Subtitles section Play video
So, I grew up in a place called McLean, Virginia, right outside of D.C.
But I, like, split my childhood, basically.
So we'll start with where I first grew up,
so I'm really excited to show you guys this.
- So this is my hometown. - Wow, that's cool.
We were the only black family on the block.
I was the only black kid in my grade.
One of three black families in my school.
And if we look, folks are in the 99th percentile
who grew up here when it comes to average income.
Less than 1% are incarcerated.
We can look at teenage birth rate-- less than 1%.
Around high school, my folks got divorced and we moved into the city.
It's the exact opposite.
It wasn't till I got to D.C. that I actually had a benchmark
for understanding everyone didn't grow up the way I did.
And it took, you know, my parents getting divorced
and us moving to the city for me to actually
understand how fortunate I really was.
Zip code influences so much that we have got to make sure
that those neighborhood conditions
aren't setting people up for failure.
We are keeping people of reasonable means out of neighborhoods.
While I was doing some research, I came across this,
which is the Opportunity Atlas.
And it's a map that shows you the average life outcomes
for people who grew up in a given census tract.
It's just crazy to think that I may have only
become as successful as I am
because I spent the majority of my childhood here
instead of in D.C.
But why don't we take a look at where you guys grew up?
Dun, dun, dun.
( theme music playing )
- Lee: So, you're, like in the Bay area. - Christophe: Oh, yeah.
- I must have grew up in Cupertino, California. - Lee: Okay.
Christophe: Majority Asian. Definitely fairly wealthy.
- A lot of, like, tech, Silicon Valley employees. - Lee: Right.
All right. So I'm gonna put in my zip code where I grew up.
So I just took you guys to Brooklyn, New York,
Crown Heights, and immediately traveling here,
it's just completely red.
Yeah, so, $30k, that makes a lot of sense to me.
But is also just-- this shows how segregated
Brooklyn is and was at the time.
Fabiola: Yeah. So right here at Grand Army Plaza,
it just looks so different from the blocks
where I grew up in Brooklyn.
And so that was out Saturday activity.
Let's go to the library. Let's go to the park.
And that was kind of escaping
a lot of the segregation in Crown Heights
to go to this area where the amenities were better.
Did you notice those neighborhoods being cleaner?
Absolutely. And I think the biggest thing was trees.
- Right. - Just like how many trees do you have on your block?
I think it does something to your psyche where it's like,
oh, I feel like I can breathe better.
I feel like someone cared enough to beautify this area.
Well, guys, thank you for taking the time out to come look at this with me
- and showing me where you grew up. - This is so cool.
I want to talk to this professor at NYU
to see if I can get some information and some insight into how we actually got here.
Jacob: So I think the overarching important message to take away
is that segregation was intentionally designed.
- There are a number of-- - Designed by who?
By a wide range of policy makers on the local level
all the way up to the federal level.
When did we start to see the government
actually leading a lot of these programs when it came to segregation?
So the federal government instituted these
massive housing programs during the New Deal
to save a housing market that was in severe distress.
Their first policy was called the Home Owner's Loan Corporation,
or H.O.L.C. or "hulk."
Part of H.O.L.C. was sending appraisers,
real estate appraisers to hundreds of cities across the country.
And these appraisers would grade neighborhoods in these cities,
and this is where the term redlining comes from.
Lee: In your lease it would say,
"You cannot resell this house to a black family."
- Jacob: Yeah. - So, let me explain.
As these appraisers surveyed cities across the United States,
they created maps that they distributed to banks.
And the banks used these maps
to decide how risky it would be to provide loans
or mortgage assistance to different neighborhoods around the country,
and each of these maps was assigned a color.
So green indicated this was the most desirable area,
and the map we're looking at right now is an area
in the northern suburbs of Chicago.
And along with these maps,
we were given documents that described
the neighborhood that was being surveyed.
If we take a look at the top, we can see the class and occupation.
We can also see the number of black families in this area,
and the preferred nomenclature of the 1930s was Negro.
There were zero.
Moving on to the next classification
were blue neighborhoods.
And blue neighborhoods were considered
to still be desirable.
So as we take a look at the description
of this blue area in Chicago,
the percentage of foreign families is still zero.
The percentage of Negro families, still none.
And as we come down to the description, we see the area is well laid out
and the improvements are attractive,
but the proximity of Negro families on Spruce Street
at the southern edge precludes the district from a better rating
and is retarding its development.
The proximity of Negro families. That's so crazy.
So as you can see, these maps didn't ignore race.
In fact, they were heavily dependent on it.
Race played a key factor in determining the value of these neighborhoods
and their ratings to the banks.
The yellow neighborhoods were listed as definitely declining.
This one had 50% foreign families,
those foreign families being Polish and German.
Race wasn't the only determining factor
in whether or not these neighborhoods had value.
Immigrant families heavily impacted whether or not
it got a favorable evaluation.
And as we move on to the last designation of these neighborhoods,
we come to red neighborhoods.
And this is actually where we get the term redlining from.
These neighborhoods were defined as hazardous.
And when we look at the description of the area,
the number of foreign families-- 5%.
They were Italians.
But the percentage of Negro families-- 90%.
And as we make our way down the description sheet,
we see "This concentration of Negroes in Evanston
is quite a serious problem for the town,
as they seem to be growing steadily
and encroaching into adjoining neighborhoods."
These maps are how the federal government institutionalized segregation,
and they used race to determine the value of all of these neighborhoods.
So I want to understand how all of these red lines
are impacting people's lives today.
H.O.L.C. was passed in 1933, and before that time,
places where H.O.L.C. made those red-lining maps
and places that didn't have those maps
were about the same level of segregation.
And the measurement that we use is a fairly common measurement of segregation
called Black Isolation.
Then by 1950, 1960, we see that cities
that were where the redlining maps were created,
there's this huge jump here.
This one sort of moment, they were collecting the data and published the data
and it vastly impacted millions of American lives from that point on.
Yeah. This gap emerges especially as the Federal Housing Administration
and the G.I. Bill kick in after H.O.L.C.,
and then we're layering on schools, highways, et cetera.
Suburbanization. And then all that gets locked in place.
So I would say that the gap that we see today
is a result of structural racism,
which includes the wealth gap,
it includes this history of exclusion.
It includes the intentional segregating of neighborhoods.
What impact did this have on our economy
and the ability for people to participate in it?
Housing segregation has all these other layers on top of it,
including education and employment opportunities.
So the isolation of people of color,
in this case specifically African-Americans,
has dramatically limited the ability of African-Americans
to kind of achieve what we generally consider to be kind of middle class status--
home ownership, wealth stability,
the ability to pass on resources to the next generation.
Any other interesting takeaways from this?
It didn't have to be this way.
So we just learned about how the government has historically
segregated neighborhoods across America,
but I wanted to understand how these problems
are affecting people today.
I'm getting ready to meet up with two former testers
from the Fair Housing Justice Center.
So, tell me exactly what a tester is.
What did you all do in that capacity?
It's a way of finding out what landlords or real estate agents
are saying to people when they think no one else is listening.
If you're a real person going out looking for a home to rent or to buy,
you provide your information and you're given certain information
about what's available in what neighborhoods at what price levels.
You have no way if knowing if someone of a different race or ethnicity
or any of the protected characteristics is being told the same thing as you.
What are the ways that we're seeing housing discrimination play out right now?
Any time I hear somebody say, "Oh, white supremacy,
white privilege is just a myth in this country," I say,
"Come do my job for half an hour and you'll see the way the doors get opened for me."
I actually had this very nice woman in Brooklyn showing me an apartment.
We're always instructed to convey disinterest.
She said, "Tell you what I'm gonna do.
Let me write down the number for the entry code for the lobby door.
If I'm not here, you just let yourselves in. Go up to the fourth floor.
Show her around the apartment because I'd really love to see you guys in here."
Most of my experiences are not like Craig's at all.
I don't want to paint the picture that every time I'm sent out to test
I'm discriminated against,
but I have been involved in cases
where very clear discrimination happened.
At times, I am shown the apartment, but I'm quoted a higher rent.
$300 over my white counterpart.
At times, not shown amenities in the building.
Not encouraged to apply where my white counterpart was encouraged to apply.
Lisa, what is-- what do some of those experiences that you've had,
what do they tell you about what regular folks might be going through?
When you're a tester, we're-- as an African-American,
I'm representing all the African-Americans that went and inquired at that building
and were lied to, so I represent so many other people of color
who are experiencing this while just looking for housing,
and housing is a basic need.
So, when my dad sold our house in D.C.,
we had to get it appraised twice.
And the first time it was appraised, the value was set at about $800,000.
But my dad knew that our neighbors on the same block
were selling their houses for much more that that.
So we spoke to a realtor who told him
to take all of the family photos off the walls,
leave them bare, and get it appraised a second time.
And that second appraisal,
the value was set at about $1.2 million.
And at the time, I didn't think that was motivated by race,
but now after talking to these testers,
I'm starting to think that race
maybe played a role in the home's valuation.
- Toby? - Yeah.
- Hey, man, I'm Lee. - Good to meet you.
Tell a little bit about what you guys do at Open New York.
So we are a pro-housing group.
We advocate for more housing
and more affordable housing all across New York.
We are on 11th Street between Fifth and Sixth Avenue in Brooklyn Park Slope.
And we're looking at a building that couldn't be built today
- as of right now in Brooklyn. - Why is that?
So, the zoning rules prohibit it.
So, in 2003, this area was downzoned.
Lee: Why would people want to downzone this neighborhood?
If you owned here, restricting supply is in your interest
because it makes your own property more valuable.
And that's been the story here for the last 40, going on 50 years.
Lee: New York City famously rezoned nearly 200,000 properties
between 2003 and 2007 under the Bloomberg administration.
But a lot of this rezoning was actually downzoning.
Here in Park Slope, some areas were downzoned to preserve the historic brownstones,
while other areas were rezoned to increase housing density.
How does this impact segregation at a racial level, at an economic level?
It's brutal, right?
By privileging incumbents,
and by incumbents I mean largely home owners,
you're entrenching all of your existing segregation.
And let's be honest, America is way too segregated today.
As so by downzoning,
if this were a white neighborhood,
you're making it much harder
for it to become a more diverse area.
Absolutely. You are actively working against it.
( phone ringing )
Fabiola, what's up? How are you?
Hey, Lee, I'm good. How are you?
I'm good. I just got in touch with this mother in Philadelphia
whose children are struggling with lead poisoning.
And I want to go talk to her because I feel like this story
might really embody the very real consequences of housing segregation.
But I'm still looking for someone to talk to about home ownership
and the racial wealth gap, and I thought you might have some ideas.
Someone that I've actually talked to before
on this is Andre Perry.
He's a Fellow at the Brookings Institute, actually,
- so he's based here in D.C. - That's perfect.
Do you have time to talk to him while I'm in Philly?
Fabiola: Yeah. I'll see if I can get in touch with him.
- Lee: Amazing. - Why is home ownership
important in terms of economic mobility?
Well, when you own a home, you're more likely
to be economically and socially mobile.
But home ownership also precludes you from moving
every time there's an economic shock.
Home ownership predicts for better health,
particularly during a pandemic.
I can't think of another asset
that is so influential
on a person's life chances than housing.
What have you found about the differences in property value
between predominately black neighborhoods
and predominately white neighborhoods?
What does that chart tell us?
Andre: Homes in neighborhoods where the share
of the black population is less than a percent
on average are priced about $340,000.
And as the percent of black people
in a neighborhood increases,
you see the home prices decrease.
So much so that when
the share of the black population is 50% or higher,
the home prices on average are about half as much
as their white neighborhoods.
So you're saying it's as simple as
the more black people in a neighborhood,
- the less the houses are worth? - That's exactly right.
A lot of people will look at that prior chart and say,
"That's because of education. That's because of crime."
We control for education, crime, walkability,
all those fancy Zillow metrics.
And what we found is homes in black neighborhoods
are underpriced about 23%,
about $48,000 per home.
Cumulatively, that's about $156 billion in lost equity.
And how does racial segregation factor into housing valuation?
Well, you know, segregation has a long-standing impact
on a number of things.
Cities are becoming more concentrated with poor folk,
and that is reducing those areas' abilities
to pay for services like education,
policing, infrastructure.
So when you concentrate poverty in areas,
not only are you putting a target on those communities' back
in terms of harmful policies,
but you have less resources in a neighborhood.
We have got to address this because if folks
can't achieve the American dream through housing,
then they're not going to achieve the American dream
in any other part of their life.
So, I'm on my way to Philadelphia,
a city where nearly 8% of the children under the age of seven
are struggling with lead poisoning.
Lead is a heavy metal, and when it gets into your blood,
it can cause anything from a reduced IQ to ADHD,
and some research has actually linked it to school failures and even criminality.
And while lead paint has been illegal since 1978,
a number of the homes here in Philadelphia were built well before then.
So I'm getting ready to meet up with a family
whose lives have been reshaped by their zip code.
- Hey. - Hi, how are you?
- I'm good. I'm Lee. Nice to meet you. - I'm Angel.
So where are we right now?
Oh, man, we're in the area of Olney in Philadelphia.
Okay. And you used to live out here?
- Yes, I did. - So, your kids got sick living in this house?
- Angel: Yes, they did. - What happened?
Angel: I took them to the doctor one day
just for a random checkup,
and I come to find out
my daughter had a nine lead level,
and my son, at the time he was two,
he had an 18 lead level.
Lee: Jesus.
What happened after you found out that your children had lead poisoning?
- I contacted-- - Did you call the landlord or--
Yes, I contacted the landlord.
The city were actually called by the doctors.
They had to do gun tests.
My children's room, which was the middle room,
they had the highest lead levels in the whole house.
How were you dealing with this? You know, you're working. You're a working mom.
- You have three children. - It's hard. It's hard. It's extremely hard.
Who wants to have their children get lead poisoning?
But when you are a single parent, you have three children,
you're doing everything by yourself,
how can you make enough money to just up and leave?
What kind of a message did that send you about, you know, where you live?
You know, if you were living center city, it just wouldn't happen.
The suburbs, it would not happen.
So when you made the decision to get your kids out of here--
Yes, I did. I actually moved to a hotel.
- For how long? - For about a month, a month and a half.
- Where are you living now? - In Reading.
- Reading? Where is that? - Yes. About an hour and ten minutes away from here.
- Can you show me where? - Yeah.
- Lee: Okay, so this is your new house in Reading? - Angel: Yes.
- So tell me about this place. - Well, when I first got here, it looked immaculate.
- Right. - Three days after,
my walls started to have a little crumbling where I saw water.
- Can you show me? Can we take a look? - Yes. Yes.
Up here, there's mold all throughout the ceiling.
This is where the water leaks at on the floor.
And here, this is more water damage.
This right here was seeping water the other day.
- Jeez. - There's mold down here
just coming out the wall.
So I went from one bad situation to a worse situation.
I'm literally on unemployment
because I was laid off at my job.
I have nowhere to go.
When people say things like, you know,
America's the land of opportunity.
You just gotta work hard. You just gotta pull yourself--
That's a lie. Because I moved from the last place to come here.
So what's next?
Okay, so I know that I grew up privileged.
I know that I was incredibly fortunate to have attended great schools,
to know from a young age that I could afford to pay for college
and to just have fresh air to breathe
and clean water to drink.
What I didn't know growing up
was that this was an incredibly rare experience,
especially if you're someone that looks like me.
I had no idea that the full weight of history
was actively working against me having that experience.
My parents beat the odds,
largely because we always owned homes
in this family going back generations,
and that had a direct impact on my chances in life.
But the scarcity of stories like mine isn't a problem
that any one of us can fix.
It is, however, something that we don't have to passively accept.
In trying to find out whether or not your zip code determines your future,
I did see some bright spots.
For decades, zoning laws were used to restrict access.
But now in some cities, they're being used to encourage investment
and create more diverse neighborhoods.
There are private firms that are investing
in low income luxury housing
that's meant to convert renters into homeowners.
And some landlords and members of the real estate industry
have woken up to the role that they've played
in perpetuating housing segregation
and restricting the upward mobility of our neighbors for generations.
For every dollar the typical white household has,
the typical black household has about nine or ten cents.
And this is connected directly to this legacy of redlining
and exclusion from the opportunity to build home equity.
So undoing that is going to require as big
if not a bigger investment
than was made in the New Deal.
Let's excite the economy
in the same way we're doing during COVID,
the same way we did after the Great Depression,
but we just didn't do it for black people.
So now's the time to really correct those wrongs.
Ultimately, we can't reverse the course of history
without those who dug this hole
reaching in and pulling us back out.
( indistinct chatter )
( chatter continues )
Woman: Hell, yeah. Do y'all want to change this background?
Woman 2: "I'm Lee, and I'm gonna find out."
Lee: You want, "I'm Lee and I'm gonna find out?
Or do you want, "Does your neighborhood determine your future?
I'm Lee Adams, and this is 'Glad You Asked' by Vox."