With a stronglabormarketandinflationnearit's 2% objective, I'd liketotake a stepbackandreviewhadthechangingeconomicandfinancialpicturebringsustotoday's decision.
Committeeparticipants, growthprojectionsfrom 2019 orlittlerevisedfromMarch, with a centraltendencyof 2 to 2.2% justabovetheirestimatesoflongerrunnormalgrowth.
Thegrowthprojectionsfortheyearas a wholemasksomeimportantdetailsaboutthecompositionofgrowth.
As I notedthem, theunexpectedstrengthwaslargelyinnetexportsandinventories, componentsthatarenotgenerallyreliableindicatorsofongoingmomentum, themorereliabledriversofgrowthintheeconomyorspendingonconsumptionandbusinessinvestment.
Whileconsumptionwasweakinthefirstquarter, incomingdatashowthathasithasbouncedbackandisnowrunningat a solidpace.
Wearefirmlycommittedtooursymmetric 2% inflationobjective, andwearewellawarethatinflationweaknessthatpersistsevenin a healthyeconomycouldprecipitate a difficulttoarrestdownwarddriftinlongerruninflationexpectations.
Theprojectionsofappropriatepolicyshowthatmanyparticipantsbelievethatsomecutinthefederalfundsratewillbeappropriateinthescenariothattheyseeasmostlikely, though, someparticipantswrotedownpolicycutsandothersdidnotofdeliberationsmadeclearthat a numberofthosewhowrotedown a flatratepathagreethatthecaseforadditionalaccommodationhasstrengthenedsinceourmainmeetingthisanatomicaccommodationwouldsupporteconomicactivityandinflation's returntoourobjective.
Thus, mycolleaguesand I willbelookingtoseewhethertheseuncertaintieswillcontinuetoweighontheoutlookandwewilluseourtoolsasappropriatetosustaintheexpansion.
So, um, generally, uh, as I mentioned, manyonthecommitteedosee a strengthincaseeightofthosestrengthincaseforcuttingrates, eightactuallywrotedownratecuts.
A numberofothersseethatthecaseisstrengthened, butthecommitteewantedtowantedtoseeMaura's I mentioned.
And, um, I alsomentionedthatsomeofthesesomeofthesedevelopmentshavebeenquiterecentvintage.
Andsowedoexpectthatwillbelearning a lotmoreonalloftheseissuesinthenearterm.
Sowe'llbemonitoringtheimplicationsofallofthosedevelopmentsforthe U.
S.
Economicoutlook.
Weexpecttolearn a gooddealmore, as I mentioned, andwe'llbeaskingthequestionwhetherthoserisksaregonnacontinuethewayontheoutlookandthenintheend, willuseourtoolsasappropriatetotosustainthislongexpansion.
I thinkthelawisclearthat I have a fouryeartermand I fullyintendtoserveit.
Youknow, hideyourpal.
I washopingthatthisisgenius.
MylookfromtheNewYorktimes.
I washopingthatyoucouldclarifyforus a littlebithowyou'rethinkingabouttherisksofwaitingtoolongtocutratesversustherisksofcuttingratesprematurely, Um, sortofwhatthebalanceofrisksareandhowyoutalkaboutthat, right?
Sowe'realwaystryingtobalancethatrisk.
But I wouldsaythatgiventhequiterecentnatureofsomeoftheevents, I thinkthecommitteefelt, though, thattherightthingtodowastowaitandSeymourandwewillsee a lotmoreonalloftheseissuesintheverynearterm.
So I don't thinktheriskofwaitingtoolongisprominentRightnow, I wouldsayis a generalmatter.
It's alwayssomethingthatwayhavetoweigh.
But I thinkwebelievethatthattherightthinghereistoistowatchcarefullyintheneartermandseehowtheserisksunfoldandseewhethertheycontinuedawayontheoutlook.
Inthiscase, youknow, there's alwayssomejudgmentinthesethings, but I wouldjustsaythatthatTherisksthatweseehavingemerged, uh, arearerisksthathavegottenourattentionandthathavecalled a numberofustowritedownratecutsand a numberofthosewhohaven't toseethatthecaseofstrengthenedMartyMartyquitsingingwiththeAP.
Youhadyourfirstdescentinyourtimeischairman.
Doesthatgiveus a sensethattherewasdebateaboutamong a groupitwaspushingfor a ratecutthistime?
Um, soitcouldcuteitherway, youknow, I wouldthinkthatextentyouseestrongerfinancialconditionsandstrongeractivityinthe C B after a ratecutthatwouldthatwouldsupporttendtosupportactivity.
Sowe'rereallyfocusedon, uh, youknow, theriskstoouronthebaselineoutlook, whichisstill a prettyfavorableone.
Isthereconcernthatyou'llbecausing a sortofdotdeflationbytellingpeopleWell, don't buyyourcarnowbecauseitwillgetcheaperinsixmonthsbecausewe'recuttingratesandthatthatcouldsortoffulfillitself.
Andsecondly, oninflation, thatwas a prettybigdropinexpectedPCyet, youknow, withoutreactingtoit, areyounotsortofunderminingyourincredible D Intermsofcommitmenttothe 2% target, I'lltaketheinflation.
Whenfirst I didn't quitefollowyourDODquestion.
Thefactthatexpectedinflationwentfrom 1.8 WhatHowardshinewithwordswentfrom 1.8 to 1.5.
Um, okay, soletmeletmeanswertheinflationquestionforsowe'resayingthatweknow I notedinthestatement, andalsoinmymindwhat I saidherewesawthatmarketbasedmeasuresofinflationexpectationsbreakevensdropped.
Wenotedthatalsoininthisstatement, and I noteditas a reasonforustooneofoneofseveralreasonswhy, whyitfeelstousthatthecaseformoreaccommodationhasstrengthened.
Sowefindthatnotable.
Notonlythat, theactualforecastforinflationforthisyearamongFOMCFOMCparticipantsdropped a coupleoftents.
Um, it's, uh, it's something I'vebeenconcernedaboutforquite a longtime.
It's oneoftheprincipalreasonswhy I calledforthereviewin a worldwhere, wherewherepolicyratesaregoingtobeclosertotheeffectofLowerbound, thenjustas a generalmatter, weneedtobereallystrongon 2% inflation.
So I think, uh, youknow, wecertainlydon't wanttobeseenasweakoninflationinit.
And I don't believeweareintermsofthedots.
You'reright.
Thisisthefirsttime I believewe'vehadWe'vetalkedaboutcuttingintheintheinthedoterror.
I guesstheDOTerabeganinJanuary 2012 andyouknowwe'reworkingourwaythroughit, and I thinkit's justsomethingwedo.
Ifyoucouldspend a coupleofminutesdiscussingtheprosandconsof a 50 basispointcaughthowyouapproachthatquestiononthespecificquestionofthat, thatjustsomethingwehaven't reallyengagedwithyet.
Donnauh, DonnaBarackwithCNNThanksChairmanPowell A Democraticpresidentialcandidate, ElizabethWarren, hasprovided a proposaltorevaluethe U S dollartoinordertoaddressconcernsaboutrisingtradedeficits.
Thepresidenthimselfhasroutinelycomplainedaboutthestrengthofthe U.
AndthatincludestheUnitedStatesthatincludesthe G 20 communicatethatweadopted 10 daysago.
So I'm nottherightpersontoaskaboutaboutthatsortofdollarpolicy.
Innovation.
Paul, ThinkGermanpalPaulKaronfromDowJones.
Um, ifthemostaccordingtotheDOTplot.
I mean, ifthemostlikelycaseisthatyouwillhavetocutratesinthenext 18 monthson, givensomeoftheconcernsaboutpolicyneedingtoreactsoonerandmoreaggressively, um, whatwouldhavebeenthedownsidestocuttingrates?
Now, whynotjustcutitnow?
Sowhynot?
Didn't whynotnow?
Um, and I wouldsaytherewasnotmuchsupportforcuttingrates.
Nowatthismeeting, therewas, asyousee, a numberofpeoplewrotedownratecuts, butallofthose, Butapparentlyonefeltthat, um, thatitwouldbebettertoSeymourtoo, beforemoving.
And I gave a coupleofreasonswhythatisthecasefirstisjustthefactthatsomeofthesedevelopmentsaresorecentthatwewanttoseewhether, whetherthatwhetherthey'llsustain.
Sowefeltthatitwouldbebettertoget a clearerpictureofthingsandthatwewould, infactlearn a lotaboutthesedevelopmentsinthenearterm.
Andtheydosupporteconomicactivitythroughthrough a numberof a numberofchannelsthatairreasonablywellunderstood, somemoredirectlytiedtointerestratesthanothers.
You're 10 yearsdeepintothis, andthat's somethingweheardquite a lotattheconferenceinChicagoontheReview, and I justwouldsayThat's whywethinkit's oneofthereasonswhywethinkit's soimportanttosustaintheexpansion.
Youknow, I don't I don't discusselectedofficialspubliclyorprivately.
Really?
So I wouldjustsaythatweareattheFedwheredeeplycommittedtocarryingoutourmissionandalsothatourindependencefromdirectpoliticalcontrolweseeasanimportantinstitutionalfeaturethathasservedboththeeconomyinthecountry.
I wanttotakeyoubacktoChicagoandthereviewofyourmonetarypolicystrategyandsomethinginteresting, I think, isdevelopingisthatoutsideexpertsareexcitedandareliketheideaoftheFedshiftingyourinflationtargetupto 4% aroundthere.
Roughly.
I guesstheythinkthatthatwould, youknow, helpmonetarypolicyandthatthere's no 2% isnotlikesanctimoniousoranythingorwhateversacreditseemsthatyou'vetakenthatoffthetable.
Thisgivesme a chancetosay a couplethingsaboutthereviewandChicagoinparticular.
Soit's a newthingforus, somethingthat I thoughtitwasbothappropriateimportantforustodo.
It'llbe a yearlongorevenlongerprocesslookingatourstrategy, toolsandcommunications.
Andit's it's meanttobe a waytoopenourselvesuptoletthesunshineinanddon't havedialogueandcriticismwiththeconstituenciesthatweserve.
Wehad a seriesofFedlistensaroundthecountryateveryReserveBank, andwehadanacademicconferenceearlierthismonthwithsevenpaperswrittenandcriticizedandleadingglobalexperts.
But I'lljustsayagainthatthattheheartoftheconferencewasthetwopanelsonwithpractitionersinlowandmoderateincomewholiveinlowandmoderateincomecommunities, uh, andarepartofthosecommunities.
Andtheywerethere.
I thinkpeoplewerequitestruckbytheirintervention, whichwasreallyuniformlyaround.
Andjustnowyouhave, youknow, companieswhowanttohireandarebringingpeopleintothefindingopportunitiesforpeopletocomeintothelaborforcetoanextentnotseeninquite a longtime.
Andthatis, I think, youknow, forsomeonewhodoesthisworkthatwasveryfocusingandandmotivatingtoo.
So I thinkeverybodythought, youknow, that's thatwasreallyquiteworthdoing.
I mean, therewastherewassomethoughtatthebeginningthatweshouldsomepeoplerecommendedthatwejusttalkedto, youknow, e conPhDsaboutthis, Butno, that's notwhatwechosetodo.
I wanttoknowwhattheistheisthe 2013 guidancestillrepresentativeofthesortoffedsthinkingaboutleveragedlendingand, uh, doestheheadofanyintentintentiontoeitherissuelike a leveragedlendingruleor a newguidancethatislessproblematic?
Youknow, it's thesurveysandthat I mentionedwillallshowthatlabormarkethastightened, butnotovertightenedJeanwiththelastquestionhygieneYoungwithmarketnews, I wantedtoask, DidtheFOMCdiscussthechangetoitsbalancesheetpolicyatthismeeting?