Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • - There's been a general decline in marriage-

  • but behind that general decline is a more interesting story.

  • I think it's important we try to understand

  • why people do get married in the first place.

  • For some people, of course, it's a religious matter-

  • it's a covenantal relationship.

  • I think for many more people

  • there's an economic element to it.

  • There's obviously the companionship and love.

  • You fall in love and want to spend

  • the rest of your life with someone,

  • and so there's a romantic element to marriage.

  • And another reason was because they got pregnant,

  • the so-called, "shotgun wedding."

  • There was a sense that if you were bringing a new life

  • into the world, that that should be done within marriage.

  • And there's probably a bit of status signaling to sometimes,

  • and this may be more true today than it was in the past,

  • that being married is a way

  • of signaling success and status within a society.

  • And so there's a blend

  • of reasons between religion, romance, economics

  • and status that have traditionally led people

  • to the marital state.

  • The old model of marriage was, for the woman,

  • it was an economic necessity

  • particularly if she was gonna have children;

  • to be with a man who would be the provider.

  • And obviously that has hugely changed now.

  • And for the man, it was a way to attach himself to children.

  • If he was gonna have children

  • he had to do that with a woman.

  • She was going to raise the children,

  • but if she was doing that, he had to provide for them too.

  • And so there was this complementarity

  • to that traditional view of marriage,

  • which of course was founded

  • on a very deep inequality between men and women.

  • That was a driving force-

  • the women's movement, including people, like Gloria Steinem,

  • saying the point is to make marriage

  • into a choice rather than a necessity,

  • and to actually free women from the economic bondage,

  • as they would've put it, of marriage.

  • And that inequality is what's been successfully

  • shattered, gladly, by the women's movement.

  • - 'All of us must stand up together and say no more.'

  • - The very institution of marriage,

  • which is central to human societies,

  • has been fundamentally transformed.

  • It's one engaged into, in very egalitarian principles;

  • women have huge exit power.

  • I think it's important to know

  • that women are twice as likely as men to file for divorce.

  • So women are using exit power from marriage,

  • they're not stuck in bad marriages anymore-

  • which is a huge achievement for humanity.

  • But for men, of course, the old role of,

  • "Well, I'll just provide while you raise the kids,"

  • that's out of the window too.

  • And so men's role in marriage

  • and what it means to be "marriageable,"

  • to use a slightly ugly term from social science,

  • is very different now for men from what it was in the past.

  • And women are looking

  • for something much more than just a paycheck.

  • It's a bit like the kaleidoscope has been shaken,

  • and the patterns haven't quite settled yet.

  • You see lesbian and gay couples

  • being able to opt into marriage.

  • Within a couple of years of the Supreme Court Decision,

  • we saw most three outta five lesbian

  • and gay couples choosing to get married.

  • You see a big class gap opening up: fewer working class

  • and lower income Americans opting into the institution.

  • What we have is what my colleague Isabel Sawhill calls:

  • "One of the main class fractures in American society."

  • No one expected that it was Americans

  • with the most choice and the most economic power,

  • and especially the American women

  • with the most choice and economic power,

  • who would be the ones who were continuing to get married

  • and stay married.

  • There's a very slight decline for those say

  • with four-year college degrees, but a really big decline

  • for those with, with less education.

  • The typical college-educated American woman

  • is almost as likely to get married as her mother was,

  • and if anything, a little bit more likely to stay married

  • than her mother was.

  • So, there really hasn't been much of a decline

  • in marriage at all in the top ranks of American society.

  • Meanwhile, significant declines lower down.

  • One of the other big changes has been

  • a significant shift up in the age of first marriage,

  • up to closer to 30 now.

  • And I think about my parents who married

  • at 21 having met at 17-pretty common.

  • And actually as late as 1970, most women who went to college

  • in the U.S., which was a minority of course,

  • but most of them were married

  • within a year of graduating college.

  • That's a world that's very difficult to fathom now;

  • where both men and women are entering the labor market,

  • they're becoming economically successful,

  • they're establishing themselves.

  • In some ways, you do all that first, then you marry.

  • And so, marriage has become more like the capstone.

  • Increasingly, marriage is a signal of everything

  • that has led up to the ceremony,

  • rather than the beginning of a journey.

  • It's as much the end of a journey

  • to a position where people feel they can get married now.

  • We can't tell a single story about marriage

  • in America anymore in the way we could just 40 years ago.

  • We have to tell different stories based

  • on class and race and geography.

  • We've seen this real divide opening up

  • in marriage in the U.S.

  • Americans, now, are much less likely to see marriage

  • as something that you have to do to

  • to be a complete person or have a good life.

  • Only 1 in 10 Americans now believe

  • that it's essential to be married

  • to have a fulfilling life.

  • That's a huge cultural change.

  • I think what we can safely say is that the model

  • of marriage that was founded on economic dependency

  • of women on men, is completely obsolete.

  • Now, I think we've created models of the family

  • that are much more equal and much fairer,

  • but maybe not quite as stable in many cases too.

  • And the challenge we all face is to find ways

  • to create more stability in our family life,

  • but without sacrificing the goal of equality,

  • which has animated the movement of the last 50 years.

  • I think what we should be looking to is,

  • how do we have strong relationships

  • within which people can raise kids well?

  • And if marriage has a part to play in that, then great.

  • But there are alternative models

  • around civil partnerships and so on, too.

  • What matters is parenting.

  • What matters is how we raise our kids.

  • And I do think that there-

  • it's quite possible to imagine a renewed future for marriage

  • based around egalitarianism between men and women,

  • but a shared commitment to kids-

  • but I think that's for us to create.

  • If marriage is to survive, it will be in a new model,

  • not a restoration of the old model.

  • - Get smarter, faster with videos

  • from the world's biggest thinkers.

  • And to learn even more from the world's biggest thinkers,

  • get Big Think+ for your business.

- There's been a general decline in marriage-

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it