Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • The stereotypical Asian eye - the ones that are small, slanted and often with a monolid.

  • These can only be seen in Asians.

  • (Wrong!)

  • Ok, not exactly true.

  • Just like how there are Asian people who have larger, non-squinty eyes

  • there also exist white people or black people who do have these squinty Asiatic eyes.

  • But just how common is it among non-Asian people, and why do they even have it?

  • In this video, I'll get into the different countries and ethnic groups from all over the world

  • that you may not expect to have this characteristic

  • as well as examples from some well-known faces.

  • First, let's start at ground zero.

  • Let's start in East Asia where these stereotypical Asian eyes are at its highest frequency.

  • A big reason why these eyes appear this way, is due to a skin fold, on the edge

  • of the upper eyelid that extends to the inner corner of the eye.

  • This is called the epicanthic fold.

  • Up to 90% of East Asians have this to varying degrees, but for non-Asians

  • this occurs only 2 to 5% of the time.

  • It is these individuals who are often cited as having 'Asian-looking eyes'

  • despite not being Asian at all.

  • By the way, having epicanthic folds doesn't necessarily mean you have a monolid.

  • Actually I've already covered all this in a previous video where I break down the different

  • characteristics of Asian eyes.

  • If you want to check that out, the link is in the description below.

  • Now, along with the epicanthic fold, individuals may also have flatter nose bridges,

  • minimal brow ridges, and wider cheekbones.

  • Some may not have all of these traits, or not to the same degree,

  • but they tend to reinforce each other visually, to create that distinctive East Asian look

  • whether you're Asian or not.

  • As you get further away from East Asia, naturally these characteristics are less common.

  • Which is why it may be surprising when so called 'Asian eyes' pop up far away

  • in unexpected populations.

  • We'll divide these instances into five very different groups

  • with each one being more unexpected than the last.

  • Starting with the first one, we have the Polynesians.

  • Polynesia is a subregion of Oceania made up of over 1,000 islands

  • scattered over the central and southern Pacific Ocean.

  • The indigenous people who inhabit these islands are called Polynesians.

  • So that includes the native people of Samoa, Tonga, French Polynesia, Hawaii, New Zealand,

  • and more.

  • Here are examples of Polynesians who exhibit some form of East Asiatic eyes.

  • Not all Polynesians have these eyes, but given the distance from East Asia

  • they do pop up more frequently than some might expect.

  • Even The Rock, who is only half Samoan, has a faint epicanthic fold.

  • Now you might be thinking it's not particularly surprising that some Polynesians have this,

  • seeing as thousands of years ago, the then uninhabited Polynesian islands

  • were settled by seafarers who originated from East Asia, but...

  • You would expect the further away you get from East Asia, the less common it would be.

  • This is the route they took starting from Southwestern China about 8,000 years ago.

  • Heading over to Taiwan first - this is where the Taiwanese aboriginals came from

  • They made there way to the Philippines, Eastern Indonesia, through Melanesia, and finally Polynesia.

  • This all took place over thousands of years.

  • What seems odd is this.

  • Polynesians have a much higher frequency of these eyes, than Melanesians

  • even though they passed through that region on their way to Polynesia.

  • This is confirmed by DNA analysis, with Polynesians having a strong genetic link to East Asians,

  • but not much at all with Melanesians.

  • Turns out, most Melanesian people, just like the Aboriginals of Australia

  • came to the region much earlier, through a very different human migratory route

  • and have therefore evolved quite distinctively from East Asians and Polynesians.

  • Add to that the Polynesian ancestors that passed through Melanesia did so fairly quick,

  • with only limited contact with the natives.

  • Now, onto the next group of people. We have the Indigenous Americans.

  • These are the pre-Columbian peoples of the Americas.

  • North, Central and South America.

  • Aside from East and Southeast Asians, it is the Indigenous Americans

  • who have the highest frequency of epicanthic folds in the world.

  • The reason for this goes back 20,000 years ago, during the last ice age

  • or I'll say the last glacial maximum.

  • The sea levels were a lot lower, resulting in a land bridge spanning the Bering Strait

  • that connected Northeast Asia with Northwest North America.

  • This allowed people from Siberia to cross over to Alaska;

  • then eventually Canada and beyond.

  • These are the ancestors of today's indigenous people and are the reason for any shared characteristics.

  • It does seem as though the further North you go, the more likely it is for the native populations

  • and tribes to have these Asiatic features.

  • And this is connected to the fact that this wasn't the only migration wave from Asia.

  • There was a second more recent wave, which resulted in the ancestors of today's Inuit people

  • as well as several other North American indigenous groups.

  • Today, they live primarily in the Arctic regions of Alaska, Canada and Greenland.

  • Since these communities came later on

  • having spent more time adapting biologically to East Asian conditions

  • before crossing over to the Americas

  • they tend to end up looking more East Asian than their southern counterparts.

  • Ok, now let's talk about white people.

  • The next one is Eastern Europeans.

  • The typical European eye tends to be larger, more horizontal or even downturned

  • and with multiple lids.

  • With no epicanthic fold, the inner corner of the eye is fully exposed

  • this is generally hidden for individuals with heavy epicanthic folds.

  • It's perhaps not too surprising that there are people from countries or regions like

  • Western Russia, Estonia, Lithuania, Poland, Ukraine, Hungary, Romania and Bulgaria

  • that can have more Asiatic features, due to the proximity to Asia.

  • These Eastern European nations have historically been in contact with various

  • Central and East Asian peoples through war and conquest.

  • Likewise, you can find many people from Western Asia, and actually Northern and Central Asia as well

  • looking like this, this or this.

  • In the 13th century, there was a huge influx of East Asian DNA into Europe in the form of the Mongol Army.

  • In fact, Genghis Khan - actually pronounced Chingis Khan

  • founder and great ruler of the Mongol Empire

  • is considered to be one of the most prolific men in human history,

  • with over 16 million individuals worldwide being able to claim a genetic link to his line

  • That's 0.5% of the world's male population.

  • So perhaps the next unexpected group can also be largely explained by the Mongol invasions.

  • Or can it?

  • This is the one that most people have been asking me about, the Northern Europeans.

  • You might have noticed East Asian eyes - or some variant of it - popping up in places like

  • Norway, Sweden, Finland and Northwest Russia.

  • People in Ireland and Scotland have also been found to have these traits.

  • Actually we can broadly say once again, that the further North you go,

  • the more Asiatic the eyes can get.

  • Certainly down south near the Mediterranean they appear much larger.

  • Although just to be clear I'm not claiming that it is rampant in Northern Europe.

  • Over there, it's still often considered quite unique and distinctive, though depending on the region.

  • There are many professional Scandinavian models with this combination of classic Northern European traits

  • with Asiatic eyes.

  • There are also well-known celebrities like Emma Stone, Michelle Williams and Renee Zellweger

  • all with nordic ancestry.

  • Although it's quite sad to see Renee Zellweger rid herself of those distinctive eyes in favour

  • of the more traditional European set.

  • Personally, I thought she looked much better before, but anyway.

  • You may have noticed that some of the last few examples differ from the classic epicanthic fold look.

  • Their eyes appear more hooded, with a somewhat swollen excess of skin

  • hanging from areas closer to the brow.

  • I know the way I just described that didn't sound all that attractive, but far from it,

  • they can look very appealing.

  • These are called 'hooded eyes', and while they are not so common among East Asian people,

  • they do seem related to epicanthic folds in a genetic and evolutionary sense,

  • but more on that later.

  • Now back to the Mongol Empire - could this be the explanation for the Northern European countries?

  • The Y-chromosome DNA haplogroup, C-M217 is found at high frequencies among Mongolians

  • and many indigenous Far East populations.

  • Here's a distribution map of the spread of the C-M217.

  • Here, we can see how it's very-well possible for people from Eastern European countries

  • to exhibit these features - to have this sort of genetic variance.

  • By the way this right here, is somewhat typical of eastern European populations.

  • That approximate 2% for Northeast Asian DNA is enough to result in the occasional epicanthic folds.

  • But this spread does not explain what we see in the Northern European countries where

  • Northeast Asian DNA is actually higher than 2%.

  • Take Finland for example.

  • At 7%, Finns have the highest percentage of East Asian genes of any European population.

  • Interestingly enough, they also have the highest percentage of blonde-haired blue eyed individuals.

  • So how did this East Asian DNA get into the population?

  • Well, it was likely through the reindeer herding indigenous people of Scandinavia called

  • themi people

  • They have inhabited the Arctic regions of Norway, Sweden, Finland and the Kola Peninsula of Russia

  • for at least 5,000 years.

  • The genetic lineage of themi is quite unique and shows

  • that they are descended from multiple populations at various times, including European and Asian ancestry.

  • About 19,000 years ago, their Asian ancestors migrated in a counter-clockwise path from

  • Southeast Asia, to China and Mongolia.

  • Then about 11,000 years ago they followed the receding glaciers westerly

  • to Northern Europe as new land opened up for settlement.

  • This explains what we see in their features today.

  • Moving on to the British Isles.

  • People have noted somewhat Asiatic eyes in some English, Scottish and especially Irish people.

  • Remember, having these eyes alone won't always give that satisfactory East Asian look.

  • It's often a variety of traits - which I've already mentioned

  • that tend to reinforce each other visually.

  • Most of these examples only have it in the eyes.

  • And some much stronger than others.

  • Now, you'll see that epicanthic folds are often paired with hooded lids

  • although they can appear separately as well.

  • Take a look at Jennifer Lawrence who is of English, Scottish and Irish ancestry.

  • She has the hooded eyes, as well as what looks to be a faint epicanthic fold.

  • Then there's JFK - who's mostly of Irish descent.

  • He has a version of the epicanthic fold that reaches the outer corner of the eye.

  • This tends to be pretty common for non-Asian epicanthic folds.

  • East Asians have the ones that reach the inner corner of the eye.

  • There are also reported cases way out in Iceland.

  • Björk is the best example of that.

  • She claims to be 100% Icelandic, but then look at those heavy epicanthic folds.

  • Unlike the other groups I've mentioned, Britain, Ireland and Iceland are a lot more difficult to explain

  • Certainly there isn't enough genetic evidence to conclude one way or another.

  • Some have said though, that the Celtic forefathers of the region developed the eye folds after

  • mingling with people in parts of Asia near the Caucasus Mountains

  • before beginning their migration westward.

  • Ireland and Britain's remote geographical position in comparison to the rest of Europe

  • meant that the gene-pool thereafter, would have been less susceptible to change.

  • Or perhaps you can thank the Vikings for it.

  • Maybe these Nordic seafarers - having interbred with themi people up North

  • brought over this trait, when they established the Kingdoms in Scotland,

  • and cities such as Belfast and Dublin in Ireland a thousand years ago.

  • The recorded history of Iceland also began with the settlement of Viking explorers and their slaves

  • Their activities extended as far Greenland and the North American coastline, which leads to another theory

  • that Vikings who came in contact with the Indigenous American tribes like the Inuits,

  • brought their DNA back with them when they returned home.

  • Ok, so that was Europe and now onto the final group. Southern Africans.

  • This one's particularly unexpected because of the distance from East Asia.

  • Let's look at Madagascar first.

  • Here, there are the Malagasy People who make up over 90% of the population.

  • They have a high frequency of epicanthic folds

  • and as you can see here

  • the Northeast and Southeast Asian DNA is of a significant amount.

  • But how could this be?

  • Remember those ancient East Asians who crossed over to Taiwan 8000 years ago

  • before making their way to Polynesia?

  • Well, they had related groups that branched off midway, from Indonesia

  • in a quest to explore the Indian Ocean.

  • Eventually they ended up all the way in Madagascar by 500AD, and have remained there ever since.

  • Moving on over to the African mainland however, things aren't as easily explained.

  • There are the Nilotic people - indigenous to the Nile Valley

  • living in countries like South Sudan, Uganda, Kenya and Tanzania.

  • They have been known to exhibit epicanthic folds

  • but it's often the Khoisan people in and around the Kalahari Desert in South Africa, Namibia and Botswana

  • who are the most famous examples of 'Africans with 'Asian eyes'.

  • Although perhaps we shouldn't really say that since there is in fact no relation to East Asians

  • if we look at their genetic markers.

  • This is unlike any of our previous examples.

  • The Khoisan represent a population historically - and on many levels - genetically distinct

  • from even other Africans.

  • They possess some of the oldest DNA lineages out there, and may have been one of the first

  • populations to differentiate from the most recent common paternal ancestor of all humans today

  • So East Asian DNA isn't the reason for their eyes.

  • It's something else.

  • To understand why they still developed these features, we have to step back

  • back to the evolutionary origins of the so-called Asian Eye.

  • How did many East Asian people evolve to seemingly have smaller and slanted eyes in the first place?

  • What caused epicanthic folds?

  • And could this give us insight into how some Southern Africans

  • with no migratory and genetic connection to East Asia, developed the same set of traits?

  • I will be answering this in a future video so make sure you're subscribed to get that.

  • But if you want to find out what kind of Asian eyes you have, grab a mirror

  • and click the video on top

  • otherwise click the one below if you prefer something else.

  • I hope you enjoyed this topic, and if you have any questions or thoughts

  • let us know down below.

  • Thanks for watching, hit that like button, and stay tuned for more interesting 'Asiany' videos.

The stereotypical Asian eye - the ones that are small, slanted and often with a monolid.

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it