Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • This is a milestone that could one day erase hereditary conditions.

  • Just like you can change a single letter in a word document,

  • now we can change single letters in the DNA.

  • It's called CRISPR.

  • Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats.

  • The new gene editing platform CRISPR is generating a lot of excitement.

  • CRISPR...

  • But this isn't the first time scientists have tried to fix the genes that make us sick.

  • It started over 30 years ago.

  • Gene therapy.

  • Medicine's new frontier.

  • It was the first time they were going to be altering a human's DNA.

  • The expectations were crazy.

  • I like reading as well as playing chess.

  • And I like to go to different places.

  • I'd want to make people more aware about sickle cell.

  • How are you, Pierce?

  • Pierceton Charles has sickle cell anemia.

  • It's a painful genetic disease that distorts his red blood cells so they can't deliver

  • oxygen to his organs.

  • His first blood transfusion was 7 months old.

  • He had a stroke.

  • He lost his spleen and shortly after the gallbladder.

  • He's had a total of 48 hospitalizations.

  • He's one of about 100,000 people in the United States with sickle cell.

  • Most are African-American and, on average, live to their mid-40s.

  • There is no definite treatment for sickle cell.

  • Sickle cell was one of the first hereditary diseases to have its gene mutation,

  • or sequence change, identified.

  • Ever since I met my first patient with sickle cell disease,

  • that's been really my challenge to say, let's find a cure that is based on the cause.

  • We've known the sequence change since the early 1970s.

  • But I'll point out, that's over 40 years ago, and we don't have any therapy

  • based on knowing that sequence change.

  • So in his lab at Stanford University, Matthew Porteus is trying to repair the gene

  • that causes sickle cell.

  • So what we have to do is edit some blood stem cells.

  • He's using a new gene editing technology called CRISPR-Cas9.

  • Ready to electroporate.

  • It works like genetic scissors,

  • cutting out and replacing a gene's misspelled bits of DNA.

  • We can change single letters in the DNA and convert the disease-causing variant

  • to a non-disease-causing variant.

  • The cells that have been edited are these bright green cells.

  • Pierceton needs monthly treatments to replace his sickle-shaped red blood cells

  • with normal cells.

  • He donates the old blood for Porteus's research,

  • which he hopes could someday help him.

  • They're attempting to modify the genes so they can cure sickle cell.

  • I think that it's pretty amazing.

  • Porteus has applied for approval for a clinical trial.

  • We think these cells represent cures for patients.

  • They do everything that they're supposed to do.

  • So that gives us confidence that it's worth trying in a human patient.

  • We have our fingers crossed.

  • We're excited.

  • But along with CRISPR's promise come fears about its accuracy...

  • A DNA break could be dangerous.

  • It could cause other mutations.

  • ...and its potential use editing genes not just in patients but in embryos,

  • which would impact future generations.

  • We're talking about something that would affect human evolution.

  • Critics worry CRISPR could be used to create designer babies.

  • You may want to make a baby taller, faster, smarter.

  • The power of this new CRISPR technology has

  • resurfaced questions that people have been thinking about for 40 years.

  • If we had a tool that would allow you to change the

  • DNA that would then be passed along to next generations,

  • is that something we should or shouldn't do?

  • Many of the questions, and the controversy, remind Ashanthi De Silva

  • of her own experience with a different kind of genetic engineering,

  • called gene therapy, nearly 30 years ago.

  • Ashanthi, Ashanthi, come baby.

  • When I was born, the umbilical cord was infected, and I would turn blue a lot.

  • She was born with ADA deficiency,

  • a rare genetic disorder that crippled her immune system.

  • Although there was no cure, her doctor had an idea,

  • though it could take a lifetime.

  • He said, "You know, there's this potential trial

  • going on at the National Institutes of Health.

  • Let me send her blood."

  • And he told me, "Mrs. De Silva, this is for

  • possible gene therapy when your daughter is 60 years old."

  • And I thought, "Oh, how wonderful!"

  • Unlike CRISPR, which repairs genes,

  • gene therapy would send in an

  • extra healthy gene to do the work of the defective one.

  • But before Ashanthi could be treated,

  • there were scientific, and ethical, hurdles to overcome.

  • They had told my parents there would be risks of leukemia, death.

  • It was the first time they were going to be altering a human's DNA.

  • We all went to the NIH.

  • And they actually didn't have FDA approval yet.

  • It was really up until that day they were waiting for the phone call,

  • I was in the room.

  • This is on the 14th of September,

  • "A great day for the world, a great day for medicine.

  • Gene therapy has been approved."

  • You can read that.

  • "Our daughter is the first patient in the world to receive gene therapy."

  • They had taken my cells and injected the vector with the corrected gene into my cells.

  • They transferred those cells back to me,

  • to see if they would give me a new immune system.

  • How about that?

  • My parents did receive death threats, because there was this idea that

  • altering someone's DNA is playing God.

  • There was a historic medical first today.

  • Genetic engineering as a potential way to cure an illness in a human being.

  • The gene therapy revolution seemed to come almost instantly,

  • fueled in part by discoveries from the Human Genome Project,

  • the national effort to find and sequence all human genes.

  • Payoff has already begun by the discovery of a long list of genes.

  • As researchers found more and more of the genes that cause hereditary diseases...

  • It is only a step toward eventual treatment, but it is a significant one.

  • Gene in a cancer patient.

  • ...news stories regularly touted gene therapy as the potential cure.

  • Gene therapy to improve a potentially deadly condition.

  • Such as muscular dystrophy, sickle cell anemia.

  • And possibly even AIDS.

  • We presumed, as a society, that if we had the gene we'd be able to

  • then quickly move to a treatment.

  • The expectations were crazy.

  • James Wilson was one of gene therapy's pioneers.

  • In these human cells he was able to replace

  • the defective cystic fibrosis gene with a normal gene.

  • In 1999, at the University of Pennsylvania,

  • he began testing a gene therapy for a rare liver disease that mostly affects boys.

  • Upon their first meal they develop a coma.

  • And there's 50 percent mortality as a result of that.

  • To deliver the healthy gene into the patient's body,

  • Wilson used a specially prepared virus called a vector.

  • A young man by the name of Jesse Gelsinger received the vector.

  • Things went terribly wrong.

  • He mounted this enormous immune response that led to his death.

  • I had spent almost 10 years trying to make it safe.

  • That's probably irrelevant.

  • What is relevant is a young man died.

  • After hundreds of gene therapy experiments, Gelsinger's death

  • came as an enormous shock.

  • Every researcher in America was reminded:

  • This is messing with the code of life.

  • Why aren't they reporting these?

  • Congress held hearings, and federal agencies investigated.

  • The FDA says Penn researchers failed to report previous

  • toxic reactions in humans and the death of test animals in similar experiments.

  • I wasn't given all the information.

  • And some of the information I was given was not true.

  • Penn's program was shut down, and Wilson banned from clinical trials

  • for five years.

  • Then investigators began uncovering problems at other institutions

  • around the country.

  • Several others died, hundreds more had side effects,

  • but researchers didn't tell federal health officials.

  • Gene therapy also faced scientific setbacks...

  • A cystic fibrosis treatment, a muscular dystrophy treatment,

  • a brain cancer treatment: all failed.

  • To this date, gene therapy has yet to cure anyone.

  • ...including Ashanthi De Silva.

  • The benefits from her gene therapy diminished with time.

  • So she still needed regular enzyme injections to support her immune system.

  • Gene therapy, at least initially, did give me that boost that I needed.

  • But it wasn't what they could call a cure.

  • The tragic death of Jesse Gelsinger

  • was one of several events that led to a precipitous decline in the support for this field.

  • Support just evaporated after that.

  • It seemed that gene therapy's prospects were over,

  • but a small group of researchers continued on.

  • Our first responsibility

  • to everyone, including Jesse Gelsinger, was

  • to try to figure out what happened and why.

  • We learned that the problem was immune response, not to the gene,

  • but to the delivery vehicle itself.

  • Wilson returned to the lab, hoping to make safer vectors.

  • And the vectors that we generated seem not only really safe

  • but were much more efficient.

  • I knew that they would be a game changer,

  • and we just distributed these to my colleagues.

  • And I hoped that there would get traction.

  • It didn't take long to discover them.

  • It took a lot longer for there to get traction.

  • An experimental gene therapy...

  • Almost 20 years later, gene therapy has been experiencing a revival,

  • and is showing promise for conditions ranging from hemophilia

  • to Parkinson's disease.

  • Peter McConnell has a genetic eye disease called choroideremia.

  • It leads to tunnel vision, and in some cases blindness.

  • He's the father of two young children and, hoping to see them grow up,

  • joined a clinical trial at the University of Pennsylvania.

  • When I initially was approved, I didn't think twice about it.

  • I was just going to do it.

  • They take a genetically mutated virus, and they inject it in the back of your retina.

  • The goal isn't to miraculously restore eyesight.

  • What they would consider successful was stopping the eye from progressing

  • and getting worse.

  • I'd be more than happy if that was the case.

  • For the first time ever, the FDA has just approved a gene therapy treatment.

  • The first gene therapy was recently approved in the United States

  • for a form of childhood leukemia.

  • But because gene therapy doesn't actually fix broken genes,

  • no one knows how long its benefits will last.

  • What we're asking to do here is to cure diseases.

  • And whether we can ultimately achieve a permanent genetic graft

  • that reverses their disease forever, we'll see.

  • That hope for a permanent cure is why so many are excited about CRISPR.

  • Wow. Human genetic engineering.

  • Yesterday was science fiction, and today it's reality.

  • Get this. It could eliminate chemotherapy.

  • It's fast, cheap and can cut and paste genetic code with great precision.

  • All the results say that it is working.

  • The ultimate test is going to be those first few patients.

  • They're the ones taking all the risks.

  • Patients who take risks like Ashanthi De Silva did with gene therapy.

  • She's grateful for the treatment she got,

  • but regrets gene therapy's long hiatus.

  • When you're doing something like altering someone's DNA, there are risks.

  • But it gave me life.

  • I was able to complete my master's, get married, you know have a nice home life,

  • so I've been very lucky.

  • As for James Wilson, he is now working with CRISPR but remains mindful of the

  • lessons from gene therapy's early days.

  • That period of exuberance, early on in the development of a new,

  • novel, cutting-edge technology, it's very easy to get caught up into that.

  • The reality is, is this is still science.

  • And these are still experiments, and we are still learning.

This is a milestone that could one day erase hereditary conditions.

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it