Subtitles section Play video Print subtitles Hi everyone. Thank you for being here today, and for hearing me out. I feel stuck in a tough situation and it's creating a really rough environment for me. Now, I'd like to inform you that I will be touching on the topic of abuse in this video, and I will give you a heads up before we dive in to that part. For ease of reference here are the time stamps that you can work around. I want to make sure this is a safe space for myself and for the viewers here. I want to continue to share content online, but I don't feel safe doing so. I've been relentlessly harassed online, as has the cohost on my podcast, who has received several death threats, driving her to the point of wanting to quit. Despite my desire for privacy around these challenging topics, I hope that by sharing some of my side of the story, some of the commenters who have been most hurtful and aggressive will stop, or at least soften their harassment of me and my friends. Now, to those who don't think there's a problem here, you haven't seen the messages I've received. Just yesterday I received this, and it's not the only instance; this is a problem that has been ongoing for months. That's at one end of the spectrum. For those of you on the opposite end of the spectrum, this is why I have been asking people to be nice in the comments. Thank you to those of you being supportive and impartial. To others, though, that have still been upset, and view their comments as honest, justified criticism, I don't believe you have all the information, and therefore your criticism isn't accurate. Unfortunately, I believe you've formed your opinion about me - not entirely, but in large part - after being primed by Martina's emotionally charged comments. I can understand why some of you feel so upset with me, and I'm sorry you've been led to such hatred. There are two sides to every story, and I hope that you can hold space for both. I am now going to share my side of the story about Meemers, my time in Hawaii, and accusations of me being a Covert Narcissist. Please join me with an open mind. Let's start with Meemers: As far as I'm aware, here's the narrative that has been presented: Meemers is sick with life threatening Struvite Crystals, which is a blockage of his urinary tract. These crystals are formed by stress, and because I have dogs, and dogs stress cats, that's bad for Meemers' health. Also I live far away, and the drive will stress Meemers, which is bad for his health too. And so, me wanting to continue to share custody of Meemers is really selfish, and could kill him. So, in terms of the Meemers situation, I think that's what I'm mainly hearing. This story is definitely one that I can understand would be upsetting. As an animal lover, myself, I'd be angry if I heard about someone insisting upon something that jeopardizes the health of their pet, like when people force their cats on a vegan diet, and I can see how easy it is for those people to feel angry in turn. So, let's start here: let me say that Meemers wasn't sick in my care. He was using his cat litter fine, drinking water regularly. He was on his prescription diet, all wet food, and I gave him wet snacks throughout the day, in order to keep his water intake high. I even found a special boutique shop that sells his favorite cat yoghurt like the ones Martina and I gave him in Japan, which isn't really yoghurt, but a long thin package of wet food. That's what would get him mlemming in all his pictures btw. (Cute 5sec vid of Meemers doing that) I spoke with my veterinarian about the Struvite crystals Meemers was experiencing. He told me that they're managed through a prescription diet, and through ensuring that the cat drinks enough water, which is what I regularly provided for him. I also asked my vet if it's ok for my cat to be alongside my two puppies, and he said it's fine, so long as the diet and water intake are taken care of. Diet is what the vet emphasized overall. So here comes the first part I'm struggling with: My vet is telling me something different than what Martina's vet said. I can't say who is better qualified, but I can say that my research into Struvite Crystals online also overwhelmingly suggests that the condition can be managed through diet. When Martina and I separated in May of 2020, we agreed to joint custody of Meemers. We had agreed to have Meemers at my place for one month, and then hers the next. I brought Meemers back to Canada in June of 2020, by myself, with no help. For those of you who've travelled overseas with pets, you'll know how challenging a process this can be. During our separation, his care and transport and papers were entirely my responsibility, and his papers were under my name. When Martina came to Canada months later, she didn't have his prescription food or litter ready, so I (rather than one of her friends or family members) had to buy everything for her, and then set it up for in her mother's house before she arrived. So now, let's talk about stress on Meemers; Meemers and Fudgy got along fine. They both slept in bed with me, with Meemers at my head, and Fudgy at my feet, and they'd touch noses in the morning. They were getting closer and closer all the time. Then Fudgy would go off and do his puppy things while Meemers napped in safe spaces made just for him, where Fudgy didn't have access. My place in Toronto had two bedrooms, and Meemers had a whole room of his own, blocked off with baby gates, and full of blankets, pillows and a dark closet. He would use it sometimes, though mostly he hung around me and Fudgy, wherever we were around the apartment. Martina hasn't ever witnessed Fudgy's behaviour around Meemers, because she's never been in my house. However, I did see Meemers in Martina's house being bothered by her niece who really really loves Meemers, while Meemers was trying to sleep, and this is something I raised as a concern with Martina in private. And so, in regards to blaming Meemers' health entirely on my home setting, I believe the narrative should be re-evaluated, and some of the weights of that responsibility pie need to be redistributed. Now, this isn't the first time Martina has tried to keep Meemers since our decision for shared custody was made. Before Meemers' health was a concern, I was told to give up Meemers because I had Fudgy; I was told it was not fair that I have an animal and she doesn't. I don't believe that my getting a dog after the divorce means I forfeit the right to my cat. If you have a child in your first marriage, you wouldn't be asked to give up access to them because you had a second child. Pets are a blessing, and I hope that Martina is able to enjoy the companionship of more animals in her life if she so chooses. Later on, in January of 2021, after Martina began to publicly express her anger towards me, she didn't want to return him to me because she thought I would give him Coronavirus, and for his safety she couldn't give him back to me. The CDC said there's no evidence of cat's getting Coronavirus. Unfortunately, our lawyers had to get involved in the matter, since I didn't share the same concerns for cat Coronavirus. Soon afterwards I was told that his Struvite Crystals have re-emerged, and Martina refused to give him back to me as we had arranged. We eventually got back into sharing custody of Meemers, but only for a couple more months. Once I started the process of moving from Toronto to London, Martina started posting more online comments about Meemers' health. She posted a comment that Meemers is 10, elderly, and that I live three hours away. None of this is true. Meemers was born around June 2012. When you were told he was 10, he was actually still 8. It was stated that he's elderly. According to what I've read, elderly cats are aged 11 and up. I don't see anywhere that suggests an 8 year old cat is elderly. If you become a senior at 60, it'd be like saying you're a senior when you're 48 to get the Pharmacy discount. It was stated I live three hours away and that driving is bad for him. I live exactly 168km away (Americans, it's kilometres, not miles). We both live a few minutes off the highway, and from my experience it's an hour and a half on every ride I've taken. And no, I don't drive 200km an hour. Also, for those of you who don't know/remember, Meemers had these crystals at a very young age, back in Korea, and the vet at the time emphasized the importance of a prescription diet and water intake. And, in Korea, we drove him from our apartment to our studio daily, and brought him into a stressful working environment. Meemers has been raised in changing environments After Martina's comments, I started receiving much more harassment from commenters online and it really impacted my mental health, to the point that I relinquished custody of Meemers in June. I had hoped that this would be enough for Martina to be able to heal, process her emotions, and that we could move forward with the goodwill we had originally intended. This is what I still want. Then, after all this fighting for Meemers, I recently learned about Martina's decision to move back to Japan, and that Meemers is being given over to her mom. I learned this from the comments in my own post. So, that's my side of things with Meemers. This has been a stressful situation for me, because I love my cat, and also because I don't want to air our dirty laundry to you. We agreed to be respectful of each other online, and to respect each other's privacy - it's section 3.1 in our separation agreement - and it's been really hard for me to witness both her posts about Meemers' custody, and the posts about myself, because I believe this stuff should be dealt with in private, and it's what we agreed to. When I was initially processing the divorce, I knew that it was going to be a very emotionally challenging time, so I took a break from posting. I went through my emotions privately, with lots and lots of therapy, and I'm glad I did. The 5 Stages of Divorce Grief are Denial, Anger, Bargaining, Depression, and Acceptance. When I was going through the process and doing the work, I was angry about Martina's past behaviour too - for her mistakes in our relationship, for the hurts I felt. I also knew that posting that stuff online wouldn't be good for anyone. If we only view ourselves as victims and others as transgressors, we're not going to learn anything, and we're not going to heal. So, I worked through my stuff in private. I can still feel compassion and consistent kindness towards Martina, because I know that just like me, she makes mistakes and she struggles, we are human. It takes two to make a relationship work, and it takes two to make it fail. And hearing only 1 side of private matters is not going to give you an accurate picture. So, Speaking of privacy, let's talk about Hawaii. I went to Hawaii in January. I bought a ticket and boarded planes legally, along with many other people. I took a Coronavirus test before flying out, another one immediately when I landed in Hawaii, and then another immediately upon landing on the Big Island. Overall, I took three tests from three different places in 72 hours, and all 3 were negative. I stayed in a small house away from the tourist area of the island, not surfing and partying it up. Instead, I spent my time meditating at isolated beaches, trying to figure out what the fuck I was going to do with my life. I was actually making arrangements to move to Hawaii in June, until the floods in the North Shore changed those plans for good. My time in Hawaii wasn't something I wanted to share publicly, as it was a deeply private personal trip. Mental health is incredibly important to me, and by going I was doing something good for my mental health, in a time when it felt like the whole world was falling the fuck apart. I didn't shoot videos there. I didn't want people to know about it, and knowing that, Martina had and has no right to keep putting it online. What if I were to post something private about her life and how she relates to the world? I'm in a tough situation where I want to both honour our agreement, and not jeopardize her relationship with her audience, the way my relationship with some viewers has been soured, and I also just don't think it's wise to process our negative thoughts publicly, especially while going through the heavy emotions of a divorce. This situation is challenging me because: I have my side of the story which I wanted to keep private Martina is sharing things online when she's upset Martina's angry posts are angering people and turning them against me I want to honour our contract, and not cause Martina any harm. Frankly, I don't know how to do this. Now I'm going to get into some heavier stuff, so if some of you are triggered by talks of survivor abuse or narcissism, you can skip past this section, to this part of the video here, if you feel comfortable to do so. Ok. So, there's one last aspect I want to address: Martina has come forward as a survivor of narcissistic abuse, and has told her audience that I am a covert narcissist. I'm really hurt and honestly shocked that Martina feels that way. From there, I don't know how to respond to this appropriately, so I apologize for those offended or hurt in advance. I'm trying my best right now, and I worry that there is no acceptable response to this. Being a survivor of abuse is a very serious title, and claims for it should be taken seriously. At the same time, it seems like the qualifications for being a covert narcissist cast a wide net. I fear anything I say is something a narcissist would say, and narcissists are great at hiding their narcissism, so there is no opening for me to address this. I will share with you that Narcissistic Personality Disorder isn't the first diagnosis Martina has given me. Since the person who knows me best made these claims about me, I took them to heart, and went to figure out how I can fix myself, since I must still be fundamentally broken. All three of Martina's developmental/mental health claims about me, I brought to therapy sessions with a licensed psychotherapist. I've been assured that I'm not displaying any signs of the other two things I had been name called in our marriage, and I've also been assured that I'm not displaying signs of Narcissistic Personality Disorder. Lastly, I'd be remiss to not say that I can also remember five other people she has given this label to before me, some of whom were excommunicated from our lives. I'm concerned that, even in expressing my side here, some people's opinions of me will not soften. And this is a different problem, I think, with human understanding overall. There are no heroes or villains in real life. There are no clearly good guys, no clearly bad guys. TV, movie, and literature tropes give us this idea of the protagonist being the embodiment of good while villains are pure evil. And this is just not realistic. It's decontextualizing, dehumanizing, and uncompassionate. I have seen in some comments people fishing for evidence of my being evil through old videos. “Remember when he brought Martina coffee and it got cold? Proof that he was shitty all along! Remember that time he playfully stole food on camera? This is how Simon must have been off camera too!” Movies do a good job of fostering this kind of smoking gun mentality: when the bad guy is revealed, and it's a surprise, then the movie gives you a flashback that shows you the signs that you missed early on in the movie. “See! The evidence is all there, in the background!” People aren't that simple, though. Movies are unrealistic depictions of human interaction, and some people use these depictions as frameworks for their own relationships. Yes, I have caused harm in my life, so has Martina, so have you, and all of us, in more ways than we know. We are human beings, growing and evolving and trying our best to understand how this world works, and sometimes we don't get it right. Often we don't get it right in relationships. Thank you for making it this far. I'd like to end off with a couple small requests. If you're still angry towards me, please just ignore me. Voicing your anger towards me is not good for our mental health, yours and mine. Secondly, please stop harassing my cohost Aliana. She has nothing to do with this. Aliana and I are friends, we are not dating, and have never dated, and she's being harassed online so much. Please, if you have nothing nice to say, leave her alone. If you don't like me, and you see something of mine that upsets you, please just ignore it and direct that energy towards being extra supportive of Martina's content. Don't use that energy to hurt people. And for those of you who have not gotten wrapped up in this, thank you. Thank you for holding space for my pain and for listening. I'm sorry that I've given more attention to the negative comments than to you lately. I'm working on redirecting my energy, and not being affected so much by negative comments, but goddamn it's so hard. I hope for a future where we can have a safer, more inclusive and supportive community.
B1 meemers health online custody diet hawaii Simon's Side of the Story 5 0 Summer posted on 2021/09/18 More Share Save Report Video vocabulary