Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • - Well, let me talk about why we have bullshit jobs.

  • We have this extraordinary fixation with work

  • and yet with every technological revolution we've had,

  • more people have gone out of work,

  • and we've been very resourceful

  • and very creative in terms of creating jobs

  • and things for them to do.

  • Most of us work in this great amorphous blob of a thing

  • called the services sector.

  • Within that services sector space,

  • there's an awful lot of work

  • which I think is work we've simply created

  • because we feel that humans cannot live

  • without organized work,

  • and also 'cause we organize our societies on that basis.

  • Certainly now in these societies based on fossil fuels

  • and ever more productive machines,

  • there actually isn't a lot of very good work

  • for everybody to do, yet we insist on full employment,

  • and it is a product of the fact that we are doing work

  • just for work's sake.

  • And these jobs are fundamentally, in many senses, bullshit.

  • Ever since people first worked out

  • how to convert energy stored in fossil fuels into work,

  • putting it through machines

  • that translate that steam into turning engines and turbines,

  • they have imagined a world in which technology,

  • in which external energy use spares us from future labor.

  • From Benjamin Franklin all the way through

  • to the early 20th century,

  • thinkers and dreamers alike all articulated visions

  • of this kind of post-work world,

  • but nobody did this better than John Maynard Keynes.

  • He was, of course, the man who transformed economics.

  • And in 1930, John Maynard Keynes wrote an essay

  • called the "Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren".

  • And in that essay, he decided to take wings into the future,

  • to go out of miseries of this depression

  • that everybody was enduring

  • and imagine what the economic world would look like

  • 100 years in the future.

  • In this essay, he famously predicted that by 2030,

  • by more or less now,

  • we'd be working no more than 15 hours in a week.

  • Why would we do this?

  • He said that based on calculations of productivity

  • and capital growth and technological advancements,

  • he believed that we would have come to an economic utopia,

  • where everybody's basic needs would be very easily met.

  • Now, interestingly enough, we passed the thresholds

  • that Keynes identified

  • and thought would only reach about now.

  • We passed those thresholds in 1980,

  • yet still, interestingly enough,

  • we continue to work pretty much the same number of hours

  • that people did back in 1930 when Keynes was alive.

  • Now if you ask them economist why do we work,

  • they will say, "Ah, it is to solve the economic problem."

  • What is the economic problem?

  • They will say, "The economic problem

  • is the problem of scarcity."

  • And then you'll say, "Well what the hell

  • is the problem of scarcity?"

  • And they'll say, "The problem of scarcity is this-

  • it is simple."

  • In the olden days, when we were hunters and gatherers,

  • we endured this horrendous struggle for survival

  • in an eat-or-be-eaten world,

  • and the transition to farming,

  • of course, changed everything.

  • The societies that developed agriculture

  • became considerably more productive than the societies

  • that were still living a life of foraging.

  • And as a result of that, we evolved,

  • we became hardwired to have this infinite need.

  • Having enough food today was simply a trigger

  • to worry about having more for tomorrow,

  • so we became accumulators, surplus creators.

  • In other words, because it was evolutionary advantageous,

  • we developed infinite needs.

  • There's no debating the fact

  • that this extraordinary work ethic

  • that was instilled into us

  • has brought us unbelievable benefits.

  • We're now at a point in human history

  • where we have an economy where we are so productive,

  • we've conquered scarcity.

  • More food goes into landfill than in our bellies every year.

  • We are living in an era of untold affluence,

  • yet very strangely we continue to organize our economies

  • as if we're farmers risking going hungry.

  • So is it a question of culture?

  • Is the reason that we continue to work as we do

  • simply because we've hung onto culture,

  • and we've all bound into these different institutions?

  • When Keynes predicted the economic utopia that he imagined,

  • he argued that there was only one real obstacle

  • to achieving that,

  • and he described that as our instinct to work,

  • our instinct that had been forged at the fires of evolution.

  • But there's a real concern that the very medicine

  • that brought us this extraordinary prosperity is now likely

  • to make the patient sick.

  • It could well be that Keynes would look at us now

  • and say, "Take it easy, chaps."

  • This is part of the process towards change.

  • So we have these vast convoluted processes

  • of people doing bullshit jobs of incredible complexity,

  • but for no apparent purpose.

  • There is a definite appetite

  • for doing things differently, for experimenting.

  • Suddenly now in the United States,

  • only 50% of people polled are interested

  • in something like universal basic income,

  • and recognize that there is a certain hollowness

  • to the narrative behind the American dream

  • quite simply because the economy is not organized

  • in those terms anymore.

  • If everybody's basic needs are met,

  • which was the Keynesian dream

  • in terms of his economic utopia,

  • how might that affect our behavior in other ways?

  • As we all learnt in lockdown in our confinement,

  • we became an amateur artist, we became amateur cooks,

  • we became amateur bakers.

  • We are a species that likes to do work,

  • and I can imagine a world

  • where we might end up all doing the work we love

  • instead of doing some crappy job that we don't want to do.

  • And a world in which everybody did what they want

  • would be a world that is much richer

  • and much more productive

  • in the things that actually matter to most people.

  • - Get smarter faster every week with new videos

  • from the world's biggest thinkers.

- Well, let me talk about why we have bullshit jobs.

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it