Subtitles section Play video Print subtitles UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME OR CONCEPT OF OR THEORY OF SOCIALISM. BRING IN CIVIC FORUM PAC CHAIR FORD O'CONNELL, FORMER OBAMA CAMPAIGN REGIONAL DIRECTOR ROBIN BIRO. FORD LOOKS ANGRY ALREADY. I WAS GOING TO START WITH ROBIN. NO. HE IS SMILING. YOU HEARD WHAT HE SAID. CAPITALISM OR INCOME DOESN'T START AT ZERO. GO AHEAD. >> THERE ARE TWO TYPES OF ECONOMIES, MARKET DRIVEN, AKA, CAPITALISM, AND GOVERNMENT DIRECTED AKA, SOCIALISM. WHAT HE IS PROPOSING A PRONG OF SOCIALISM BECAUSE PROVIDING DISINCENTIVE TO WORK. THIS UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME COMES FROM HIS BELIEF AUTOMATION WILL DISPLACE AMERICAN WORKERS F HE WAS TRULY WORRIED ABOUT THE DISEMPLOYMENT OF AMERICAN WORKERS WHAT HE WOULD BE TALKING ABOUT PROVIDING CREDIT TO SEND PEOPLE BACK TO SCHOOL TO RETRAIN THEM. FOR HIM TO SAY CAPITALISM IS NOT WORKING THAT IS NONSENSE. IN 191940% OF THE AMERICANS WORKED IN AGRICULTURE. TODAY 1 1/2%. WE'RE AT FULL EMPLOYMENT. JOBS ARE CHANGING, JOBS WILL BE THERE, ONLY QUESTION WHERE THEY ARE IN THE ECONOMY. CONNELL: YOU BRING UP A GOOD POINT, WHAT ARE THE SKILLS FOR THE JOB, DEBATE AND DISCUSSION WE SHOULD BE HAVING. WHOLE IDEA AFTER PROGRAM THAT GIVES PEOPLE MONEY. GIVE THEM $1000, SAY IT IS NOT SOCIALISM. NOW I GUESS, WE DO HAVE PROGRAMS LIKE THAT, THAT HELP PEOPLE HER, THAT FOR FOR PEOPLE. WE HAVE FOOD STAMPS. IF YOU GET RID OF THE PROGRAMS, REPLACE IT WITH THIS, IS IT MUCH DIFFERENT THAN WE HAVE NOW? WHAT DO YOU THINK? >> YOU BRING UP A GREAT POINT, CONNELL THIS, WORKED IN SOME COUNTRIES, EUROPEAN COUNTRIES. WE HAVE THIS RIGHT NOW IN ALASKA, BUT THAT IS PAID FOR BY THE OIL RESERVES ON FEDERAL PROPERTIES. IF YOU ASK THE QUESTION, IS IT SOCIALISM, WHO IS PAYING FOR THIS? IF WE DIVIDE THIS UP AMONG EVERYONE IN THE UNITED STATES WE WOULD BE PAYING IT OUT OF OUR TAXES. CONNELL: WE COULD PROBABLY DEBATE ALL THIS STUFF. THERE IS WHAT THE WHOLE THING WOULD COST BUT I WONDER IF YOUR PARTY, THE DEMOCRATIC PARTY WANTS TO DO THAT? IS THIS WHAT THEY WANT? THEY WANT WHOLE DEBATE HOW MUCH OF A SOCIALIST ARE YOU? ARE YOU REALLY A SOCIALIST? DO THEY REALLY WANT THAT? >> ANDREW YANG, I NEVER HEARD THAT NAME BEFORE HONESTY BUT DOING HIMSELF A SERVICE HERE SETTING APART FROM THE CROWD BY TALKING ABOUT THIS. WE'RE TALKING ABOUT IT NOW, GETTING HIS MOTIVE ACROSS. BUT NO, I DON'T THINK THAT MAJORITY OF DEMOCRATS WANT THIS RIGHT NOW. IT IS SOMETHING WE'RE JUST NOW DISCUSSING, BUT LOOK, THIS DIDN'T PASS IN SWITZERLAND BY ALMOST 77%. DO YOU HONESTLY THINK IT STANDS A FIGHTING CHANCE HERE IN THE UNITED STATES? CONNELL: PROBABLY NOT. I BET THE PRESIDENT, FORD LOVES THIS IDEA THIS KEEPS COMING UP. THIS IDEA WE'RE FOR SOCIALISM, ARE WE REALLY? IS THIS SOCIALISM? THAT IS PLAYING RIGHT INTO HIS HANDS IN MANY WAYS, DON'T YOU THINK? >> THE PRESIDENT LOVES IDEA OF CAPITALISM VERSUS SOCIALISM DEBATE. LET'S UNDERSTAND WHY. THE REASON IS VERY SIMPLE. THE BRAND OF SOCIALISM AS ROBIN POINTS OUT IS EXTREMELY TOXIC. IN LATEST FOX POLL, ONLY 25% FIND IT FAVORABLE. THAT SAID WHAT THE DEMOCRATS ARE PUSHING INDIVIDUAL SOCIALIST POLICIES, WHETHER FREE GOVERNMENT-RUN HEALTH CARE OR FREE COLLEGES, REGULATING BANKS BASICALLY INTO OBSECURITY. THEY ARE TRYING TO DUCK, DODGE, TACKLE THAT TERM OF SOCIALISM, YET THAT IS EXACTLY THE POLICIES THEY ARE PUSHING. REPUBLICANS DOESN'T UNDERSTAND THAT IF THEY DON'T FIND A BETTER WAY TO MESSAGE THIS, THIS COULD CREEP UP ON THEM REALLY QUICKLY. CONNELL: SOME OF THE INDIVIDUAL PROGRAMS ARE QUITE POPULAR.
B1 US socialism connell capitalism debate socialist robin 2020 presidential candidate Andrew Yang supports universal basic income 29 1 王惟惟 posted on 2019/04/04 More Share Save Report Video vocabulary