Thatisatleast a worldwherethereistheleastamountofsufferingthatiscommensuratewiththeexistenceoftheworld.
And I wouldsaythatwehaveameliorated a substantialamountofsufferinginthe 20thcentury, we'redoing a verygoodjobofdoingsuchthingsascombatingabsolutepoverty,
youmayormaynotknowthateverysingleday, about 150000 peopleworldwideareliftedoutofabsolutepoverty,
wemightaswellriskeverythingtoobtainthehighestpossiblegood, andthenthatwouldmakethemiserythatconstitutesourlifebearableas a consequenceofourintrinsicnobility.
(inaudiblesounds...butdon't worry, Dr. Petersonwillrepeatthequestionlater)
Okay, sothequestionis, howdoyouspeaktruthin a highlyhierarchalenvironment, like a workplacewhereperhapsyouhavedisagreeableoreventyrannicalmanagersand a resistancetothetruth?
Well, that's anexcellentquestion.
Thefirstthing I wouldsayis, youprepareyourself
andso, ifyouwanttonegotiate, forexample, youcan't negotiatefrom a positionofweakness,
becauseyoulose.
You'llloseineveryway. Youcan't withstand a conflict; you'vegotnothingtofallbackon.
Soifyou'rein a workplacethat's notamendabletoinformativemessages, let's say,
thefirstthingyoudoislookforanotherjob.
I don't meanthatyoutakeanotherjob, thatisn't what I mean,
I meanthatyouneedtoprovideyourselfwithcredibleoptions.
Becauseotherwise, you'llbeweakwhenyoustandforit.
andespeciallysomeonewho's a bullywilljustbullyyourightover
Well, youknow, inmanytimesinmylife, I'vetriedtoface, let's say, thechoicebetween a politicalrouteandthis, I wouldsay, a philosophicalrouteor a psychologicalroutethat I'vechosentogo.
Andwhat I gaveyoutonightisreallythebestanswerthat I have.
I'm nottryingtomakethecase I wouldn't, butthat's a comprehensiveanswer.
But I thinkthatifyouwanttomoveforwardproperly, thebestthingtodoistoorganizeyourself, I meanpersonally,
and I thinkthatthat's wherepeoplehavetheirmostpower.
And I thinkthatpowerisnotinsignificant, notatall.
So, that's thebest I candoforthat.
Yeah, I mean I can, thatwas a reallyinterestingquestionand I'm not a SocialJusticeWarriormyself,
butas I understandit, I think a lotofpeoplewho I'vetalkedtohavebeenthinkingaboutthat, I thinkthey'rereallytryingtodismantlewhattheyseetobeunfairsystemsofadvantagesandpatriarchalstructures, thereyouhaveit?
Itispossiblethatthat's thecasebutifthat's thecasethere's nothing I candoaboutit, I'm partofthehumanraceand I'm goingtoactoutitsdestinythebestthat I canmanage
and I'm notwillingtoreconsiderthingsatthatlevel,
I thinkthatthat's because I'vethoughtthemthroughsufficientlyforme,
andbecause I'vealsodeterminedinthecourseofmyownlifethat, (andfromwatchingtheeffectsofwhat I havebeentalkingaboutonotherpeople), what I'm doingisservingthegood.
Atleastaswellas I candoit.
Andwhat I'velearnedhasbeenveryhelpfultomepersonally, it's beenveryhelpfultomyfamily, I knowit's beenhelpfulformystudentsbecausetheytellmethat, andpeoplewritemeallthetime
I thinktherightquestionis: howshouldthegovernmentconstituteitselfsothatitcanrespondflexiblythedemandsofthesituation?
I believethatthere's utilityintheconservativeviewpoint, and I believethatthere's utilityintheliberalviewpoint, butthatitdependsonthespecificsofthesituation.
whohasmentionedEgyptashisinspiration, so I wonderhowmightsomebodylikeFoucaultorsomeonelikemewhocanthinkalongwithsomebodylikeFoucaultgeteachotheralong(?)
Well, I'veread a reasonableamountofFoucault
and I wouldsaythatamongthePostmodernistshe's ratherremarkableinthefactthatyoucanactuallyunderstandwhathesay.
I don't findwhathewroteparticularlysurprising, liketheideathatmentalillnessisinpart a socialconstruct,
is...ifyou're a reasonablyeducatedclinician, that's morethanself-evident
inthatvirtuallyeverycomplexactivitythathumanbeingsengageinisculturallydeterminedto a largedegree.
It's Derridathat I havethemostproblemwith.
And I alsoknowthatheputhisfingeron a verycomplexproblem, whichisthatthecentralPostmodernistclaimisthateverysituationallowsfor a potentiallyinfinitenumberofinterpretations,
Andso I thinkthePostmodernistsradicallyoverplayedtheirhand,
andthat's particularlytrueforDerrida,
and I thinkthepeoplewhofollowDerridaareinmanycasesdoingsobecauseit's hellof a loteasierthanactuallydoingthedifficultjobofextractingtheusefultoolsfromtheliteratureoftheworld,
Andso, I thinkthatPostmoderniststookthepartofNietzschethat's onlydestructivetoitsfinalconclusion, andthat's actuallywhat's beingplayedoutnow.
Derrida's critiqueofmoderncivilizationisPhallogocentric, right? maledominated, centeredaroundtheideaofthelogos - heregardedthatasnothingbut a toolofoppressionandmarginalization.
Andthere's sometruthinthatbecausewheneveryouproduce a valuesystem, youalsoexcludethingsfromthevaluesystemasnotvaluable, obviously
buttheproblem I thinkthatthePostmodernistswon't addressisthatthealternativetocreatingvaluesystemsanddealingwiththeexlusionthatcomeswiththatistodrowninNihilisticchaos,
I thoughtfor a longtime, from a psychologicalperspective, I triedtounderstand, whetheritwasNietzsche's philosophythatdrovehiminsane.
But I thinktheevidenceforthatisnon-existent, I thinkhedidsufferfrom a degenerativebraindiseaseofgreatseverity
and I actuallythinkthathisfundamentalphilosophywhich I'veread - I'vereadeverythinghewrotebecausethere's beennewbookspublished, but I readhisgreatworksinchronologicalorder
I thinkhisfundamentalphilosophyisaffirmative, notnegative.
Buthe's a critic, youknow? andhewantedtofindsomethingthathecanstandonandthat's whatcriticsdo
ifyou're a realcritic, you'renotlookingtodestroy, you'relookingforsomethingthatyoucanstandon
AndNietzschewascertainlyveryusefultomeand I knowhewasalsoextraordinarilyusefultoCarlJung, who's a realstudentofNietzsche,