Subtitles section Play video
Rheumatoid arthritis is estimated
to affect up to 1% of the entire population.
It is painful and often debilitating
talking inflammation in the joints,
the likes of which unless you have it,
sometimes you just can't believe.
And the flare ups with aura seem to come out of nowhere.
What triggers them?
Oftentimes it's a mystery, and that is what researchers
at the Physicians Committee wanted to figure out.
And today,
we're joined
by one of the lead
researchers of a brand new groundbreaking study
that analyzes the effect of diet on rheumatoid arthritis.
We welcome the director of clinical research
for the Physicians Committee, Dr.
Hana Kahleova.
Dr. Kahleova, thanks for being back here.
Thanks for having me, Chuck.
So good to see you again.
So good to be here.
Oftentimes
when you're on the show, we talk about diabetes,
but today we're talking about R.A.
And the thing that I know about R.A.
is that when I said it was painful, just a minute ago,
I've seen people just literally crippled over, crippled over
and have their days just ruined by it.
So when we're talking about pain
and R.A., I mean, how painful is this condition?
Yeah, that's exactly right.
Like, it affects the small joints in
the hands in the wrists,
the knees, but also other joints in the body.
And they're not only painful, but also swollen
and eventually over the course of many years
of the disease, there may be a permanent damage.
So it may be disability and disease also
you know, a big cause of disability. So
this is no fun.
We know that there's genetic factors
but also environmental factors.
And, you know, among the factors that we can influence,
diet seems to be one of them.
It's an autoimmune condition, which means that
it may be triggered by certain proteins.
And that's why we were trying to figure out,
you know, if we modified the diet, could we
could we help these people
with their pain and with their swollen joints?
And that's exactly why we conducted a clinical trial.
And let me share my screen with you and just tell you
a little bit about the study.
Yeah, by all means.
And we see the screen up on there right now.
Wonderful.
So we were looking into the effects
of a plant-based diet for rheumatoid arthritis.
And the findings have just been published
in the American Journal of Lifestyle Medicine.
And, you know, when
when people come in with their joint pain,
I need to say not all joint
pain is due to rheumatoid arthritis.
So in our study, we had a rheumatologist
who verified the diagnosis of rheumatoid arthritis, and
he was also making sure
to do the count of the joints
and all of the assessments that rheumatologists do
without knowing which group the participants were
in, both at baseline and then and then at midpoint.
And then at the end of the study,
we recruited 44 people with rheumatoid arthritis
and they were randomly assigned to either
the diet phase
or the supplement phase.
For sixteen weeks.
And then after the sixteen weeks were over,
we re-assessed their joint pain
and we were using questionnaires
and also the rheumatologist met with them and
we drew their labs.
And after a four week washout
period, four, four week of a break,
they switched over to the opposite intervention.
So those who were on the diet previously went on a supplement
and those who were on
a supplement went on the diet for another six weeks.
And then we did all the final assessments again.
Now, let me describe the diet.
What what exactly was the diet about
for the first four weeks?
It was a low fat vegan diet.
That means no animal product, no meat, no dairy,
no cheese, no eggs for four weeks.
Then for another three weeks
on the top of eliminating all the animal foods,
we also eliminated certain plant foods,
for example, gluten containing grains.
So foods and certain vegetables and fruits.
And for the
last nine weeks, we were reintroducing
the eliminated foods one by one back into the diet.
And if the introduced foods didn't cause any problems,
the participants just kept them in the diet
and kept adding new and new foods.
However, if, let's say
introducing potatoes back to the diet
caused a lot of joint pain and so,
you know, the joints were swollen again,
then the potato was just out of the diet again.
And we were testing other foods which provided each participant
with individualized food triggers that would cause
the joint pain and and swelling.
Here's the list of all the eliminated foods
on the elimination diet.
So in addition to eliminating all the animal foods
during the after four weeks,
during the subsequent three weeks week, we excluded
all the gluten containing grains.
Some vegetables such as potatoes and sweet potatoes,
and onions and tomatoes and eggplants and celery.
Only a couple
of fruits such as apples and bananas and citrus fruit,
nuts and peanuts,
soy foods and chickpea and also chocolate,
coffee, sugar, alcohol and nutritional yeast.
So these foods were eliminated for three weeks,
and then they were introduced one by one every two days.
The participants added another food from this
from this elimination diet list.
Now, the disease activity
measured by the DAS 28 score,
which is one of the the major
rheumatologist assessments
didn't change significantly
on the supplement or which was a placebo
but was reduced substantially during the diet
by 2.1 points.
And I need to say that we also did another analysis
looking at people who increased their medications
during the study.
When we excluded them, we we got similarly results.
And also when we took participants with no medication
changes whatsoever during the study and left
only them then and the results were comparable as well.
And another significant
finding from the study was the number of swollen joints
which was reduced by 3.7 during the diet phase
and did not change significantly on the placebo
So in conclusion, it looks like the elimination
plant based diet really work for rheumatoid arthritis
and can be definitely tried out if you have
rheumatoid arthritis.
I'd like to encourage you to give it a try
and we will post the whole
the whole paper with the list of the foods
that that were eliminated on the elimination diet
so that you can you can do it yourself.
Those are really fascinating results. Dr.
Kahleova.
What was your hypothesis going into this?
I mean, we know that plant-based
diets, by and large are anti-inflammatory.
So was it your suspicion that this
probably would be helpful to a lot of these study participants?
Yeah, exactly.
Our thought was let
let's try out how a plant-based diet can help these people.
We know that plant-based diets in general are
anti-inflammatory.
But then
also we realize that there are certain triggers
beyond the animal foods that are excluded from from
the plant, plant-based diet.
That's why we also included the elimination phase.
Unfortunately, the individual foods
that need to be eliminated in
in each single person,
they are completely different from one person to another.
So there is no way how to predict whether a person
will be reacting to a potato or a tomato
or an apple or onion.
Every person just needs to try these foods out.
So one part one part is eliminating
all the animal products.
And most participants reported significant improvement
of their joint pain even after the first four weeks.
But there was still some remaining pain
in some of the participants, and that's
where the elimination diet came into play.
Interesting.
I find it really interesting how wide of a variation
there was as far as the trigger foods.
So what you're saying is
you can't exactly say that while, you know,
fruits are more likely to be triggers or potatoes,
as you said, or onions or whatever
the case may be, you can't say
any of that is more likely to be a trigger than another food.
Do we have any sort of understanding as to why
it varies so widely from person to person?
Our body, it's an autoimmune condition
and it's triggered by certain proteins.
And it also depends on your genetic
background and also your early, early life exposures.
So let's say people who were not breastfed
and where cows and milk was introduced early, early in life,
they may react to dairy much stronger
than a person who was breastfed, for example.
You know, there's different
there's different foods that are being introduced
into the diet in the early life.
And some of them just turn out to be to be triggers.
It's it's also the case
with meat and
with eggs.
You know, the earlier the exposure in life,
the higher the probability that the body will be reacting
to these foods later in life.
So that's also
stressing a
point for all our mothers
who have small babies to be really careful
about the diet of their babies.
You know, make sure they breastfeed them long enough
and also that they introduce foods that are not
not any of these triggers too early in life.
And I'm looking at the list of foods
that were part of the elimination diet.
There were three in particular that stood out to me
that I'm like, hmm, I wonder if some people had a hard time
eliminating these completely I'm talking about coffee
and I'm talking about sugar and I'm talking about chocolate.
Weren't did any of the participants say, hey, look, Dr.
Kahelova, this is like so hard to take out of my life?
Absolutely.
There were a few people who were like,
How am I going to survive without my coffee?
But they did it.
You know, you can you can do everything
if you put your mind to it, like
going through the elimination diet.
Gave the study
participants unique information for the rest of their life.
Let's say,
you know, you're
you're experiencing some pain in your joints, Chuck,
and you don't know where the pain is coming from.
And someone will tell you, you know, let's let's figure it out.
Over the next six weeks, we will know exactly
what triggers your pain.
Then you might be up for that.
You know
what? You might be willing to eliminate
all your sugar in coffee.
The strict elimination phase was only for three weeks.
So, you know, it's not too bad.
And also, eliminating chocolate doesn't mean eliminate the
chocolate taste, and the eliminating sugar
doesn't mean eliminating the sweet taste either.
So there's ways how you can somehow make it work.
So. Okay, so you're talking about sugar?
Are we just talking about added refined sugar or.
Okay, and so but the fruits that were not on that
elimination list, they they could still freely eat
as much as they wanted.
Exactly.
So berries and grapes, for example, they can they
they they were able to eat as much as they wanted.
All right.
Well, that's a sweet relief right there.
Not too bad.
Okay.
And how confident are we given the fact that this is an
autoimmune disorder, that
other autoimmune disorders might also see
the same type of benefit?
I mean, obviously, they're all a little bit different.
But, you know, so we've got R.A.
here and other autoimmune disorders, say,
like Sjogren syndrome or something like that.
Are we confident that,
you know, looking at a nutritional intervention
might also prove helpful for those other conditions?
It might.
We just don't have the exact information.
And some some studies need to be conducted.
We're currently running a study for people
with type one diabetes, which is also an autoimmune condition.
So see how we can help these people with with with a diet,
you know, and if that can make a difference in their life.
Also.
And what final question?
I mean, what was the takeaway for the participants?
I mean,
was it really kind of EYE-OPENING for them
if they saw
real positive results
like, wow, I've been looking
for something like this my entire life and now
oh my goodness,
it's it's not medicine, it's not this, it's not that.
It's it's food.
Food seems to be kind of like something
that can really help me out here.
Was there a lot of surprise among them?
Absolutely.
For the first time in their life, you know, they saw relief
by something as simple as a as nutrition.
And, you know, most of them were super grateful
for this experience
because that informed them for the rest of their life.
Dr. Kahleova, medicine woman, I love it.
You always bring the knowledge.
So today is no different.
So thank you very much for being here.
Thank you so much.
If your health
IQ is a couple of points higher than it was a few minutes ago,
go ahead and like this video or subscribe
to the YouTube channel and to take it even higher.
Head over to Apple Podcasts
or wherever you get your favorite shows.
Look for the exam room by the Physicians Committee.
Hit the subscribe button
there as well and help to make your world a healthier place.