Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • This is a building collapsing in Turkey hours after a series of earthquakes and aftershocks on February 6th.

  • First, the bottom floor crumbled.

  • Then the rest of the building came down on top of it in what's known as a "pancake collapse".

  • Thousands of buildings near the epicenter in southern Turkey and northern Syria tumbled straight down in a similar way.

  • The intensity of the earthquakes alone carried the potential for destruction.

  • But it's the pancake collapses that have made this one of the deadliest disasters in the region.

  • Even in very well-designed and executed building would have suffered.

  • This doesn't rule out that the buildings were free of defect.

  • "How well buildings protected residents played a significant role in lives saved and lost."

  • "Clearly a lot of these buildings were not up to standard."

  • The death toll continues to climb as many victims are still stuck under the weight of the buildings.

  • So what is it about these buildings that has made this earthquake even more devastating?

  • First, let's look at the larger region that's prone to severe earthquakes because of these two fault lines.

  • They sit along tectonic plates that meet one another and cause friction.

  • When the friction builds up, a powerful earthquake is eventually released.

  • Over the last century, Turkey has seen major earthquakes along both fault lines.

  • The most recent one happened here.

  • This is the seismic impact that shows the epicenter.

  • When you take a closer look at the most impacted areas, they were densely populated with Syrian refugees who ended up living in buildings that were haphazardly built and largely neglected.

  • And across the border in Syria, buildings in these areas were already weakened by the prolonged civil war.

  • But what really complicates this disaster is that Turkey was aware of the buildings that were the most high risk.

  • They're called soft-story structures.

  • A soft-story building is typically a large structure with multiple floors and an open plan on the bottom.

  • That bottom floor can sometimes be a parking garage space for small businesses or extra homes.

  • These buildings are very common throughout the world, especially in countries like India, Pakistan, and Turkey.

  • Because they offer a solution to overcrowding in densely populated areas.

  • But they historically do a poor job of withstanding medium to powerful earthquakes.

  • Here's why:

  • These columns here are usually made of wood and the stories on top might be made of heavier materials like concrete.

  • Sometimes the bottom floor has fewer walls than the ones above with sides that may be left open or columns that aren't connected by walls.

  • This means that a soft story is the weakest floor and cannot fully support the heavier ones above it.

  • So when an earthquake hits, the structure may shake, until that bottom floor collapses.

  • During powerful earthquakes like Turkey and Syria's, the remainder of the building may follow.

  • This kind of collapse traps people under heavy construction materials making rescue missions even more difficult.

  • But this is a challenge Turkey has faced before.

  • A comparable 7.6 earthquake hit Izmit in 1999 and caused over 17,000 deaths.

  • It became clear that poor building design and soft stories which made up nearly 90% of building collapses exacerbated the death toll in this disaster.

  • The aftermath pushed the Turkish government to reintroduce building codes with an emphasis on earthquake safety.

  • But they weren't enforced due to corruption.

  • And many buildings in Turkey were built too well before 1999, which meant those buildings could only be strengthened retroactively.

  • There is a way to keep soft-story buildings intact in the event of an earthquake: retrofitting them with materials that can support the weight of the structure.

  • In an ideal scenario, these wooden columns can be replaced or reinforced with steel frames.

  • These open walls can be reinforced too and extra bolts and braces can be drilled into the foundation.

  • So if the structure shakes, there's support from that bottom floor.

  • A solution like this seem simple, but it's extremely expensive to execute.

  • According to the World Bank, around 6.7 million residential buildings in Turkey need retrofitting or reconstruction at a cost of $465 billion.

  • As of 2021, only about 4% of those buildings were transformed.

  • In fact, retrofitting is an expensive undertaking and nearly impossible, even in countries like the US.

  • Here is every remaining soft-story building in San Francisco that needs reinforcements that would cost billions.

  • But another problem in Turkey is that construction companies have been cutting corners and ignoring building codes for decades.

  • And the Turkish government has let their violations slide.

  • According to the BBC this post advertised a building that complied with Turkey's latest earthquake safety regulations which emphasizes the use of strong materials.

  • But the way that same building collapsed suggests it was a soft-story structure.

  • Now, Turkey is cracking down on contractors that are allegedly responsible for these collapses.

  • The scale of this disaster is a result of complex factors,

  • like geography, neighborhoods still reeling from war, and weak buildings.

  • But what makes this moment particularly harrowing is that while earthquakes along fault lines are inevitable, many of these deaths didn't have to be.

  • Turkey, along with other countries near fault lines are all prone to intense earthquakes.

  • But they won't have to be this deadly if cities enforce codes and treat safe housing as a human right.

This is a building collapsing in Turkey hours after a series of earthquakes and aftershocks on February 6th.

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it