Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • George Eliot's Old Grandfather  Rode A Pig Home Yesterday.  

  • Mnemonics are great for trying to  remember our 4th grade spelling words.  

  • But actually deciding what that word  geography means is a bit trickier.

  • Sure, we memorize state and world capitals  [because everyone's impressed if you can  

  • rattle them off - like the capital of CanadaOttawa.] Or we learn that rivers flow downhill  

  • or that the US imports more than 3 billion  pounds of bananas from Guatemala each year

  • And those are cool factoids, but  that's not all Geography is.  

  • Geography helps us answer bigger questions like  "what's the story of the Earth?", "how do humans  

  • change their environments?", and "why, of all  places, did that huge mountain form there?"

  • There's a lot to cover in this series  because geography encompasses all 4.5  

  • billion years or so of the Earth's history  and even makes predictions about our future.  

  • So we're going to do our best to highlight  the weirdest, most awe-inspiring parts

  • I'm Alizé Carrère and welcome  to Crash Course Geography.

  • Let's take a closer look at that last factoid  I threw out and... go a little bananas.  

  • It might come in handy at a trivia game to know  the volume of the US-Guatemala banana trade,  

  • but there must be more to the storyLike, why Guatemala? And why bananas?

  • In geography, we use those questions  to better understand the connections  

  • between us and the physical worldSo today, let's start in Guatemala.

  • We think of the land now called  Guatemala as part of Central America,  

  • a region between North and South America  that's covered with dense rainforests  

  • and incredible biodiversity. To look just at Guatemala,  

  • we'd jump between 13°45' and 17°48' north  latitude and 88°14' and 92°13' west longitude.

  • We could even give the absolute locationor geographic coordinates, of different  

  • geographic points of interest in Guatemala, from  Volcan de Fuego to the Mayan ruins at Tikal

  • From there we might notice the physical  environment -- like the climate,  

  • the landforms, or the rivers and waterwaysGuatemala is a mountainous country with both  

  • recently active and long dormant volcanoes  that have provided rich, fertile soil.

  • With soil like this, it seems like there's  no shortage of options for what would grow,  

  • and yet...bananas.

  • It turns out, to be successful, bananas need  to grow at a temperature between 20 and 35  

  • degrees celsius -- Guatemala's tropical regions  range between 18 and 35 degrees. Bananas need  

  • about 170 centimeters of rain a year -- most of  Guatemala gets between 70 and 200 centimeters.  

  • And bananas need well-drained soils rich  i n potassium -- Guatemala's volcanoes  

  • spew rocks rich in iron, magnesiumand -- you guessed it -- potassium.

  • What we're doing here is identifying the spaceor the features and relationships that occur in a  

  • given area. Basically it's the cold, hard facts  about a specific location on Earth's surface.  

  • We need to pinpoint where we're interested in,  

  • before we can start to answer  why various things happen there.

  • Working with the idea of space is one of  the defining characteristics of geography,  

  • and we'll get into even more  specifics in later episodes.

  • Historically, maps, and more recently,  

  • satellite images are tools that  help define and quantify space.

  • But there are plenty of non-spatial things  we might already have in our minds about  

  • Guatemala and Central America. For examplethat it's long been home to large populations  

  • of indigenous peoples including Mayan  groups like the K'iche', Kaqchikel, and Mam,  

  • and non-Mayan groups like the XincaOr that it's a region known for its  

  • history of empires like the Mayan or  those created by Spanish colonizers.

  • Guatemala has been known by many names  including Cuauhtēmallān, a name given to  

  • the area by Tlaxcalan warriors accompanying  Spanish Conquistadors. Like almost any land  

  • or mountain or stretch of sea, “Guatemala”  means different things to different people.

  • It's a place, or somewhere that has attached  value, meaning, and emotion to it that can't  

  • be measured. It's subjective, for surebut a place can be observed and described  

  • to others. We can think of place as the  significance attached to a particular space.

  • So as we try to better understand the significance  of bananas and how they fit into Guatemala, the  

  • space and the place, we'd learn bananas actually  aren't native to Guatemala or even the Americas

  • Explorers and missionaries brought bananas  to Central America in the 1500s from the  

  • areas near present-day Indonesia and Papua  New Guinea where bananas grow natively.

  • Thinking about where bananas  can grow in Guatemala and why  

  • adds another layer to our  geographical investigation. After all,  

  • almost one out of every three people in the  workforce works in agriculture as of 2020.

  • So the next chapter in theGeography  of Guatemalan Banana Importsstory  

  • is thinking about interactions  humans have with the environment.

  • In geography, human-environment interactions  are all the ways humans connect with and live  

  • within the environment and the impact  the environment has on lives, choices,  

  • and experiences of peopleThis is key to geographers.

  • So in Guatemala, where there's enough  flat land and fertile soil and it's not  

  • too hot or cold or dry or wet, humans  might decide to grow bananas. But that  

  • still doesn't tell us how bananas  came to be one of the main crops  

  • grown in Guatemala or why there's so much  trade in bananas specifically with the US.

  • If we think about demand economics, one answer  for why the US imports more than 3 billion pounds  

  • of bananas from Guatemala each year is because  there are no tariffs or import restrictions,  

  • and transportation costs are fairly low.

  • Other banana hotspots like EcuadorPanama, and India are a bit farther away,  

  • so transportation is more expensiveThe greater the ocean distance,  

  • the higher the price. But  that's not the whole story

  • To this day, the agriculture industry  in Guatemala relies on the plantation,  

  • which is a large scale commercial enterprise that  just produces one crop and mostly exports it.

  • Plantations arrived in Guatemala with  European explorers colonizing the Americas.  

  • But they can also be found in other parts of the  world that experienced colonialism, like cocoa  

  • plantations in the West Indies, tea plantations  in Sri Lanka, and cotton plantations in the US.

  • No matter where they're located, using  plantations has had long lasting consequences  

  • we still contend with today. To peel back  the layers, let's go to the Thought Bubble.

  • Bananas first became popular as a “rare and  delicious treatin the United States in the  

  • late 19th century --even though they'd long  been a diet staple in many tropical regions.  

  • Sensing an opportunity, American businessmen like  

  • Minor C. Keith and Andrew Preston started  importing them from around Latin America.

  • The two men were forced to merge their  lucrative banana empires in 1899.

  • Tropical Trading and Transport Company in  Central America joined with the Boston Fruit  

  • Company that dominated the Caribbean, creating  the soon-to-be-infamous United Fruit Company.

  • Along with others, it would become so  powerful that in 1901 the author O.  

  • Henry described countries like Honduras  and Guatemala asbanana republics”-- a  

  • reference to the vast control the fruit  companies wielded over many nations.

  • For example, in 1904, Keith, as vice  president of United Fruit, signed an  

  • exclusive deal with President Manuel Estrada  Cabrera that gave the company tax-exemptions,  

  • land grants, and control of all railroads  on the Atlantic side of Guatemala.

  • By the 1930s United Fruit was the  largest landholder in Guatemala

  • Across Latin America they became embroiled in  violent disputes, like the 1928 Banana Massacre in  

  • Colombia that was immortalized in Gabriel Garcia  Marquez's great novel, “100 Years of Solitude.”

  • Or the 1934 Great Banana Strike that eventually  led to the creation of trade unions in Costa Rica.

  • Or in 1954 when they lobbied the US government  to stage a coup and depose the Guatemalan  

  • president when hoarded United Fruit land  was being redistributed. Which the US did.

  • They had to be politically  involved to keep control.

  • A US-backed military dictatorship  didn't actually help their stock value,  

  • but such a big and profitable company  had connections across the US government  

  • and were able to set up agreements that  persist in some form or other today.

  • Which means that the US still gets  most of its bananas from Guatemala.

  • Thanks Thought Bubble! It might seem like  we've confused History for Geography,  

  • but the sordid past of the  banana isn't in the past at all.

  • You might not have heard of United Fruit, but  you've probably seen the label in grocery stores  

  • or heard of Chiquita bananas. The United  Fruit Company eventually became Chiquita  

  • Brands International in 1984, which is still  the number one US supplier of bananas today

  • Basically, banana plantations have hadhuge influence on the unequal distribution  

  • of land and wealth, leading to peasant  uprisings, repressive military regimes,  

  • and the growing economic  inequalities in Guatemala.

  • Entire books could be written  on the last 150 years of banana  

  • trade and they'd read like political thrillers.

  • So with fertile soil, the political power  structure, the rise of colonialism, and Europeans  

  • swooping in to create plantations...bananas  have been stamped into Guatemalan history.

  • Wow! All that from just one little factoid about a  

  • fruit you can buy in pretty much  any corner store across the US.  

  • I told you that Geography was complicated! And  every factoid actually has a story behind it.

  • But there are always more questionsLike, if we focus on the environment  

  • part of human-environment interactions, what's the  environmental impact of these large plantations?

  • And this is just Guatemala. What about the other  places in the world where bananas growCosta  

  • Rica, Panama, and the Dominican Republic. What's  the story associated with their banana exports?

  • And that's why just the factoid you  learned in 4th grade alone isn't geography.  

  • Geography is that factoid and  the story that surrounds it.

  • We just looked at the geography of bananas, but  we could have done the same thing for chocolate.  

  • Or the Nile River valley. Or  heat islands in the Chicago area.  

  • The Earth has so many stories, and  geography is here to tell them!

  • Clearly, the world is complicated. But  in geography we try to look at the big  

  • picturethe confluence of spaceplace, and the human and environment  

  • interactions and how they've overlapped  to bring us this far into the story.

  • This is what makes geography  a spatial scienceit's all  

  • about how things vary from place  to place and askingwhy here?” 

  • No two places are the same, but when we ask  questions to learn more about one place,  

  • we just might be able to explain  what is happening in another place.

  • Of course, geographers are going to  make mistakes because we're curious,  

  • imperfect, wonderful humans. And there will  be so many more moments where we go bananas  

  • and realize what we thought was justcool fact actually has a huge backstory.

  • There's a whole team working on Crash Course  Geography trying hard to avoid making mistakes,  

  • but we also know that when we tell  a story we make certain assumptions,  

  • or we have to leave out facts to make sure there's  a beginning, middle, and end in a 10 minute video.

  • So as we move through this series and  learn together, let's all try to think  

  • about the interconnectedness of Earth and  its peoples and economies and histories.  

  • And the fact that a banana factoid can  be way more complicated than we expect.

  • That's what will make us all a little  more thoughtful and geographically aware.

  • So, what is geography? It's so much more than just  identifying cities and countries and capitals on a  

  • map. Geographers look to find connections between  the physical processes at work on Earth's surface  

  • (and under the surface too) and how  people use and interact with the Earth.

  • Next time, we'll look at one of the  most useful tools that geographers use:  

  • maps. Maps tell their own story, and can even  be made specifically to tell a particular story.

  • Many maps and borders represent modern  geopolitical divisions that have often  

  • been decided without the consultation, permissionor recognition of the land's original inhabitants.  

  • Many geographical place names also don't  reflect the Indigenous or Arboriginal  

  • peoples languages. So we at Crash Course want  to acknowledge these peoples' traditional and  

  • ongoing relationship with that land and all the  physical and human geographical elements of it.

  • We encourage you to learn about  the history of the place you call  

  • home through resources like native-lands.ca  and by engaging with your local Indigenous  

  • and Aboriginal nations through the  websites and resources they provide.

  • Thanks for watching this episode of  Crash Course Geography which was made  

  • with the help of all these nice peopleIf you would like to help keep all Crash  

  • Course free for everyone, forever, please  consider joining our community on Patreon.

George Eliot's Old Grandfather  Rode A Pig Home Yesterday.  

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it