Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • Good morning, John.

  • A nuclear reactor at Chernobyl exploded.

  • This kind of explosion had never happened before and hasn't happened since

  • and it wasn't supposed to be possible.

  • But why?

  • Why was it supposed to be impossible, and why wasn't it?

  • There are simplified answers out there.

  • I'm not gonna get deep into physics,

  • but I am gonna be a little bit more robust in how I talk about it because I think it's really interesting to actually

  • understand what happened here and why.

  • But first, an introduction of terms:

  • Nuclear: pertaining to the nucleus, which is the center of the atom that contains the protons and the neutrons.

  • Protons: the nuclear particle that has a positive charge.

  • The number of protons defines what element an atom is.

  • Neutrons: the neutral particle. Why does it even exist?

  • Well, why does anything exist?

  • But basically, for, like, subatomic particle physics reasons.

  • If you have too few neutrons in your nucleus, the nucleus will fall apart.

  • If you have too many, nucleus will fall apart.

  • Why?

  • Forces? I guess?

  • Isotope.

  • So, the number of protons an atom has always determines what element that atom is.

  • Six protons? It's carbon, every time.

  • Now, carbon usually has six neutrons, but sometimes it has five or seven or eight or nine,

  • and so we have this word "isotope" to describe these different forms of carbon.

  • So the normal carbon is carbon-12 and then there's carbon-13 and carbon-11, etc.

  • Unstable isotope.

  • Now, almost all naturally existing elements on Earth are stable isotopes;

  • that's because they're stable.

  • Unstable isotopes generally have too many or too few neutrons,

  • and so they will emit energy or particles on their path to becoming a more stable nucleus.

  • And that process of emitting energy or particles is called "radioactive decay."

  • Radioactive decay is one kind of nuclear reaction. There are two other kinds:

  • there's fusion, where two atoms come together to become one atom,

  • and then there's fission, when one atom breaks into two atoms.

  • During fission the leftover fission products, which is all the particles and atoms that are left over, are always a little bit lighter than the original atom.

  • What happened to that mass?

  • Well, it became energy.

  • As described by a pretty famous equation.

  • That energy is most of what we ultimately capture in a nuclear reactor and turn into electricity.

  • The products of fission themselves are unstable isotopes,

  • so they continue to decay inside the nuclear reactor.

  • So heat in nuclear reactors is actually created in two ways:

  • One, the vast majority of it is created through the fission of the atoms into smaller atoms.

  • Secondarily, though, heat is produced by the radioactive decay of these unstable isotopes

  • that are the product of the fission reactions.

  • So even after the nuclear reaction stopped, this radioactive decay continues to produce heat.

  • That heat has to go somewhere; it goes into the fuel,

  • and if you can't keep cooling off the fuel, it will melt itself.

  • And then it keeps getting hotter and hotter;

  • it makes itself hotter as long as these isotopes are unstable and emitting radiation.

  • They heat themselves up and that can melt through just about anything, which is what we call a "meltdown."

  • Now there is one single naturally occurring isotope on our planet that has a very...

  • special ability.

  • Uranium-235, if you hit it with a neutron, not only will it split apart, but it will create more neutrons.

  • And those neutrons, if they hit another uranium-235, that will split apart,

  • and it will cause this nuclear chain reaction.

  • This is the reason why we have nuclear power on this planet.

  • Now U-235 is a rare isotope;

  • it's about 0.7% of naturally occurring uranium.

  • Uranium-238 is much more common and much more stable.

  • So usually when we're making nuclear power or a nuclear bomb,

  • we have to enrich the uranium so there's much more U-235.

  • In, like, a nuclear bomb, it's like 80% U-235.

  • In that case, pretty much every neutron flying around in the thing is causing another fission reaction,

  • which is causing more neutrons.

  • So this, instantaneously, all of the uranium fizzes.

  • Fizzes?

  • It becomes a bomb. Like it's a bomb. That's the whole point of the bomb.

  • This is, of course, not what we want in nuclear reactors.

  • We want to be able to very carefully control the speed of the chain reaction.

  • Usually a super important part of this is enriching the uranium -

  • not all the way up to 80%, but to some more enriched version than naturally occurring uranium.

  • Just that enriching uranium, it turns out, is extremely expensive.

  • So the genius-ish thing about the RBMK reactor design, the thing that people liked about it,

  • was that it was a cheap way to use unenriched uranium or very slightly enriched uranium

  • to create a self-sustaining nuclear reaction.

  • Now to do this, because the fissionable atoms of u-235 are farther apart

  • and there's other stuff in there that can absorb neutrons,

  • you have to do more with the neutrons you have.

  • A primary goal of all nuclear reactors is controlling neutrons

  • and you can do this in two ways:

  • You can absorb them, which slows the reaction down

  • or you can moderate them, which speeds the reaction up.

  • That sounds a little counterintuitive...

  • It is, I'll explain why.

  • When a uranium atom splits apart, the neutrons that come out are going extremely fast.

  • They're going too fast actually, for quantum mechanics reasons that I don't understand,

  • to actually hit another uranium atom and break it apart.

  • Mostly it will just bounce off.

  • And then it'll fly out of the reactor and it won't get used.

  • So counter intuitively, you have to slow down the neutrons to speed up the rate of reaction.

  • To do this, you use something called a "moderator" - they moderate the speed of neutrons,

  • they do not moderate the speed of the reaction,

  • they *increase* the speed of the reaction.

  • Now there are some reactors that are able to do this with heavy water,

  • which is like isotopically enriched water

  • that actually makes it really good at neutrons bouncing off of it and slowing down some.

  • That's expensive because heavy water is expensive

  • but the nice thing is -

  • if the reactor starts to get hot, the heavy water starts to boil,

  • and then there's less of it around to slow down the neutrons,

  • so the reaction starts to slow down.

  • It's a negative feedback loop, which is the kind that you want inside of a nuclear reactor.

  • Now the RBMK reactors used regular water as a coolant because that's cheaper

  • but regular water is actually a neutron absorber.

  • That's gonna become really important later.

  • So instead of heavy water, RBMK reactors use big, heavy blocks of graphite to slow down the neutrons.

  • That's the neutron moderator.

  • So to sum up, you've got moderators which help speed things up

  • and you've got absorbers, which help slow things down.

  • These are your gas pedal and your brakes in your nuclear reactor.

  • And you need these things because there's other stuff that affects the rate of the reaction,

  • that changes as the fuel is used,

  • it changes depending how long the reaction has been going.

  • And then all reactors - like in the fuel - you have the build up of different byproducts of the fission.

  • And some of those absorb neutrons, some of them slow neutrons down.

  • There's a big one, xenon-135, which is part of the decay pathway after uranium breaks apart.

  • So it doesn't show up immediately, it just like ramps up slowly and it starts absorbing neutrons,

  • so you have to pull your control rods out some.

  • There's ways to control all this stuff but it's complicated.

  • So you need ways to be able to put on the brakes or put on the accelerator.

  • The xenon thing is what happened on the day of the accident.

  • They had basically run the reactor all day, in a sort of a perfect procedure for what you would do -

  • if you wanted to increase the amount of xenon-135 in your reactor.

  • They didn't do this on purpose,

  • it's just what happened.

  • And so when they started to decrease the power for the test,

  • the xenon started to suck up all the neutrons,

  • and the reactor dropped into this situation where they just weren't getting any power out of the reactor.

  • Now the normal thing to do with an RBMK reactor, because of all these positive feedback loops,

  • is to very slowly bring the power back up.

  • But they wanted to get the power back up fast.

  • And so what they did is they pulled all of the control rods out -

  • pretty much all the control rods out of the reactor.

  • The only things left absorbing neutrons in this reactor now

  • are water and xenon-135.

  • If one or both of those things go away,

  • then you would have a nuclear reactor that is in a very difficult to control state.

  • They talk in the show, and a lot of science communication talks about,

  • (and I completely understand this because like you don't have however long this video is to explain all of this)

  • they talk about how the control rods were tipped with graphite.

  • So when they came back into the reactor, the first thing that happened -

  • is that this moderator, the things that speed up the reaction, was the first thing that came into the reactor.

  • Now you might, having heard that version (which is the simplified version),

  • be like, "Why on earth would you tip a control rod with graphite?"

  • Like there's easier, cheaper stuff to tip a control rod with.

  • The simple answer to that question... is that they didn't?

  • Let's explain.

  • So when you're using normal water as your coolant, it also is absorbing neutrons.

  • So if you take your control rod out, which is the thing that absorbs neutrons,

  • and all that's left, like water, is just taking that space -

  • you have a less good but still a control rod made of water in that space absorbing neutrons.

  • So in RBMK reactors, they have control rods that control in both directions.

  • The top of the control rod is made to absorb neutrons

  • and then as that pulls out, it pulls in a graphite rod and that is made to increase the reaction.

  • This is the "graphite tip".

  • That's not actually a graphite tip, it's part of what makes the reactor work.

  • So you have, in every control rod, a brake and an accelerator.

  • And you can't do one without the other.

  • So on the day of the accident, they hadn't just pulled out all of the brakes -

  • they'd pulled in all of their accelerators.

  • Pretty much all of them.

  • This is not the biggest problem.

  • The biggest problem is neutron flux,

  • which is basically the movement of neutrons throughout different parts of the reactor

  • and you want to control the movement of neutrons throughout the reactors,

  • so that all of the fuel burns evenly,

  • so you don't waste anything,

  • and so there aren't areas of the reactor that are hotter than some other areas.

  • To accomplish this,

  • the graphite moderator rods are actually shorter, both at the top and the bottom, than the fuel rods.

  • So in those spaces, there's some water

  • and that water is absorbing neutrons.

  • And in the middle, you get a nice flat curve of neutron flux,

  • evenly distributed throughout the reactor.

  • And this is fine. This is great.

  • Unless, you take all of the control rods out at the same time

  • and then put them all back in at the exact same time.

  • And we'll see why.

  • So on the day of the accident,

  • they had pulled out all of the absorbers, pulled in all of the accelerators

  • and then you have your positive feedback loops kicking in.

  • Specifically, because the flow of water through the reactor had been slowed down, the water started to boil.

  • Water is usually there absorbing neutrons.

  • So it's boiling, and suddenly there isn't as much water there absorbing neutrons,

  • which is increasing the rate of the reaction,

  • and finally, all these neutrons that are suddenly flowing around eats up all of the xenon-135

  • So that control, that had been there the whole time, is suddenly gone.

  • And then you have the final fatal decision,

  • the thing that you're *supposed* to do in this situation.

  • When the control rods started into come back to the reactor,

  • the graphite rods displaced the water at the bottom of the reactor,

  • until suddenly there was nothing in the bottom row of the reactor

  • that, in any way, throughout the entire reactor, was controlling neutrons at all.

  • So the reactor is already dangerously overpowered

  • and then, localized in the bottom of this reactor, you have this spike of neutron flux

  • that's beyond anything the reactor is designed for.

  • That very rapidly increased the amount of energy being produced

  • and something somewhere broke.

  • It could have been a lot of different things that in this situation broke.

  • It might have been multiple things at once.

  • But when it broke, it locked those graphite rods into this most dangerous of positions.

  • And now it's time for a sidenote on explosions.

  • An explosion generally seems like it has something to do with fire to us.

  • Fire is often a component of explosions, it's why we can see them.

  • Like movie explosions, like very fiery.

  • But explosions actually happen - usually - when a solid or a liquid converts into a gas.

  • And gases take up much more space than liquids and as that rapid expansion happens, that is your explosion.

  • That sounds wild but it's the case.

  • This is all about phase change and the hotter your gas is, the more space it takes up.

  • And so, and so, and so, the water and the reactor got so hot that it turned into this...

  • extremely pressurized vat of steam.

  • So hot, that in fact it dissociated into hydrogen and oxygen,

  • which then becomes itself a fuel.

  • The top popped off the reactor.

  • The graphite in this environment became basically fuel and so it caught on fire.

  • In short, exploded.

  • Now Fukushima also exploded.

  • It exploded in a much different way.

  • Instead of the reactor itself exploding,

  • hydrogen escaped from the reactor and that hydrogen gas exploded

  • and that damaged the reactor.

  • Bad. But much different from what happened at Chernobyl.

  • All those isotopically unstable fission products then either started melting, because there was no cooling left,

  • or they burned and went into the air for people to breathe for hundreds of miles.

  • This sounds like a worst-case scenario.

  • And in some ways, it is.

  • This is as bad as it can get when it comes to a reactor exploding

  • but it is not the worst-case scenario when it comes to the impact that it could have on people.

  • There were ways, after the fact, that this could have gone much worse,

  • if it were not for a lot of hard work and clever engineering and bravery.

  • But reactor design is all about creating balance.

  • Even with all of these problems, the design of the reactor prevented anything catastrophic from happening,

  • unless you did a very specific set of things -

  • the things that they did in 1986.

  • If you want to get a little deeper into the physics of this, Scott Manley's video on this topic is amazing

  • and if you want to watch the HBO miniseries,

  • I found that very good and enlightening, in terms of the human and political causes of this disaster,

  • as in addition to the engineering and physical causes of the disaster.

  • John, I'll see you on Tuesday.

Good morning, John.

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it