Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • If you were an early settler in the Wild West,

  • and you got sick, you had three health care options.

  • One, find a doctor, and hope their strange potions

  • numbed your pain.

  • Two, figure out how to cure your own ailment.

  • Or three, die.

  • Of course, if you were able to find a doctor,

  • you'd probably die anyway, because they sort of just

  • winged it as they went along.

  • Today, we're going to discover what

  • it was like going to a doctor in the Wild West.

  • But before we cut into this here story,

  • we reckon you subscribe to the Weird History Channel

  • and holler at us about a Old West thingamajingins you'd

  • like to hear about.

  • Now, take a swig of whiskey, and bite down on this here rag.

  • We're going to go see a doctor in the Old West.

  • Now, you have to remember the state of medicine

  • in the Old West.

  • It wasn't so much of a science yet

  • as it was a way to make money.

  • Sure, you had a lot of doctors in it for altruistic reasons,

  • but for the most part, medicine was a cutthroat business.

  • When a new physician established an office in a smaller

  • town that already had a doctor, things

  • could get ugly fast, as they'd usually become territorial.

  • Two doctors in one town meant they'd have to split profits.

  • One of the more infamous incidents of dueling doctors

  • took place when a Dr. Edward Willis

  • moved to Placerville, California, which

  • was then called Hangtown.

  • Upon his arrival, Dr. Willis pitched

  • a tent that would serve as his home and medical office.

  • He then hung a sign above his door

  • announcing his services as doctor and surgeon.

  • None of this was cool with Doc Hullings, the first doctor

  • to open a medical practice in the burgeoning mining camp.

  • Hullings immediately walked over to the new doctor's tent

  • and ordered him out of town.

  • Dr. Willis calmly told Hullings he wasn't going anywhere then

  • turned his back on him, and then ordered him out of his tent.

  • Incensed, Hullings stormed out and came up

  • with a plan, which wasn't so much of a plan

  • as it was just him showing up several days later

  • with a backup of several well-armed Hangtown gold

  • miners.

  • Hullings demanded Willis produce a diploma, which he promptly

  • did.

  • Hullings tore it in half and tossed it to the ground.

  • Mr. Paul Clam, a friend of Dr. Willis,

  • was there and witnessed the exchange,

  • and then punch Doc Hullings.

  • Hullings escalated the fight, challenging Clam and Willis

  • to a duel with pistols.

  • This duel was held in an abandoned mining pit.

  • After the Sheriff yelled "Fire," both men shot,

  • and both men went down.

  • Clam was badly wounded from three body shots.

  • Doc Hullings was slightly more wounded.

  • He was dead

  • According to miners' law, any man

  • who abandoned his claim also gave up all rights to his land.

  • Since Doc Hullings was dead, He had technically

  • abandoned his claim, and Dr. Willis instantly

  • became the town's sole physician.

  • His first job was to save Mr. Clam's life,

  • and his first official act was to sign Doc Hullings's death

  • certificate.

  • Doctor was an extremely vague title people gave themselves

  • in the Wild West.

  • While some had formal training, one

  • didn't need a fancy degree or any real formal hands-on

  • experience.

  • All you needed was a bag full of unsterilized surgical tools

  • and the ability to convince people

  • you knew what you were doing.

  • And because there was a shortage of medical professionals

  • on the frontier, becoming a doctor

  • was as simple as calling yourself a doctor.

  • For example, in 1827, a janitor performed the first cesarean

  • section in the West.

  • John Richmond worked as a janitor at a medical school,

  • and while he was there, he'd listen in on lectures

  • and take mental notes.

  • Eventually, he quit his janitorial gig,

  • then called himself a doctor and performed a c-section

  • without ever observing one or cutting into a human body,

  • for that matter.

  • Richmond wrote, "Finding that whatever was done

  • must be done soon and feeling a deep and solemn sense

  • of my responsibility, with only a case of common pocket

  • instruments, about 1 o'clock at night,

  • I commenced the cesarean section.

  • The patient never complained of pain

  • during the whole course of the cure."

  • That said, Dr. Richmond might have exaggerated a bit,

  • as the accounts of the c-section has been debated.

  • While the woman survived the shady procedure,

  • the child did not.

  • And in her 2018 book Cesarean Section, An American History

  • of Risk, Technology and Consequence,

  • Jacqueline H. Wolf wrote.

  • "The mother begged him to stop.

  • She couldn't endure the pain."

  • As barbaric as Richmond's attempted c-section was,

  • it's the first published account of an attempted

  • to cesarean performed in the United States.

  • For every John Richmond, there were formally

  • trained doctors who had an idea of what they were doing.

  • But even these medical professionals

  • relied on dangerous and highly-experimental treatments.

  • Dr. Daniel Drake, a founder of Ohio's first medical college,

  • strongly advised bleeding for patients whose

  • pulse is nearly imperceptible.

  • If the doctor's lancet couldn't induce blood flow from a vein,

  • Dr. Drake recommended cutting the jugular vein in the neck.

  • Yes, the majority of patients who

  • underwent blood letting through their jugular

  • had a prognosis you'd probably predict.

  • They perished.

  • Blister treatments were another one

  • of the more confusing treatments these doctors regularly

  • performed.

  • This questionable practice called for a doctor

  • to cover a portion of the skin with crushed chili

  • peppers to produce hyperemia.

  • The chili paste would produce a very powerful

  • counter-irritation so that the pain of the blisters

  • would override the painful condition being treated,

  • sort of like hitting your head with a hammer

  • if you had a stomach ache.

  • Purgation was another go-to treatment

  • these Old West doctors liked to suggest to their patients.

  • If a doctor suggested you purge, you

  • would be ordered to swallow calomel, a mercury-based drug

  • that made you evacuate your bowels

  • with the velocity of a broken frozen yogurt machine.

  • The hope here was that the purging would get rid

  • of the black bile in one's stomach,

  • but it rarely healed anyone.

  • As medieval as medicines seemed in the Old West,

  • it's no surprise that common folk

  • were alarmed by some of the practices

  • these new doctors sprung on them.

  • When doctors sliced open human bodies

  • or performed unorthodox surgeries

  • to save patients' lives, it really freaked people out.

  • One frontier doctor reported that he

  • opened the throat of a child choking with diphtheria

  • and kept the windpipe open with fish hooks.

  • Now, imagine it's 1875, and you see this.

  • You'd probably flip out, too.

  • It's no surprise that some people

  • believed doctors were performing satanic rituals.

  • In another case the famed surgeon Dr. Ephraim McDowell

  • performed a messy operation on a 45-year-old Kentucky

  • woman named Jane Crawford.

  • McDowell was summoned to the Crawford farmhouse

  • to assist in what was thought to be a long overdue childbirth.

  • McDowell soon found that Crawford wasn't pregnant.

  • She was suffering from a massive ovarian tumor.

  • Dr. McDowell then suggested the removal

  • of the tumor, a surgery that had never been attempted before.

  • Eventually, Dr. McDowell was able to extract Crawford's ,

  • tumor all 22 pounds of it.

  • That said, he had a difficult time

  • with some of the townsmen, who thought he was

  • doing the work of the devil.

  • Superstition and taboos contributed to the talk

  • that McDowell was doing something otherworldly

  • in his office.

  • His patient survived a 25-minute procedure without anesthetics,

  • but accusations of satanic practices

  • followed most surgeons of the era, even when they

  • saved the odd life.

  • While the majority of the frontier's doctors were men,

  • the Old West provided lots of opportunities for women.

  • Yeah, there was some basis of facts

  • from Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman.

  • In 1874, Dr. Bethenia Owens-Adair

  • studied at the Eclectic Medical College of Pennsylvania

  • and in 1874 earned her MD from the University

  • of Michigan's medical school.

  • She moved to Oregon, where she practiced medicine

  • in Portland and Astoria.

  • As Dr. Owens-Adair described, practicing medicine in the west

  • was a major challenge.

  • "I carried out my professional work as best I could in that

  • out-of-the-way place.

  • And at no time did I ever refuse a call, day

  • or night, rain or shine.

  • Through trails so overhang with dense undergrowth

  • and obstructed with logs and that a horse and rider could

  • not get past, and through muddy and flooded tide lands

  • in gum boots."

  • Interesting fact about Dr. Owens-Adair,

  • she was a big proponent of the eugenics movement.

  • In 1909, she supported a bill to sterilize

  • criminals, epileptics, the insane, and the feeble-minded.

  • The bill actually passed the Oregon legislature,

  • but the governor at the time refused

  • to sign it into law, although the bill became law

  • eight years later.

  • A similar bill became law in nearby Washington State

  • in 1909, largely due to the doctor's efforts.

  • While many untrained frontier doctors got into medicine

  • to turn a quick profit, they really

  • didn't make a whole lot of money.

  • Not in the small towns, anyway.

  • Doctors of the era usually charged $0.25 for a visit,

  • while extended visits, including overnight care,

  • might cost up to a dollar.

  • However, many patients couldn't afford

  • to pay doctors in legal tender.

  • Instead, these cash-poor patients

  • paid for their medical care in goods or services,

  • usually in the form of a bundle of wood,

  • produce, a side of beef, eggs, blankets,

  • or other items of value laying around.

  • Some doctors even offered a discount

  • on medical services on house calls

  • if their patients fed their horses.

  • Frontier doctors didn't just treat patients, a lot of them

  • also had side hustles as drugists.

  • Yep, even these physicians weren't formally schooled,

  • they often made and sold their own medicines.

  • While some settlers living on the open range

  • in the middle of nowhere usually had to grit their teeth

  • and suffer through their malady with whiskey,

  • settlers in developed towns were able to visit

  • their local apothecary, the drugstore of their day.

  • The drugists at these apothecaries

  • diagnosed problems, gave advice, and sold

  • their homemade remedies.

  • Remember, most drug laws in the US

  • never came into effect until after 1900,

  • so these drugists were free to sell whatever they think

  • might cure their patients.

  • Medicines made by frontier drugists

  • were usually based around raw herbs, leaves, and roots.

  • If you study the ingredients of these early serums,

  • you'll note that many of them have

  • foundations and remedies concocted by Native American

  • Indians.

  • Of course, many frontier doctors looked down

  • on Native Americans.

  • Naturally, they rejected anything associated with them,

  • even though their natural plant-based serums were

  • derivative of what the Native American Indians had been

  • practicing for generations.

  • While advanced medicine was making great leaps and bounds

  • in other developed parts of the world doctors, in the Wild West

  • just didn't know what the hell they were doing.

  • Nowadays, you should feel better about going

  • to the doctor, right?

  • But what do you think?

  • Who would you go to if you caught a fever, knowing

  • your doctor would tell you to drink sulfur with a whiskey

  • chaser?

  • Let us know what you think in the comments below,

  • and while you're at it, check out some of these other videos

  • from our Weird History.

If you were an early settler in the Wild West,

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it