Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • On a Monday night in September 2015, in a little town outside New Delhi,

  • an angry mob showed up to the house of man named Mohammad Akhlaq.

  • The mob hit Akhlaq's elderly mother. They severely injured his son and then, they found Akhlaq.

  • They dragged him on to the street and they beat him with bricks until he immediately died.

  • The reason Akhlaq was killed, the anger from this mob

  • came from a rumor, a rumor that he was carrying beef.

  • "56 year old Muslim man was beaten to death by an allegedly Hindu mob."

  • An investigation was immediately launched.

  • Not only into Akhlaq's murder, but also into whether or not he truly was carrying beef.

  • 18 suspects were identified, but now, four years later,

  • the trial hasn't even begun yet. In fact, the accused are out on bail,

  • which has led to fear among the victim's family and community.

  • Earlier this year, one of the accused was invited to sit in the front row of a political rally.

  • He later claimed that 16 of the accused were in the audience that day.

  • Aklhaq's murder isn't an isolated incident.

  • Here in a town in eastern India, two Muslim

  • cattle traders, one of them just 13, we're driving to a fair to

  • sell their cows when they were stopped by a group of men, who beat them and hanged

  • them from a tree where, they both died. Over the last seven years hundreds of

  • Indians have been attacked, many killed. This violence has affected some Hindus

  • and other minorities, but the majority of the victims are Muslims.

  • All these incidents plotted on the map have one thing in common: they're all directly tied to cows.

  • But these attacks like this weren't always this prevalent.

  • In 2012, there was just one such attack in all of India.

  • The next year there were just two.

  • But then in 2014, something changed.

  • Look at the rise every year since.

  • And if you look closer at what's actually happening

  • on the ground, you can start to see exactly why these violent attacks are on the rise.

  • "Showing violence by so-called cow vigilantes in India."

  • "Self-appointed guardians of cows, which are sacred to Hindus claim they're being

  • illegally slaughtered. Not afraid to use violence to stop them."

  • There are millions of stray cows in India.

  • These cows don't belong to anyone.

  • They are usually past the age where they can be productive on farms and so

  • they're just set free to roam the country and you see them everywhere.

  • Cows are considered sacred in Hinduism and the majority of India's 1.3 billion people identify as Hindu.

  • Cows are generally revered by Hindus, many of whom abstain from eating beef,

  • but many Indians practice religions that don't share that same belief.

  • While transporting and trading cows isn't always illegal in the country,

  • slaughtering cows is banned in most of India's states. In some parts of the

  • country, especially those in the northern region, the police go on raids looking

  • for people who are breaking these cow protection laws, but in recent years,

  • it's not just the police cracking down.

  • These are cow vigilantes.

  • "Once again, the beef brigade has taken law in its own hands in this country."

  • "This is one of several viral video showing violence by so-called cow vigilantes in India."

  • "A resident of Haryana's Mewat district was transporting two cows in

  • his vehicle when he was beaten to death."

  • They're almost always groups of young men piling into SUVs to patrol the highways at night.

  • They'll take whatever weapons they have. Rifles or like small handmade guns. Then, they'll raid the highways

  • looking for any vehicle. Sometimes they'll have police around with them.

  • Sometimes they will be on the phone with the police. That's Snigdha Poonam.

  • She's a national affairs writer with The Hindustan Times in Delhi.

  • And I've been one of these vehicles with them for a

  • midnight raid and everyone has to stop,

  • even if it's like a group of young people driving late at night, they have

  • to stop and these cow protectors can do with them as they please.

  • If these vigilantes hear about someone

  • who's in possession of a cow or is carrying beef, sometimes they will turn

  • them over to the police, but more and more, they've been using violence on their own.

  • Often they make videos and then, that starts passing around on Facebook and Whatsapp.

  • Many cow vigilante's have ties with Hindu militant groups that specifically

  • target Muslims and other religious minorities. According to a Human Rights Watch report,

  • between 2015 and 2018, of the 44 cow-related deaths, 36 of them were Muslim.

  • To understand why these attacks have surged during this time you have to

  • look at the rise of one of India's biggest political parties.

  • "It's interesting to take a look at why and how this has become

  • such a massive landslide in terms of seats has been unprecedented. 70 seats for the BJP."

  • In 2014, India's Hindu nationalist party called Bharatiya Janata Party or BJP won

  • the national elections and that made the leader of the party, Narendra Modi, the Prime minister of India.

  • His political platform has long been this idea of

  • Hindu nationalism and a big focus of his speeches has been the protection of cows.

  • One of the things that Narendra Modi did while campaigning was talk

  • about cows and how cows needed to be saved or worshipped or celebrated.

  • Let's look at this map again, which shows how cow violence increased after 2014,

  • but now look at the attacks of 2017 and 2018. You can see that most of them are

  • clustered around this one area. This is Uttar Pradesh or UP.

  • With over 200 million people, this is India's most populous state

  • and in 2017, the Modi government appointed this man to be the leader of the state, Yogi Adityanath.

  • Earlier this year at an election rally, Yogi referred to Muslims as quote a

  • "green virus." In fact, it was at one of his political rallies where one of Akhlaq's

  • accused murderers was invited to sit on the front row.

  • After being appointed, Yogi directed the police to scrutinize the slaughterhouses

  • in his state, shutting down any that didn't have the proper paperwork.

  • They shuttered thousands of meat shops and closed hundreds of slaughterhouses that

  • they claimed were illegal putting many Muslims in Uttar Pradesh out of business.

  • And with Yogi in power, cow vigilantes were quickly emboldened.

  • In fact soon after he was appointed, three meat shops were set on fire by a mob.

  • That year cow related violence spiked in UP

  • and the impact of the Yogi's policies didn't end there.

  • I traveled south from the capital of UP, where Yogi's office sits, to a city on the banks of the Ganges.

  • I'm in a part of Uttar Pradesh, which is a huge leather producer and just a few

  • months ago the government gave a notice to this factory that they needed to stop all operations.

  • They used water pollution as the excuse because leather production

  • uses water and can pollute rivers and things like that so this factory worked really

  • hard to install pumps and filters and even after they provided all of the

  • information and jumped through all those hoops, the government still hasn't given

  • them permission to open up the factory again and so it's sits completely shut down, frozen in time.

  • All of these workers, the owners, everyone here is Muslim and this has been an

  • industry that Muslims in Uttar Pradesh have worked in for many many years

  • and it's now completely halted.

  • I'm associated with the industry for the last 50 years. I have never seen such bad days.

  • Since he came into power in 2017, Yogi has allocated government

  • funding to build shelters for stray cows around his state. I went to visit one of

  • these shelters to meet with the head of a local cow protection organization.

  • As someone who has dedicated his life to peaceful and lawful cow protection,

  • he was excited when Yogi announced his plan to construct many more cow shelters.

  • The place is not actually protecting or supporting cows. It's a lot that exists here

  • for the cows to be in, but these cows are starving, you can see their ribs.

  • They don't have enough food. They don't have enough shade.

  • The state government has used the setting up of a lot of

  • these cow shelters as a political

  • showcase of their commitment to Hindu ideals, but when you come look at them

  • you realize this isn't about protecting cows. This is about fueling an ideology.

  • Akhlaq was killed by a mob because of a rumor that he had beef in his

  • possession, but the murder investigation revealed that the meat he was carrying was not beef.

  • It was mutton.

  • Akhlaq's brothers suspect that the murder has less to do with cows and beef

  • and more to do with the fact that he was a Muslim who had money.

  • It's not about cows. It's how they feel that the Muslims have risen.

  • They are buying more land. They are buying better houses

  • or they are earning more. They are rising and how that upsets their social position.

  • After a series of horrific cow related incidents in 2017,

  • thousands took to the street in protest prompting Prime minister Modi to break

  • his silence and finally condemn violence in the name of cows.

  • Then, in 2018, the Indian Supreme Court passed a series of directives urging state governments

  • to take the problem more seriously, to properly prosecute these cases.

  • Some state governments have tried to raise awareness to curb the rumors that incite

  • this violence, but no official action has been taken by the national government.

  • Meanwhile, Modi just won another nationwide election and Yogi remains in power.

  • And India, this country that is rooted in the ideals of secularism and diversity

  • has become more and more dangerous for millions of its Muslim citizens.

On a Monday night in September 2015, in a little town outside New Delhi,

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it