Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • I gotta go to town in a little bit and pick some things up.

  • Oh, I can go. I'm not doing anything today.

  • Why don't we go together?

  • Luca Guadagnino's coming-of-age romance Call Me By Your Name operates invisibly.

  • The film is visually striking, for sure, but in every aspect, it really excels in its sensuality and subtlety.

  • Look at how people walk downstairs in Call Me By Your Name.

  • Why did Oliver just touch that wall?

  • Why are we now shown him dusting off his bike?

  • Why is Elio touching his hair so much?

  • Why does his hand linger so painfully on this rail?

  • On page 4 of the Call Me By Your Name screenplay, the film's screenwriter James Ivory gives the simple direction Oliver is coming down the stairs.

  • On page 10, he cuts straight from should we take Anchisa's bikes to Elio and Oliver are riding bicycles.

  • But when director Luca Guadagnino gets on set, he puts into practice a lesson drilled into him by the legendary Italian film director Bernardo Bertolucci.

  • And he said, Luca, you're so naive.

  • Scripts, they don't count.

  • You have to throw the script when you start the movie.

  • And I took the lesson by the letter.

  • Part of a film director's job on set is to direct performances and determine the blocking of the scene, the movement of actors within the space.

  • So every chance he gets, Luca Guadagnino emphasises the tactile nature of this world.

  • In this scene, Guadagnino directs Armie Hammer to curiously feel out the texture of the wall and all of a sudden this house is given an extra tactile dimension.

  • Let's now re-edit the bike scene to show how Ivory wrote it in the screenplay.

  • Should I give him Anchisa's bike?

  • And now as Guadagnino directed it.

  • Should I give him Anchisa's bike?

  • Should I give him Anchisa's bike?

  • It's not much, but now whenever you see them riding, you can feel your own hands on the handlebars and really place yourself on that bike.

  • Directed as it is, the world becomes not just a beautiful thing to see with your eyes, but a place you can touch, feel and linger upon.

  • Let's jump forward a little to page 19 in the screenplay and watch the scene at the same time.

  • Anchisa approaches Elio, carrying a large fish wrapped up in a t-shirt which he uncovers for Elio.

  • Let's pause here.

  • In this script, Anchisa takes the fish straight to the kitchen.

  • But remember, as soon as Guadagnino gets on set, he throws this script into the fiery pits of hell.

  • So he decides to create a few more actions which add to Elio's character and emphasise yet another important sense.

  • This film sounds incredible.

  • Notice particularly how it makes the house a character of its own.

  • Listen to the knock on this door and you can feel its weight.

  • Now listen to the silence.

  • And listen to how this book cuts it like a knife echoing throughout the house.

  • Listen to this bell, how loud and crisp it is.

  • And now listen to that sound barely reaching Elio's room.

  • With just this difference in sound, you can feel the size and emptiness of the house.

  • Guadagnino also places a heavy emphasis on taste.

  • There is a lot of eating in this movie and most of it is not sexual but simply epicurean in nature for the simple purpose of sensual enjoyment.

  • But of course there is the peach scene.

  • You need look no further than this simple question from T.S. Eliot's classic poem

  • The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock.

  • Do I dare to eat a peach?

  • But in Call Me By Your Name, Guadagnino combines the natural taste of the fruit with the taste of a slightly more sexual substance.

  • The question of daring thus becomes the question of daring to eat a peach.

  • The question of daring thus becomes sexual in nature.

  • But it's not something you just think about or intellectualise.

  • It's something you can disgustingly almost taste on the screen.

  • Do I dare to eat a peach?

  • And finally notice how the film smells.

  • There's this obvious example.

  • Elio is really enjoying himself in there.

  • But notice that this theme of dirty used clothing runs throughout the film.

  • This is what Guadagnino lets us smell after they have sex.

  • And immediately after we're treated to this.

  • I don't know that much about lakes but listen to the mosquitoes.

  • This lake you can definitely smell.

  • But let's return to the lyrics of Sufjan Stevens which I used to open this video.

  • This quote talks about a paradoxical clarity that comes through lack of vision.

  • By focusing on the invisible one can truthfully feel an experience rather than seeing and intellectualising it.

  • And I think this philosophy is also true for the film's story.

  • It took Call Me By Your Name almost 10 years to find funding and get made because there was no obvious antagonist or even conflict.

  • In fact the world of this film is a utopia.

  • Elio lives in the most beautiful house in the most picturesque town.

  • He is fed wonderful food every day.

  • He spends his time swimming in lakes and pools, writing and transcribing music.

  • At night they go out dancing and there are girls all over him.

  • It's perfect.

  • And in any other gay romance it would be so easy to create conflict within the story by bringing in obvious homophobia.

  • But Call Me By Your Name steers clear of this cliché.

  • In fact it pushes it in the opposite direction.

  • Gay couples are shown to be friends in this world and Mr Perlman explicitly denounces homophobia.

  • When I tell you to play, you'll play.

  • You're too old not to accept people for who they are.

  • What's wrong with them?

  • What's wrong with them?

  • You call them Sonny and Cher behind their backs?

  • This is an idealistic scenario for kids growing up in the 2020s, let alone the 1980s.

  • You could not wish for a better environment to fall in love with someone.

  • This is utopia.

  • But then we get this scene which finally brings to light the film's conflicts which until this point have been invisible.

  • I may have come close but I never had what you two have.

  • Something always held me back or stood in the way.

  • How you live your life is your business.

  • Just remember our hearts and our bodies are given to us only once.

  • And before you know it your heart's worn out.

  • And as for your body, there comes a point when no one looks at it.

  • Much less wants to come near it.

  • Luca Guadagnino has said that the antagonist of this film is time.

  • In fact, Mr Perlman's monologue echoes the words of Elio himself just before he leaves with Oliver.

  • God, we wasted so many days.

  • Why didn't you give me a sign?

  • I did.

  • You didn't give me a sign.

  • I did.

  • When it went.

  • When watching the film you kind of forget about the fact that Oliver's presence is temporary.

  • In other words, the antagonistic force of time is invisible and so his departure sneaks up on us.

  • We're just as shocked as Elio when it happens.

  • But I don't think time is the true antagonist in this film.

  • Oliver could easily come back to Crema next year.

  • In fact, in the books he does.

  • But in the film there's one thing stopping him and Elio correctly guesses it before Oliver even mentions anything about it.

  • Oh, you're getting married?

  • I suppose.

  • I might be getting married next spring.

  • In his monologue, Mr Perlman hints that he also had an experience like Elio's.

  • But he says,

  • Something always held me back or stood in the way.

  • This line is split into internal and external elements.

  • The internal element I always saw as that fear and anxiety that anyone would have when approaching love.

  • But there's also that external element.

  • Something always stood in the way.

  • And for both Elio and his father, that is mostly heteronormative society which creates an invisible anxiety towards same-sex relationships.

  • It's such a pervasive anxiety that Mr Perlman can't even tell his wife about it.

  • Does mom know?

  • I don't think she does.

  • Like Elio, Mr Perlman has the perfect life.

  • He has a perfect house in the most beautiful town with the most extraordinary occupation.

  • But ultimately he has the most beautiful, intelligent and empathetic wife.

  • While watching the film, we see their marriage as the perfect ideal relationship.

  • And so when Mr Perlman reveals that this supposedly utopian marriage is in fact built on a lie, the illusion is broken and we are left with immense tragedy.

  • Look here, for example, at the subtlety of Stuhlberg's performance in this scene when he finds out Oliver is getting married.

  • Pay attention to his long, drawn-in breath before his response and the knowing way he looks at his wife afterwards.

  • Well, speaking of which, I'm trying to tell you guys I got engaged.

  • Ah, wonderful!

  • Congratulations, Oliver.

  • Listen, we'll leave you, we'll let you speak to Elio.

  • Happy Hanukkah!

  • Happy Hanukkah!

  • Mr Perlman says congratulations, but inside he feels just like Elio, longing for the heat of an ephemeral summer that can never again exist.

  • Yes, heat.

  • In this final shot, Elio isn't telling us that he longs for that summer again.

  • We can feel it.

  • We can feel the heat of the fire reflected on his tear-streaked face.

  • And we are reminded of that heat.

  • The sweltering heat of the bus.

  • The heat of the sun beating down on us as we ride into the distance.

  • The heat that makes water taste like air.

  • The heat that sets dreams on fire.

  • Open your eyes and you will see Elio sitting in front of a fire.

  • But I entreat you to close them.

  • And now, you will see without your eyes the first time that you kissed me, boundless by the time I cried.

  • The first time that you kissed me, boundless by the time I cried.

  • This is the second video I've ever made on this channel.

  • The first was a review of a Netflix teen drama show, Young Royals, and this is a bit of a departure from that.

  • Call Me By Her Name is just a bit too beautiful, and I was inspired by video essayists like The Nerdwriter and Tony Zhu to create something a little more poetic for this week.

  • For my next video though, I think I will return to a more casual style and review an up-and-coming or a new film or show.

  • But as I said, this is my second video, so I'm still just experimenting and trying things out.

  • If you want to join me on this creative journey, then make sure you're subscribed to the channel.

  • I also do want to give a big thank you to not only everyone who subscribed after my last video, but everyone who reached out to me on Instagram, Twitter.

  • In particular, I do want to thank this Instagram user, MagnetsAreCool.

  • That's their Instagram username.

  • And after I posted a TikTok about all of this sensory stuff in Call Me By Her Name, they came up with this connection between that and the Sufjan Stevens song, which I then used, obviously, to a large extent in this video.

  • So a big thank you to them.

  • And of course, if you do want to talk about anything, then all the links to my socials are in the description.

  • So once again, thank you for watching.

  • Thanks for being part of this journey.

  • And I can't wait to see you in the next video.

  • Bye.

I gotta go to town in a little bit and pick some things up.

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it