I reallylikedyourvideoonFridayaboutsiblingrivalryandcompetition, anditmademethinkaboutparticipation.
Trophiesliketoday's youngpeoplearesometimescalled a participationtrophygeneration, whoexpecttobelavishedwithpraiseforeventhesmallestaccomplishmentsandrewardedforfailure.
Thatkindofpseudocultureofanalysisalwaysoversimplifies, ofcourse, but I feellike I mighthavesomeinsightintoparticipationtrophyculturebecause I had a profoundandliteralexperiencewithitdecadesbefore.
Itwas a thing.
Theyear 1984.
I'm sevenyearsoldand I'm a baseballplayer.
Specifically, I amtheoldestplayeronmyLittleLeague T ballteamand T ball.
Theballhasnotpitched.
Instead, it's placedon a teatomakeiteasiertohit.
Mostkidsmyagehadmovedonfrom T ball, butnotme.
Thethingaboutmychildhoodsportingadventuresisthateventhough I was a terribleathlete, I lovedsportslike I wassopassionateandalsosohopelesslike I wentontoplayformymiddleschoolsoccerteamand I rememberinonegame I cameoffthebenchlikemidwaythroughthefirsthalf, and I wasfeelingreallygoodaboutmyselfbecauseusually I didn't getinuntilwewereupordownbyatleastfivegoals.
Andthenathalftime, thecoachsaid.
Youknowwhy I putGreenon?
Becauseatleasthecares.
I waslike a motivationaltool.
Anyway, backto T ball.
I had a prettygoodseasonthatyearowingtothefactthat I was 123 yearsolderthanallofmyfellowcompetitors.
Andthencametheendofseasonawardsbanquetlikealltheotherkidsthatgot a smallparticipationaward.
Butthentheystartedhandingouttherealtrophies, theonesthatyou'vegot, ifyouwereselectedforthe T BallAllStarteam, which I wasnot.
ShouldanAllstargetinjuredorotherwisebeindisposed, I wouldbecomeanAllStarandifwewontheAllStarGame, I wouldget a trophy.
Therewasonlyoneproblem.
OurfamilywasscheduledtobeoutoftownduringtheAllStarGame, visitingmygrandparent's, whichclearlyneededtoberescheduledbecause I wasanalternatefortheAllStarteam.
Theywerecountingonme.
Whatif I arguedtomyparents, oneoftheAllStarscontracts, Chickenpox?
OristhealternategoingtogointotheAllStargame, hitthewinning a homerunandget a trophy?
Eventually, myparentssettledon a solution.
Wewouldstillgovisitmygrandparentsand I wouldmisstheAllStargame.
But I wouldget a trophytobeprecise.
Myparentswenttothetrophystoreandhad a trophymadeforme.
Thatsaid, JohnGreen, 1984 allstarinourhearts.
I mean, it's theultimateparticipationtrophy.
Notonlydid I notearnit, myparentspaidforit, so I wouldfeellike a winner, eventhough I wasnot a winner.
Sohowdidthisexperienceaffectme?
Yeah, I don't know.
I think I turnedoutmostly.
Okay.
Myparentsalwayspraisedmyeffortmuchmorethanmyachievements, likeevennowwhensomethingnicehappenstooneofmybooks, mymomismuchmorelikelytosay, I knowyouworkedreallyhardonthatstorythancongratulationsonwinningthataward.
I thinktheAllStarinourheartstrophywasanextensionofthat, andforawhile I wasreallyproudofit.
I mean, I hadalmostbeenanAllStar, andthenitbecame a funnystorytotellbecausehetalkedaboutonFriday.
Peopleaskusallthetimeifwe'recompetitiveasbrothersandweareinthesensethatwhenweplaysportsorboardgames, I definitelywannawin.