Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • It was the last Friday of the school year, and I had been actually subbing for a teacher for 3 days.

  • It just seemed like a nice day.

  • On May 18th, 2018, a gunman entered a high school in Santa Fe, Texas and opened fire.

  • I look down and I realize in my pants⏤I had bloody holes in my pants and I realized: I'm shot.

  • The gunman killed ten people.

  • Flo Rice was shot six times.

  • And then, finally, Scot managed to, um, he managed to find me.

  • For four years, Flo and Scot have told their story over and over to push for new laws that could prevent mass shootings.

  • It's made them part of a recurring conversation on guns in the US and a cycle the country has seemed stuck in for decades:

  • a mass shooting, a push for reform, and then, no action.

  • - ... the tragic school shooting in Santa Fe, Texas... - ...this time in El Paso...

  • - ...nine people killed in Dayton... - ...how many years do we have to go through this?

  • - ...Congress is paralyzed... - ...we collectively seem to ask the same question:

  • What does it take to pass some gun reform in this country?

  • But here's the thing, this cycle of inaction on gun laws isn't exactly accurate.

  • Over the past few decades, federal legislation on guns has been rare.

  • But in state legislatures, mass shootings have led to new gun laws.

  • Thousands of them.

  • And how those laws have emerged can tell us a lot about the future of guns in the US.

  • In 2020, a study tried to determine "the impact of mass shootings on gun policy".

  • They looked at 25 years of high-profile mass shootings.

  • Then, they looked at gun legislation passed during that timeover 3,000 laws across all 50 states.

  • When they took a closer look at those laws, a pattern emerged:

  • That, at first seemed unsurprising, state legislatures controlled by Democrats were more likely to pass tighter gun laws.

  • Republican-controlled states typically loosened gun laws.

  • But they found a key difference.

  • Mass shootings didn't have any statistically significant effect on the number of laws passed by Democrats.

  • While for Republican legislatures, a mass shooting roughly doubles the number of laws enacted that loosen gun restrictions in the next year.

  • To arm more teachers, for example, or arm more school staff.

  • That's James Barragán, a politics reporter at the "Texas Tribune".

  • There is more access to guns afterwards, and a state like Texas would go more towards, um, pro-gun policies in the aftermath of a gun shooting.

  • Texas has some of the loosest gun laws in the nation, and that matters for people all over the country.

  • People probably don't know about the importance of, uh, state gun laws and, really, state laws in general.

  • Our gun laws at the federal level had been frozen in time since basically the 1990s,  

  • which allowed the states to have a much bigger role and a much bigger influence in how gun culture played out in their jurisdictions.

  • Let's look at Texas.

  • In 1991, a gunman killed 23 people at a Luby's restaurant in Killeen, Texas.

  • A woman there named Suzanna Hupp lost both her parents in the shooting.

  • She believed she could have stopped the massacre and turned her experience into a crusade for loosening gun laws.

  • I'm mad at my legislators for legislating me out of the right to protect myself and my family.

  • It worked.

  • In 1994, Texas elected a new governor, George W. Bush, who made it legal to carry a concealed gun his first year in office and set off a trend in the state that's continued for decades.

  • For example, in 2012, after the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting drew attention to gun laws across the country,

  • Texas responded a few months later by creating a program allowing some school employees to carry guns in school.

  • In 2017, a gunman killed 26 people at First Baptist Church in Sutherland Springs.

  • Within two years, Texas made it legal to carry weapons in places of worship.

  • But after the Santa Fe High School shooting, Governor Greg Abbott did something unusual.

  • He asked lawmakers to consider a "red flag law", which would allow authorities to take firearms away from a person courts deem dangerous.

  • Uh, that is not something that Republicans in this state often do.

  • Flo and Scot were also pushing for legislation in response to Santa Fe,

  • like laws that would hold parents accountable if their guns were used by their children to harm people.

  • They also pushed to make it harder to buy ammunition online.

  • Our shooter, he just checked the box and said, "Yes, I'm 18," and they delivered it to his doorstep.

  • You can't get alcohol delivered without, um, showing proof of ID or something, but he ordered ammunition.

  • Their hope for stricter laws was in line with Texas public opinion.

  • Polling showed only a small minority of Texans supported loosening gun laws, and just over half supported tightening them.

  • We thought it was common sense that this would be done.

  • They came to Flo's hospital room the week of the shooting.

  • And we had the governor, lieutenant governor; we had congressmen, we had senators, their wives;

  • there's chief of staff, all in her room at one time, at least 20 people, and said,

  • "We're gonna take care of you. We promise we'll be there for you. We'll fix this."

  • But in the end, these proposals, along with Abbot's openness to red flag laws, went nowhere.

  • After gun rights supporters went after himthe gun culture is strong.

  • But the gun lobby itself also exerts a lot of pressure on Texas politicians.

  • There were bills that were put out there, but they never made it out of committee.

  • Later in 2019, two shootings in west Texas just weeks apart prompted Lieutenant Governor Dan Patrick to suggest another tighter gun policy, closing background check loopholes.

  • That is a very strong comment from a lieutenant governor who is very pro-gun and who is very friendly with the NRA.

  • But Republican leaders were saying, "We may have problems here."

  • Democrats are pushing to take over the state house for the first time since 2003.

  • After elections were over, with Republicans still in control, in 2021, Texas passed "constitutional carry".

  • There would no longer be a requirement for Texans to have a license or receive any training to openly carry handguns.

  • For me, it's very scary because if I see someone in public with a gun, I will... I will panic.

  • Um... that's gonna send me into an anxiety attack.

  • That constitutional carry law that, uh, the state legislature passed in 2021 had been rejected by Republican leaders.

  • But as, uh, the Republican Party has gone further and further to the right on issues,

  • you get a fringe of the party that is much more vocal about, uh, all kinds of issues, including gun rights.

  • In recent years, a better organized gun control movement has seen more success with tightening laws in some states.

  • But the movement to expand gun access isn't stopping.

  • In 2002, fewer than half of the 50 states had 1 party in control of both the state legislature and the governor's office.

  • Today, three-quarters of the states do.

  • That means, in the places where Republicans or Democrats have full control, they can push through new gun laws with little chance of a veto.

  • So, what happens, um, and you see it in state house to state house,

  • is one state passes a law that is very successful for one side of the aisle, and then, another state house adopts a very, very similar law.

  • Remember that constitutional carry law in Texas?

  • Today, 24 states have similar laws on the books for that, too.

  • And more than 400 local governments across 20 states have adopted variations on a "Second Amendment sanctuary law",

  • meaning a city, town, or county refuses to recognize any state or federal gun laws that they believe violate the Second Amendment.

  • These things get replicated; they get cloned, they go from state to state.

  • And they essentially make up this patchwork of laws throughout the country.

  • In June 2022, in the aftermath of the Uvalde shooting in Texas, President Biden signed the most significant federal gun bill in 30 years.

  • One thing it does is incentivize states to pass red flag laws.

  • But it can't make them do it.

  • That power still belongs to the states.

  • I have survivor's guilt because I'm alive, and, so, I feel like it...

  • I have to keep speaking out; I have to do what I can.

  • There's times when I just think I'm gonna stop.

  • I... I'm no⏤I cannot do this for my own mental health.

  • But we just keep... we keep going.

It was the last Friday of the school year, and I had been actually subbing for a teacher for 3 days.

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it