Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • Something terrible happened in these dollhouses.

  • Maybe a suicide.

  • A murder.

  • A stabbing with an adorable knife.

  • These dollhouses are part of Frances Glessner Lee's Nutshell Studies of Unexplained Death,

  • which she made in the 1940s and early 50s.

  • They're in the Renwick Gallery of the Smithsonian American Art Museum

  • for a reason.

  • They're incredibly detailed

  • these cans are all labeled.

  • Accurately.

  • And these dollhouses are used by law enforcement

  • to train and to develop analytical capabilities.

  • But these artful dioramas actually contain two mysteries:

  • What happened in these houses?

  • And why did Frances Glessner Lee spend her time, and part of her fortune, making them

  • perfect?

  • This isthree-room dwelling,” and it's a dollhouse murder showstopper.

  • There are 19 of these dioramas and each one comes with a backstory, drawn from composite

  • real crimes.

  • In this one, Robert, Kate, and baby Linda Mae Judson had a nice porch where the milkman

  • stopped by.

  • They were living the American dream until the murders happened.

  • As you start to sort of investigate the evidence...

  • the first time I approached this case, I looked at it for a couple of hours, I took tons of

  • pictures home and I analyzed them for hours, trying to figure this out, because it doesn't

  • seem like things add up.

  • There's a bloodstain that's in the baby's room but it's just a blood pool, and there

  • doesn't seem like there's any kind of trail from it, it's just sitting there.

  • We don't know what had happened there.

  • There's bloody footprints that are leading into the bedroom, the husband is lying on

  • the ground on some of the bed coverings, we have no idea how he died, he's covered in

  • blood all over his pajamas, so it's very hard to tell.”

  • Three-room Dwelling's morbid details come from the same mind that crafted incredibly

  • delicate ones.

  • There's this little eggbeater down under the cubbard here that I like to point out,

  • and this was apparently originally a solid gold charm from a charm bracelet.

  • The Nutshells themselves are lit as the rooms would be, the flashlight helps you find the

  • evidence.

  • There's quite a lot of evidence in these pieces that you would probably never discover

  • without it, so it's a fun thing to have in the exhibition, but it's also a real

  • training tool for really systematically looking through these pieces.”

  • And you notice the fabric on a chair, the blocks scattered on the porch, and the blood

  • spattered on the baby's wall.

  • Because law enforcement still use these to train, it's tempting to play CSI with these

  • murders.

  • But notice that Atkinson only broke down the nutshells, she didn't didn't give away any

  • solutions.

  • That's partly because the solutions are still kept secret for those in training.

  • But mostly, it's because the mystery serves a purpose.

  • The point of the nutshells is not to solve them.

  • The point is to collect detail.”

  • Erin Bush saw the nutshells in their home before the Renwick gallerythe Maryland

  • Medical Examiner's office, where they're used for training investigators.

  • The goal of the nutshells is to train your eye to see small, minute, seemingly insignificant

  • details that stand out.

  • So the kitchen: It's Spring, 1944 — Robin Barnes is a

  • housewife.

  • Fred Barnes, her husband finds her.

  • And the story is, he's out of the house to run an errand.

  • He comes home, he looks through the kitchen window and he sees her laying on the kitchen

  • floor.

  • He can't open the door, the door is locked from the inside, the window is locked from

  • the inside.

  • So he calls the police, the police break the door down.

  • So this is what we know when we arrive.

  • She was clearly in the middle of something.

  • She's clearly preparing a meal.

  • There's a pie in the stove, there are potatoes in the sink.

  • You don't commit suicide if you're in the middle of dinner.

  • And I think, if you look very closely at the stove, and if you can recognize a 1940s stove,

  • you will see that all the gas jets are on.

  • There are a lot of weapons in the room.

  • There's a rolling pin, there's an iron, there is a knife, on the chair.

  • It's very possible someone hit her over the head.

  • If you look very closely at the door, it's stuffed with newspaper.

  • So now we're back to suicide.

  • The point, of course, was to recognize these details and to teach investigators how to

  • recognize these details.

  • It was a very different way to investigate crime than they were used to.”

  • Frances Glessner Lee was an heir to International Harvester, a company that produced farm equipment

  • and other machinery.

  • Her family made a fortune, a part of which she eventually used to fund miniature crime

  • scenes.

  • She endowed Harvard's Department of Legal Medicine, the first of its kind, and became

  • an honorary police captain.

  • Her artistic obsession helped detectives become more attentive to crime scenes, relying on

  • evidence instead of hunches.

  • For me, as a historian, when I look at them, I don't think who did it, I think

  • my God why is she inventing this scene the way she's inventing it, you know, what's

  • in her head, and to me that's fascinating.”

  • Lee's nutshells are as complex as the scenes they depict.

  • They overflow detail: the magazines crumpled on the floor; the apples that will never be

  • eaten; the body that will never move but is so vividly rendered that you can imagine it

  • once did.

  • On the one hand, she was the young Frances Glessner who was this philanthropic lady who

  • was brought up in a fine household, and the other half of her personality was

  • Captain Lee, and those two things did come together sometimes.”

  • Lee wrote a 1952 article in the Journal of Law and Criminology.

  • Some years ago, the writer was greatly surprised to learn that nowhere in America

  • was Legal Medicine, as thus described, being taught.

  • The writer has for many years worked sporadically at miniatures, hence these presented themselves

  • as the solution.”

  • Frances Glessner Lee died in 1962 of natural causes.

  • It must be understood, these models are not 'whodunits' - they cannot be solved

  • merely by looking at them.

  • They are intended to be an exercise in observing, interpreting, evaluating and reporting-- there

  • is no 'solution' to be determined.”

  • This toy's only approved for ages...dead and older.

  • YEAAAAHHHHHHH!!!”

Something terrible happened in these dollhouses.

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it