but it doesn't look appealing.

Do I have to eat it?

- Hey I'm Sarah Beth and I am a former Chick-fil-A employee.

- I'm Brian and I used to work at McDonald's.

- I'm Marissa and I'm a former employee of KFC.

- My name is Diana Flores

and I'm a former worker for Wendy's.

- The perfect cookie is something that tastes fresh.

- It has to be warm, a little bit crispy.

- I want to see the chocolate ooze a little bit

when I bite into it.

- I want it to be soft, I want it to melt in my mouth.

- Sometimes you get like a chunky piece

and that's (muah), that's the good stuff right there.

- I know everybody's gonna like these cookies from Wendy's

'cause they're really delish.

It's my favorite and I bet it'll be yours too.

- This is what I want in a cookie.

- This looks so good,

this has the big chocolate chunks in it.

- It's large which is always a good thing.

- I wanna get to this chocolate piece over here.

I want that.

- It's like less of like a chip and more of a chunk.

- Eat it with two hands it's so big.

- Mmm, mm-hmm.

- It's not quite as soft as I would like.

- I guess this one just tastes a little bit more

like a classic chocolate chip.

- Whoa!

That is so good!

Mmm I would eat that whole thing right now.

It's baked to perfection.

- Overall the spirit of what a cookie should be

in my opinion, is all there.

So I give it a seven.

- I'd say it's like a seven.

- Wow!

That's a 10 cookie right there.

That is a 10 10.

I do want this one for later, that is really good.

- The thing I love about the KFC cookies

is that it comes with like so much freshness

already like packaged in there.

And so you have that reliability, that consistency.

My mouth is watering already.

- What?

- This looks like a fake cookie.

- The edge, there's no chocolate.

Tastes like vanilla, like a vanilla cookie.

The chocolate's all the way in the middle.

- This one doesn't feel like it has a lot of flavor.

- And nothing that's screaming like,

"Hey Grandma just baked me,

I'm yours."

- It's hard.

- It could use a little more chocolate chips,

need more chocolate "chippage", you know what I'm saying?

- You know a good five, it's still a good cookie.

- I would rank this a seven for the effort.

- Not a huge fan of this one.

Let's go with a four.

(pleasant guitar music)

McDonald's cookies are very soft.

They're very chewy,

like they have the nice little chunks

of chocolate chip in there and that's good.

It's really like the perfect cookie

assuming you make it correctly.

- It looks like something that was like freshly baked.

It's definitely like more brown.

- I do love a thin, crispy cookie I will say

so this is looking somewhat promising to me.

Ooh do you hear that like crunch?

That was nice.

Mmm (crunches cookie).

- Nope.

- I don't like this cookie.

I don't even wanna eat it.

(cookie knocking table)

- I think I was kind of nervous

it was gonna be a little bit too crispy

but no, it's not at all.

It definitely has like a nice crunch to it,

like you can hear when I was biting into it.

It's like, it's a thin, crispy cookie.

And so, I think if that's what your in the market for

this one's a good choice.

- It's so unappealing looking like,

that I don't wanna eat it.

Why would you sell this?

- [Producer] Is there a more positive thing

you can say about it?

- Positive?

It looks like a cookie, that's it.

- I would say I'm gonna give it a 7 1/2.

I mean it's no KFC so don't get me wrong

but it's solid.

- We're gonna just give this one a two

and pretend that didn't happen.

- If I would rank this it would be a one.

- So the Chick-fil-A chocolate chip cookie is good

because it has chocolate chunks in it.

They're not skimping on the chocolate people.

And it's usually warm when you get it

and if it's not warm you better ask for a warm one,

because that is how they're the most delicious.

- This looks like a hearty cookie.

- It looks like a giant Chips Ahoy cookie.

- Presentation is just, this is a chocolate chip cookie.

When you look at it,

you feel like there's so much going on in there.

You can just see the chunks of chocolate.

You can see kinda like the texture.

- Oh it's soft.

I like it.

Oh look it's like melty.

I taste the chocolate it's really good.

You can see it smearing across the chocolate.

(Diana chuckles)

- Comes apart decently, that's nice.

The chocolate's like a little soft and melted

so that's a good sign.

This, you know what maybe I'm judging this cookie

before I actually get to know it.

Let's give this a shot.

It's a little too crunchy for me, not a fan of that.

Mmm, I will give it credit

the chocolate is very melty and that's nice.

Just a little melty right there.

- Mmm-hmm

wow wow wow.

There's like some dimension to the cookie

and it's very buttery as well which I love.

This is an amazing chocolate chip cookie.

- This one, not my favorite cookie

um if I had to rank it, I give it like, like a five.

- I would rank this cookie,

a 10.

Yeah I like it.

- I think I'm gonna give this one a 10.

I don't know what would make it better.

It's like moist on the inside.

Yeah I'm gonna give it a 10.

- Oh man the perfect chocolate chip cookie

Chick-fil-A cookies!

Come on people they're so good!

I knew we'd get here.

Um they really are amazing.

They're soft and warm and yummy

they got the chunks in 'em.

So if you haven't tried it, you need to go try it

but um, yeah that will bless your life.

And it will be my pleasure.

(upbeat music)