinker, and I didn't evenwanttoaskhimanythingaboutthatbecauseit's it's completelyirrelevantin a certainway.
Butthelastquestionwhen I hadhimonlasttime, I saidhim, Doyouthinkyoursexualityhas a littlesomethingtodowithyoursensitivityaboutfreedom?
Because, youknow, itmightbeyoufirst.
Andhesaidthathethoughthisskinwas a littlethinnerbecauseofthat.
Andso I dothinkthatpeoplethatareontheoutsideforwhatever, whateverthatis, itdoesn't havetobeSexualitycouldbeobviously a myriadofdifferentissues.
Um, I dothinkyoubecome a littlemoresensitive, sensitivetoit, andforthatreason I'm incredibly I'llgo a stepfurther.
I amblessedthat I liveintheUnitedStatesofAmericaand I cando I can.
I'm a freemaninthefreestcountryever.
And I'm veryappreciativethatyoucanseewhywegeton.
Yeah.
Hi.
Seriously.
Cananyonepushbackagainstthat?
Andyet, half a timewhenyoulistentotheelitetohavetheirhandsontheleversofinfluencetodayyouwouldthinkwelivedincruelandoppressivecultures.
Andwhatcameoutofthat I thinkoftheFrenchRevolution.
ThinkoftheRussianRevolution.
Thinkofthemassrevolutionwhichonehasproduced a reallyunderstandingoftheindividualandsecuretheirfreedoms.
IntegrateawayonwhereinAustralia, ofcourse, areunbelievablyblessedtouseyourwordagainbecausewe'veinheritedwhat's called a washMinsterthebestoftheBritishHouseofCongress.
There's nodoubtthathe's writingshortenedthelifeofthatevilregime, butthebitthatstayedwithme, inwhichyoureferredtoandhavemanytimesyouwrite a greatessayonwhateverChristmas I recommendedtoyou.
Thatwasveryprofoundfor 1,000,000 publiclifewhen I wastellingthesefriendsonthewayoutthat, forexample, youknow a pointthatcametometobequiterealize, a youngfederalmemberofparliamentwasintheoutbacktownofWaldenon a very, veryangryyoungaboriginalmancameuptome.
I mean, I'vethoughtaboutitfordecadesbecauseit's such a remarkablestory.
I thinkhetellsitinthesecondvolumeoftheGulagArchipelagobecauseit's a threevolumebook, fullbook, andit's allworthreading, especiallythesecondvolumeandespeciallythesecondhalf.
Andinthathedetailshistransformation, I wouldsayhispsychologicalorspiritualtransformation.
No, um, hewasontheRussianfront, whichwasnot a pleasantplacetobebecauseStalinhadsigned a pactwithHitlerandHitlerbrokeit, andtheRussianswerecompletelyunprepared.
AndsotobeontheRussianfrontatthebeginningofWorldWartwowas a verybadplacetobe.
Andhewrotelettersto a compatriotiscomplainingaboutthelackofpreparation, andthat's whatgothimthrowninthecamps.
Soifyouwere a SovietsoldierandyouhadgonetotheWestandfoughtandyouwerecapturedandputin a say, a GermanprisonerofwarcampandtreatedterriblybecauseStalindidn't signtheum, agreement.
Andthat's prettyinterestingin a reallydarkway, right, becauseit's like a hellthat's runbythedevils, andtheycouldescapeatanymomentiftheyjustrealizedthattheyweretheonesrunningit.
Andsowhathelearnedwasthatevenunderterriblecircumstances, therewerewaysofbeingmoreorlessnoble, and I supposeitwouldbeunderterriblecircumstanceswherethatsortofthingwouldbeputtothetestanditreallymadehimthinkabouthisownroleinhisowndemise.
Andhedecidedthathewouldgooverhislifewith a finetoothcomb, getnothingbuttimetothinkabouteverytimehehadactedinsomemannerinhislifethattransgressedagainsthisownconsciencerighttherewherehedidsomethingheknewtobewrongandthentoseeifhecouldfigureouthowtosetitrightthenNowobviouslycouldn't necessarilyapologizetothepeopleagainstwhohehadtransgressed, right?
Sometimesyouhavetopayforsomethingyoudidin a currencyotherthanthatwhichyoutookandhisdeterminationwastoochroniclehisexperiencesinhistruthful a manneraspossible, whichwasbasicallyimpossible.
Becausetheotherthing I'venotedanddiscussedwithpeoplefrequentlyisIfyouhavesomeonethatyoulove a child, let's sayandyou'retryingtoraise a childin a decentmanner, youdon't tellthem.
Look, kid, thisishowtheworldruns.
Everything's corruptbeyondbelief, includingyouandyourparentsandandsocietyand a natureforthatmatter.
There's veryinterestingsceneinRevelationsis a verystrangedocumentappendedtotheendoftheprimarybookintheWesterncanonright, andit's a hallucinogenicnightmarerevelation.
Well, I'llliewhenit's inmyfavor, and I'lltellthetruthwhenit's expedientforme, it's likeyou'reyou'reinthecategoryofthedam, and I thinkthat's absolutelyright, becausethat's rielcowardice.
Ifyoubelievedinfalsehood, it's likeGood.
Getonwithit, man.
Youcouldbe a criminalandlayyourlifeoutandseehowthatworks.
Wewelivein a timewithsuchabsurdfreedomsintheWestthataresobeyondimaginationofwhatpeoplecouldonlydreamoftwogenerationsago, evenonegenerationago.
Especiallywiththis, thatpeoplenowhave a perceiveddepressioninsteadof a realdepression.
Sooneofthingsthat I findwhen I gotowhen I gotocollegecampusesisthatyouknow, thesekidswillprotestandthey'llscreamandthatyouknow, thateveryone's allrightandeveryone's neoNaziandtherestofthisand I I alwaysfindAllright, Well, howdoyouHowdoyoubreakthroughtosomebodylikethat?
Howdoyouactuallywhentheyhave, youknow, you'vetalkedaboutthiswhentheyhavethatlookintheireyetruly a possessedlookingandthey'reyouknow, it's thisThispostmodernmonsterhasbecomesortof a secularreligionon I thinkthat's alsooneofthereasonswhywhatJordan's doingisresonatingbecausethey'vetheyremovedreligionfromtheequation, andnowtheyhavenomeaning.
SoButifyoucoulddosomethinglikethat, I mean, ifyousay I meaneveryoneinthisroomcoulddoit, I caneveryonepictureoftheirgrandparents.
Doyouhave a betterorworse?
I mean, doesanyoneinyourhaveitworsethantheirgrandparents.
Andthatshowsyouthatit's a perceiveddepression, not a realoppression, thatthatthethingthatthey'refighting, thispatriarchal, postmoderncapitalisticthingthatthey'refighting, thentheycan't defineit.
Soit's hardtodefineitforthemthatitactuallyhasbenttowardjustice, always, alwaysandwhenwhenyougetit, ifyoucanplantthatseedinthem, I thinkit's a littlebitofsomething, butit's veryhardtobreakthemoutofthat.
But I thinkthekeyhereisunderstandthatit's a perceiveddepression.
Ifyoulivein a freesocietyintheWestin 2019 you'renotoppressedyou.
Ormaybeyou'resickandthey'renotor a seriesofotherthings.
Um, butyou'vegot a chance, andthat's allyou'resupposedtohaveinlife.
And I thinkgettingthatthroughtothem, asopposedtoOh, thesystemishorribleand I havetonowdestroythesystemasiftheycouldmagicallyreconstitute a systemthatreallywouldjustbeineffect, throwingawaythousandsofyearsofhumanhistorythatthey'resowise.
Andthere's a bigdifferencebetweensomethingbeingcompletelysomethingandsomethingbeingpartlysomethingbecauseoneofthethingsyoumightpointoutisthatyoucanlookathumanhistoryanywhere, andwhatyouseeis a completebloodynightmare, right?
Youknow, someabilityofustopullourselvesoutofthemire, youknow, andtheWestisthesameisthere's plentyofcatastropheinourpastofallsorts, and I thinkit's it's necessarytoknowthat.
I thinkyoushouldstartwithyourselfbecause, well, thenyou'reonlyharmingyourself, andyouknowwhat a badpersontopracticeonandthenyoucouldextendthattoyourfatWell, atleastyousufferfortheconsequencesofyourownexperimentsthatway, ratherthanhavingsomeoneelsedoit, andthenmaybeyoucanworkonbringing a littlemoreharmonyintoyourfamily.
Andmaybeyoucanget a jobandseeifyou'reanygoodatthat.
Andthenifyoumanagethosethreethingshalfways, respectably, well, thenyoucoulddaretoput a toeholdoutintothebroadercommunityandthink, maybe I haveanideaherethatwecouldtentativelyattemptThatmightmakesomesmallthingsslightlybetterthatwecouldmeasurecarefullyandassess.
Andthatwouldbeyourcontribution.
Andandmaybeyougetrealgoodatthat, youknow?
Sobythetimeyou're 50 or 60 andyouhave a souloflifebehindyou, you'reactuallycapableofgeneratinglargescaleimprovementscarefully.
Um, youknow, asyouweresayingthat I wasthinking I mean, thisisexactlywhatAlexandriaPicazioCortezis.
I mean, thisis a failedthis a bartenderwith a 4 30 creditscore, whichisprettyterrible, butallshe's everdoneinherlifehasbeen a bartender.
Nowthat's fine.
I'vebeen a bartenderattimes, buttheheronlyaccomplishmentisbecoming a congresswomanwith, I think, around 15,000 votesbysayingtheexactthingthatthethatthemediawantsyoutosayallthetime, right?
Althoughthenshedeletedthatpartandputthat, youknow, it's likeit's thelackofhumilitytherethat's actuallystaggeringthatshethinksnoonebeforehermighthavetriedtomovesomeofthesethingsonthemargins a littlebit, Butshebutthecrazyortheorthatmovingthingsonthemarginsisn't enough.
Well, theydon't believeit's enough, Butthereallycrazypartofthisisthatprettymuch I thinkthefiveorsixDemocraticcandidatesthatwehavenowhaveallbasicallysignedonboardthisthing, thisthing, whichis a I thinkyoucouldprobablyarguethatit's unconstitutionalononthegroundsofIt's justtakingmoreforthegovernment.