Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • Hi everyone. Thank you for being here today, and for hearing me out. I feel stuck in a

  • tough situation and it's creating a really rough environment for me. Now, I'd like

  • to inform you that I will be touching on the topic of abuse in this video, and I will give

  • you a heads up before we dive in to that part. For ease of reference here are the time stamps

  • that you can work around. I want to make sure this is a safe space for myself and for the

  • viewers here.

  • I want to continue to share content online, but I don't feel safe doing so. I've been

  • relentlessly harassed online, as has the cohost on my podcast, who has received several death

  • threats, driving her to the point of wanting to quit. Despite my desire for privacy around

  • these challenging topics, I hope that by sharing some of my side of the story, some of the

  • commenters who have been most hurtful and aggressive will stop, or at least soften their

  • harassment of me and my friends.

  • Now, to those who don't think there's a problem here, you haven't seen the messages

  • I've received. Just yesterday I received this, and it's not the only instance; this

  • is a problem that has been ongoing for months. That's at one end of the spectrum. For those

  • of you on the opposite end of the spectrum, this is why I have been asking people to be

  • nice in the comments. Thank you to those of you being supportive and impartial. To others,

  • though, that have still been upset, and view their comments as honest, justified criticism,

  • I don't believe you have all the information, and therefore your criticism isn't accurate.

  • Unfortunately, I believe you've formed your opinion about me - not entirely, but in large

  • part - after being primed by Martina's emotionally charged comments.

  • I can understand why some of you feel so upset with me, and I'm sorry you've been led

  • to such hatred. There are two sides to every story, and I hope that you can hold space

  • for both. I am now going to share my side of the story about Meemers, my time in Hawaii,

  • and accusations of me being a Covert Narcissist. Please join me with an open mind.

  • Let's start with Meemers: As far as I'm aware, here's the narrative that has been

  • presented: Meemers is sick with life threatening Struvite Crystals, which is a blockage of

  • his urinary tract. These crystals are formed by stress, and because I have dogs, and dogs

  • stress cats, that's bad for Meemers' health. Also I live far away, and the drive will stress

  • Meemers, which is bad for his health too. And so, me wanting to continue to share custody

  • of Meemers is really selfish, and could kill him.

  • So, in terms of the Meemers situation, I think that's what I'm mainly hearing. This story

  • is definitely one that I can understand would be upsetting. As an animal lover, myself,

  • I'd be angry if I heard about someone insisting upon something that jeopardizes the health

  • of their pet, like when people force their cats on a vegan diet, and I can see how easy

  • it is for those people to feel angry in turn.

  • So, let's start here: let me say that Meemers wasn't sick in my care. He was using his

  • cat litter fine, drinking water regularly. He was on his prescription diet, all wet food,

  • and I gave him wet snacks throughout the day, in order to keep his water intake high. I

  • even found a special boutique shop that sells his favorite cat yoghurt like the ones Martina

  • and I gave him in Japan, which isn't really yoghurt, but a long thin package of wet food.

  • That's what would get him mlemming in all his pictures btw. (Cute 5sec vid of Meemers

  • doing that) I spoke with my veterinarian about the Struvite

  • crystals Meemers was experiencing. He told me that they're managed through a prescription

  • diet, and through ensuring that the cat drinks enough water, which is what I regularly provided

  • for him. I also asked my vet if it's ok for my cat to be alongside my two puppies,

  • and he said it's fine, so long as the diet and water intake are taken care of. Diet is

  • what the vet emphasized overall. So here comes the first part I'm struggling with: My vet

  • is telling me something different than what Martina's vet said. I can't say who is

  • better qualified, but I can say that my research into Struvite Crystals online also overwhelmingly

  • suggests that the condition can be managed through diet.

  • When Martina and I separated in May of 2020, we agreed to joint custody of Meemers. We

  • had agreed to have Meemers at my place for one month, and then hers the next. I brought

  • Meemers back to Canada in June of 2020, by myself, with no help. For those of you who've

  • travelled overseas with pets, you'll know how challenging a process this can be. During

  • our separation, his care and transport and papers were entirely my responsibility, and

  • his papers were under my name. When Martina came to Canada months later, she didn't

  • have his prescription food or litter ready, so I (rather than one of her friends or family

  • members) had to buy everything for her, and then set it up for in her mother's house

  • before she arrived. So now, let's talk about stress on Meemers;

  • Meemers and Fudgy got along fine. They both slept in bed with me, with Meemers at my head,

  • and Fudgy at my feet, and they'd touch noses in the morning. They were getting closer and

  • closer all the time. Then Fudgy would go off and do his puppy things while Meemers napped

  • in safe spaces made just for him, where Fudgy didn't have access. My place in Toronto

  • had two bedrooms, and Meemers had a whole room of his own, blocked off with baby gates,

  • and full of blankets, pillows and a dark closet. He would use it sometimes, though mostly he

  • hung around me and Fudgy, wherever we were around the apartment. Martina hasn't ever

  • witnessed Fudgy's behaviour around Meemers, because she's never been in my house. However,

  • I did see Meemers in Martina's house being bothered by her niece who really really loves

  • Meemers, while Meemers was trying to sleep, and this is something I raised as a concern

  • with Martina in private. And so, in regards to blaming Meemers' health

  • entirely on my home setting, I believe the narrative should be re-evaluated, and some

  • of the weights of that responsibility pie need to be redistributed.

  • Now, this isn't the first time Martina has tried to keep Meemers since our decision for

  • shared custody was made. Before Meemers' health was a concern, I was told to give up

  • Meemers because I had Fudgy; I was told it was not fair that I have an animal and she

  • doesn't. I don't believe that my getting a dog after the divorce means I forfeit the

  • right to my cat. If you have a child in your first marriage, you wouldn't be asked to

  • give up access to them because you had a second child. Pets are a blessing, and I hope that

  • Martina is able to enjoy the companionship of more animals in her life if she so chooses.

  • Later on, in January of 2021, after Martina began to publicly express her anger towards

  • me, she didn't want to return him to me because she thought I would give him Coronavirus,

  • and for his safety she couldn't give him back to me. The CDC said there's no evidence

  • of cat's getting Coronavirus. Unfortunately, our lawyers had to get involved in the matter,

  • since I didn't share the same concerns for cat Coronavirus.

  • Soon afterwards I was told that his Struvite Crystals have re-emerged, and Martina refused

  • to give him back to me as we had arranged. We eventually got back into sharing custody

  • of Meemers, but only for a couple more months. Once I started the process of moving from

  • Toronto to London, Martina started posting more online comments about Meemers' health.

  • She posted a comment that Meemers is 10, elderly, and that I live three hours away. None of

  • this is true.

  • Meemers was born around June 2012. When you were told he was 10, he was actually still

  • 8. 
 It was stated that he's elderly. According

  • to what I've read, elderly cats are aged 11 and up. I don't see anywhere that suggests

  • an 8 year old cat is elderly. If you become a senior at 60, it'd be like saying you're

  • a senior when you're 48 to get the Pharmacy discount. 


  • It was stated I live three hours away and that driving is bad for him. I live exactly

  • 168km away (Americans, it's kilometres, not miles). We both live a few minutes off

  • the highway, and from my experience it's an hour and a half on every ride I've taken.

  • And no, I don't drive 200km an hour. Also, for those of you who don't know/remember,

  • Meemers had these crystals at a very young age, back in Korea, and the vet at the time

  • emphasized the importance of a prescription diet and water intake. And, in Korea, we drove

  • him from our apartment to our studio daily, and brought him into a stressful working environment.

  • Meemers has been raised in changing environmentsAfter Martina's comments, I started receiving

  • much more harassment from commenters online and it really impacted my mental health, to

  • the point that I relinquished custody of Meemers in June. I had hoped that this would be enough

  • for Martina to be able to heal, process her emotions, and that we could move forward with

  • the goodwill we had originally intended. This is what I still want. Then, after all this

  • fighting for Meemers, I recently learned about Martina's decision to move back to Japan,

  • and that Meemers is being given over to her mom. I learned this from the comments in my

  • own post. So, that's my side of things with Meemers.

  • This has been a stressful situation for me, because I love my cat, and also because I

  • don't want to air our dirty laundry to you. We agreed to be respectful of each other online,

  • and to respect each other's privacy - it's section 3.1 in our separation agreement - and

  • it's been really hard for me to witness both her posts about Meemers' custody, and

  • the posts about myself, because I believe this stuff should be dealt with in private,

  • and it's what we agreed to.

  • When I was initially processing the divorce, I knew that it was going to be a very emotionally

  • challenging time, so I took a break from posting. I went through my emotions privately, with

  • lots and lots of therapy, and I'm glad I did. The 5 Stages of Divorce Grief are Denial,

  • Anger, Bargaining, Depression, and Acceptance. When I was going through the process and doing

  • the work, I was angry about Martina's past behaviour too - for her mistakes in our relationship,

  • for the hurts I felt. I also knew that posting that stuff online wouldn't be good for anyone.

  • If we only view ourselves as victims and others as transgressors, we're not going to learn

  • anything, and we're not going to heal. So, I worked through my stuff in private. I can

  • still feel compassion and consistent kindness towards Martina, because I know that just

  • like me, she makes mistakes and she struggles, we are human. It takes two to make a relationship

  • work, and it takes two to make it fail. And hearing only 1 side of private matters is

  • not going to give you an accurate picture.

  • So, Speaking of privacy, let's talk about Hawaii.

  • I went to Hawaii in January. I bought a ticket and boarded planes legally, along with many

  • other people. I took a Coronavirus test before flying out, another one immediately when I

  • landed in Hawaii, and then another immediately upon landing on the Big Island. Overall, I

  • took three tests from three different places in 72 hours, and all 3 were negative. I stayed

  • in a small house away from the tourist area of the island, not surfing and partying it

  • up. Instead, I spent my time meditating at isolated beaches, trying to figure out what

  • the fuck I was going to do with my life. I was actually making arrangements to move to

  • Hawaii in June, until the floods in the North Shore changed those plans for good.

  • My time in Hawaii wasn't something I wanted to share publicly, as it was a deeply private

  • personal trip. Mental health is incredibly important to me, and by going I was doing

  • something good for my mental health, in a time when it felt like the whole world was

  • falling the fuck apart. I didn't shoot videos there. I didn't want people to know about

  • it, and knowing that, Martina had and has no right to keep putting it online. What if

  • I were to post something private about her life and how she relates to the world?

  • I'm in a tough situation where I want to both honour our agreement, and not jeopardize

  • her relationship with her audience, the way my relationship with some viewers has been

  • soured, and I also just don't think it's wise to process our negative thoughts publicly,

  • especially while going through the heavy emotions of a divorce.

  • This situation is challenging me because:

  • I have my side of the story which I wanted to keep private

  • Martina is sharing things online when she's upset

  • Martina's angry posts are angering people and turning them against me

  • I want to honour our contract, and not cause Martina any harm.


  • Frankly, I don't know how to do this. Now I'm going to get into some heavier stuff,

  • so if some of you are triggered by talks of survivor abuse or narcissism, you can skip

  • past this section, to this part of the video here, if you feel comfortable to do so.

  • Ok. So, there's one last aspect I want to address: Martina has come forward as a survivor

  • of narcissistic abuse, and has told her audience that I am a covert narcissist. I'm really

  • hurt and honestly shocked that Martina feels that way.

  • From there, I don't know how to respond to this appropriately, so I apologize for

  • those offended or hurt in advance. I'm trying my best right now, and I worry that there

  • is no acceptable response to this. Being a survivor of abuse is a very serious title,

  • and claims for it should be taken seriously. At the same time, it seems like the qualifications

  • for being a covert narcissist cast a wide net. I fear anything I say is something a

  • narcissist would say, and narcissists are great at hiding their narcissism, so there

  • is no opening for me to address this. I will share with you that Narcissistic Personality

  • Disorder isn't the first diagnosis Martina has given me. Since the person who knows me

  • best made these claims about me, I took them to heart, and went to figure out how I can

  • fix myself, since I must still be fundamentally broken. All three of Martina's developmental/mental

  • health claims about me, I brought to therapy sessions with a licensed psychotherapist.

  • I've been assured that I'm not displaying any signs of the other two things I had been

  • name called in our marriage, and I've also been assured that I'm not displaying signs

  • of Narcissistic Personality Disorder. Lastly, I'd be remiss to not say that I can also

  • remember five other people she has given this label to before me, some of whom were excommunicated

  • from our lives.

  • I'm concerned that, even in expressing my side here, some people's opinions of me

  • will not soften. And this is a different problem, I think, with human understanding overall.

  • There are no heroes or villains in real life. There are no clearly good guys, no clearly

  • bad guys. TV, movie, and literature tropes give us this idea of the protagonist being

  • the embodiment of good while villains are pure evil. And this is just not realistic.

  • It's decontextualizing, dehumanizing, and uncompassionate.

  • I have seen in some comments people fishing for evidence of my being evil through old

  • videos. “Remember when he brought Martina coffee and it got cold? Proof that he was

  • shitty all along! Remember that time he playfully stole food on camera? This is how Simon must

  • have been off camera too!” Movies do a good job of fostering this kind of smoking gun

  • mentality: when the bad guy is revealed, and it's a surprise, then the movie gives you

  • a flashback that shows you the signs that you missed early on in the movie. “See!

  • The evidence is all there, in the background!” People aren't that simple, though. Movies

  • are unrealistic depictions of human interaction, and some people use these depictions as frameworks

  • for their own relationships. Yes, I have caused harm in my life, so has Martina, so have you,

  • and all of us, in more ways than we know. We are human beings, growing and evolving

  • and trying our best to understand how this world works, and sometimes we don't get

  • it right. Often we don't get it right in relationships.

  • Thank you for making it this far. I'd like to end off with a couple small requests. If

  • you're still angry towards me, please just ignore me. Voicing your anger towards me is

  • not good for our mental health, yours and mine. Secondly, please stop harassing my cohost

  • Aliana. She has nothing to do with this. Aliana and I are friends, we are not dating, and

  • have never dated, and she's being harassed online so much.

  • Please, if you have nothing nice to say, leave her alone. If you don't like me, and you

  • see something of mine that upsets you, please just ignore it and direct that energy towards

  • being extra supportive of Martina's content. Don't use that energy to hurt people.

  • And for those of you who have not gotten wrapped up in this, thank you. Thank you for holding

  • space for my pain and for listening. I'm sorry that I've given more attention to

  • the negative comments than to you lately. I'm working on redirecting my energy, and

  • not being affected so much by negative comments, but goddamn it's so hard. I hope for a future

  • where we can have a safer, more inclusive and supportive community.

Hi everyone. Thank you for being here today, and for hearing me out. I feel stuck in a

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it