Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • Our deepest longing is to have stable, satisfying relationships,

  • but the painful fact is that very large numbers of relationships have one painful episode after another,

  • or seemingly intractable miserable conflicts running through them.

  • It's one of the biggest questions there is: why is it so hard to be happy in love?

  • The huge and not yet fully digested insight of psychoanalysis

  • is that the challenges of relationships always start when we were children.

  • It was the contribution of a great English psychoanalyst called John Bowlby,

  • to trace the tensions and conflicts we have with our partners

  • back to our earliest experiences of maternal care.

  • His ideas are sound,

  • in part because he drew so deeply and honestly on his own experiences in order to formulate them.

  • Born in 1907, Bowlby had a quintessentially upper-class British childhood.

  • Yet Bowlby hardly saw his parents and was looked after by a nanny, who was let go when he was just four,

  • leaving young Bowlby bereft.

  • At seven, he was sent off, and lying with the conventions of his class, to boarding school.

  • He hated it, and later declared, "I wouldn't send a dog away to boarding school at the age of seven."

  • Bowlby became a brilliant medical student and an imaginative researcher.

  • When he was a consultant to the World Health Association in the early 1950s, Bowlby wrote a report:

  • "Maternal Care and Mental Health."'

  • He attacked prevalent assumptions and argued that kindness doesn't smother and spoil children.

  • "It's as if maternal care were as necessary for the proper development of personality

  • as vitamin D for the development of bones," he wrote.

  • This insight initiated a wave of reform.

  • The visitation rules of many health institutions were reformed to allow parents to stay with their children,

  • where they'd once been allowed only to visit and never to touch.

  • It sounds like a dry, bureaucratic move,

  • but it ended countless afternoons of quiet sorrow and evenings of solitary anguish.

  • In a book published in 1959 called, "Separation Anxiety,"

  • Bowlby looks at happens when there isn't enough of this kind of parental care.

  • He described the behavior of children he'd observed

  • who'd been separated from their parents.

  • If the child is separated for too long, they still crave the attention, love, and interest of the parents,

  • but feel that anything good may disappear at any moment.

  • They look for a lot of reassurance, and get upset if it's not forthcoming.

  • They become volatile,

  • they take heart, and then they despair, and then they're filled with hope again.

  • This is the pattern of what Bowlby called, "anxious attachment."

  • But the degree of separation from the parents may lead to another sort of problem.

  • The child could feel so helpless, they become what Bowlby called, "detached."

  • They enter their own world to protect themselves,

  • and become remote and cold.

  • They experience what Bowlby calls, "avoidant attachment."

  • That is, they seek tenderness, closeness, emotional investment as always dangerous and to be shunned.

  • They may, in truth, be desperate for a cuddle over reassurance, but such things look far too treacherous.

  • The focus of Bowlby's thinking

  • was about what happens to a child if there are too many difficulties in forming secure attachments.

  • But the consequences don't magically get restricted only to the age of 8, or 12, or 17--

  • they're lifelong.

  • Our attachment style is fed by our earliest experiences.

  • It's a pre-existing script that gets written into our adult relationships,

  • usually without us even realizing that this has happened.

  • In lying with Bowlby's views about how children relate to their parents,

  • there are three basic kinds of attachment we can have to other adults.

  • Firstly: secure attachment.

  • This is the rare ideal.

  • When you are securely attached, if there's a problem, you'll work it out.

  • You aren't appalled by the weakness of your partner.

  • If your partner's a bit down, confused, or being a bit annoying,

  • you don't react too wildly,

  • because even if they can't be nice to you, you can take care of yourself and,

  • have hopefully, a little time left over to meet some of the needs of your partner.

  • You give the other the benefit of the doubt when interpreting behavior.

  • You realize that maybe they had a tricky time at work; that's why they're not so interested in your day.

  • The explanations are accommodating, generous, and usually more accurate.

  • But there's another kind of attachment: anxious attachment--

  • and this is marked by clingyness.

  • Texting and calling all the time just to check where the other is and keep tabs on what they're up to.

  • You need to make sure they have a bus and haven't left you or the country.

  • Anxiously attached people become coercive and demanding,

  • and focus on their own needs, not their partner's.

  • Anxious attachment involves a lot of anger;

  • because the stakes feel so high,

  • a minor slight, a hasty word, a tiny oversight

  • could look, to the anxiously attached person, like huge threats.

  • They seem to announce the imminent breakup of the whole relationship.

  • One feels,

  • "The reason you don't tell me that the minestrone soup I made is delicious is that you don't love me and are planning to leave me,"

  • when the true explanation may simply be that one's partner is mulling over

  • a very tricky bit of news about a contract at work.

  • "Avoidant attachment" means that you would rather withdraw and go away

  • than compromise, get angry, or even just getting close to another person.

  • If there's a problem, you don't talk.

  • Your instinct is to say you don't mean to the other person, especially if you're lonely.

  • Avoidant spouses often team up with anxious ones.

  • It's a risky combination;

  • the avoidant one doesn't give the anxious one much support,

  • and the anxious one is always invading the delicate privacy of the avoidant one.

  • Bowlby helps us to feel more generous, and more constructive

  • about what these partners are doing when they upset or disappoint us.

  • Almost no one, in truth, is purely anxious or purely avoidant--

  • we're just a bit like that some of the time.

  • So, alerted by Bowlby, we can see that a partner's apparent coldness and indifference

  • is not caused by their loathing of us,

  • but by the fact that a long time ago, they were probably rather badly hurt by intimacy.

  • And it opens possibilities of self-knowledge,

  • which can help one reform, if only a little, one's own mother's eccentric behavior.

  • [The latest research shows that in the UK population:

  • 56 percent are securely attached;

  • 24 percent are avoidantly attached;

  • 20 percent are anxiously attached]

Our deepest longing is to have stable, satisfying relationships,

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it