Subtitles section Play video
“Evil is not committed by people who feel uncertain about their righteousness, who question
their own motives, who worry about betraying themselves.
The evil in this world is committed by the spiritual fat cats, by the Pharisees of our
own day, the self-righteous who think they are without sin because they are unwilling
to suffer the discomfort of significant self-examination.”
M. Scott Peck, People of the Lie Most politicians proclaim themselves to be
exemplars of virtue, but many of them compulsively lie, engage in corruption, censor and demonize
those who disagree with them, and enact policies that destroy society.
Are such politicians aware of their hypocrisy?
Do they truly believe in the morally righteous self-image they try to portray?
In this video, drawing from the insights of the American psychiatrist M. Scott Peck, we
explore the psychology of malignant narcissism in order to better understand the evil that
has infected modern politics.
M. Scott Peck defines evil as “that force, residing either inside or outside of human
beings, that seeks to kill life or liveliness.”, or as he continues:
“. . .evil is 'live' spelt backward.
Evil is in opposition to life…Specifically, it has to do with…unnecessary killing, killing
that is not required for biological survival…Evil is also that which kills spirit.
There are various essential attributes of life – particularly human life – such
as sentience, mobility, awareness, growth, autonomy, will.
It is possible to kill or attempt to kill one of these attributes without actually destroying
the body.”
M. Scott Peck, People of the Lie All of us are capable of committing evil acts;
for as Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn noted “the line dividing good and evil cuts through the
heart of every human being”.
Nonetheless, two types of people are particularly prone to evil actions: psychopaths, and malignant
narcissists.
The psychopath's potential for evil is well-known, but it is the malignant narcissists who may
be responsible for more of the world's evil as they outnumber the psychopaths, and as
Peck writes in The People of the Lie:
“It would be quite appropriate to classify evil people as constituting a specific variant
of the narcissistic personality disorder…psychiatrists have begun to pay increasing attention to
the phenomenon of narcissism, but our understanding of the subject is still in its infancy.”
M. Scott Peck, People of the Lie The central characteristic of narcissism is
an inflated sense of self.
Narcissists are overconfident and admire themselves to a degree that is not warranted by the reality
of who they are, or what they have accomplished.
The narcissist's infatuation with a grandiose self-image leads to self-absorption, reducing
their capacity to empathize with the feelings and experiences of other people.
Narcissism exists on a continuum; some of the milder forms of narcissism, such as identifying
with an idealized self-image one creates on social media, are unhealthy, but relatively
benign.
At the extreme end of the spectrum lies the pathology of malignant narcissism, in which
one identifies with an illusory self-image of moral purity.
Or as Peck explains:
“Utterly dedicated to preserving their self-image of perfection, [malignant narcissists] are
unceasingly engaged in the effort to maintain the appearance of moral purity…While they
seem to lack any motivation to be good, they intensely desire to appear good.
Their 'goodness' is all on a level of pretense.
It is, in effect, a lie.
This is why they are the 'people of the lie.'”
M. Scott Peck, People of the Lie Malignant narcissism is a defensive phenomenon
that is rooted in a deep fear of being inferior or inadequate, particularly in matters of
morality.
Due to childhood trauma, growing up with hyper-critical or narcissistic parents, or for other reasons
of upbringing, socialization, or genetics, the malignant narcissist cannot acknowledge
that, like everyone else, they make mistakes, behave immorally, and possess a potential
for evil that is rooted in human nature.
Or as Peck writes:
“What is the cause of this arrogant self-image of perfection, this particularly malignant
type of narcissism?
Basically, it is fear.
[Malignant narcissists] are continually frightened that they will come face-to-face with their
own evil…
This terror is so chronic, so interwoven into the fabric of their being, that they may not
even feel it as such.
And if they could, their omnipresent narcissism will prohibit them from ever acknowledging
it.”
M. Scott Peck, People of the Lie When psychologically healthy people commit
an immoral or evil act, they acknowledge their wrongdoing, feel guilt and remorse, and attempt
to make amends by returning to the side of the good.
Most of us, in other words, have a functioning conscience which places moral constraints
on our behavior.
The conscience of the malignant narcissist, in contrast, is forced into a state of dormancy
by continual acts of self-deception.
As the malignant narcissist's identity is anchored in a grandiose self-image of moral
goodness, when he morally falters, he resorts to rationalizations, confabulations, and other
defense mechanisms to maintain a feeling of moral righteousness, thus bypassing the conscience
and escaping feelings of guilt.
Because the malignant narcissist silences his conscience with ongoing self-deceptions
he can repeatedly lie and behave in ways that oppose life, yet still believe that he is
on the side of good.
Or as Peck explains further:
“It is not their sins per se that characterize [malignant narcissists], rather it is the
subtlety and persistence and consistency of their sins.
This is because the central defect of [malignant narcissists] is not the sin but the refusal
to acknowledge it…Rather than blissfully lacking a sense of morality, like the psychopath,
[malignant narcissists] are continually engaged in sweeping the evidence of their evil under
the rug of their own consciousness…It is out of their failure to put themselves on
trial that their evil arises.”
One of the main self-deceptive mechanisms which the malignant narcissist uses to avoid
awareness of his morally imperfect self, is, paradoxically, the very mechanism that leads
him to commit some of his most evil acts.
This mechanism is scapegoating, which, as Peck notes, “works through a mechanism psychiatrists
call projection.”
The malignant narcissist unconsciously externalizes the emotions and motivations he cannot accept
in himself, attributing them to other people, and he then blames these targets for what
in reality are his own moral failings and wrongdoings.
“A predominant characteristic…of the behaviour of [malignant narcissists] is scapegoating.
Because in their hearts they consider themselves above reproach, they must lash out at anyone
who does reproach them.
Since they must deny their own badness, they must perceive others as bad…They never think
of themselves as evil; on the other hand, they consequently see much evil in others.”.
M. Scott Peck, People of the Lie Narcissistic scapegoating is on full display
in the political world.
Many politicians today are so desperate to appear morally righteous that they categorically
refuse to consider the possibility that their policies, mandates, and social reforms are
the primary drivers of much that is wrong with society.
When presented with evidence of their catastrophic failures, or when other people challenge their
morally flawless self-image, political malignant refuse to accept blame, and instead double
down on their policies and heap the blame for society's problems upon their favored
scapegoats – be it other nations, political opponents, or individuals who merely happen
to hold differing political views.
Or as Peck explains:
“Strangely enough, [malignant narcissists] are often destructive because they are attempting
to destroy evil.
The problem is that they misplace the locus of the evil.
Instead of destroying others they should be destroying the sickness within themselves…As
life often threatens their self-image of perfection, [malignant narcissists] are often busily engaged
in hating and destroying that life—usually in the name of righteousness…They sacrifice
others to preserve their self-image of perfection…They create for those under their dominion a miniature
sick society.”
M. Scott Peck, People of the Lie In observing the sick state of society, we
may be tempted to impose the diagnosis of malignant narcissism on any politician we
disapprove of.
But in doing so we run the risk not only of a misdiagnosis, but worse, of mimicking the
malignant narcissist's scapegoating behavior.
Or as Peck reflects:
“Indeed, might I not be guilty of evil myself by so labelling others who disagree with my
opinions?
Might I not be misusing the concept of evil by facilely applying it to any and all who
oppose my judgment?”
M. Scott Peck, People of the Lie To avoid misdiagnosing and scapegoating others,
we need to become more conscious of our dark side.
For the more aware we are of our own moral failures and potential for evil, the less
likely we are to project our dark side onto others.
Or as Jung writes: “Many projections can ultimately be integrated back into the individual
once he recognizes their subjective origin.
” (Carl Jung, Practice of Psychotherapy) But by facing up to our dark side, we do more
than withdraw our projections, we also develop a sixth sense to detect the darkness which
lurks behind the malignant narcissists' morally pure mask.
For as the psychologist Marie Louise von Franz observed:
“If one knows about the evil possibilities within oneself then one develops a kind of
second sight or capacity for getting a whiff of the same thing in other people…to go
down into the depths of one's own evil enables one usually to develop the instinctual recognition
of corresponding elements in other people.”
Marie Louise von Franz, The Interpretation of Fairy Tales
With a heightened capacity to detect evil, we can help others overcome their naivety
regarding the reality of human evil.
For the reason malignant narcissists are able to gain popular support and persist in positions
of political power, is because most people refuse to fathom the fact that someone who
tries so hard to appear good, can in reality be morally corrupt.
Most people, in other words, do not recognize that evil has a tendency to cloak itself in
the good.
Or as the psychologist Erich Fromm observed:
“…the main fallacy which prevents people from recognizing potential Hitlers before
they have shown their true faces…lies in the belief that a thoroughly destructive and
evil man must be a devil – and look his part; that he must bear the sign of Cain so
visibly that everyone can recognize his destructiveness from afar.
Such devils exist, but they are rare…much more often the intensely destructive person
will show a front of kindliness…he will speak of his ideals and good intentions…Hence,
as long as one believes that the evil man wears horns, one will not discover an evil
man.”
Erich Fromm, The Anatomy of Human Destructiveness As more of us become aware of the political
evil that is dividing and destroying society, we should try, as much as possible, not to
let anger and hatred sully our attempts to be a force of good.
Malignant narcissists are easy to hate, but harboring hatred only nourishes their malevolence
and makes us easy targets of scapegoating.
Hatred also harms us through the stress it generates in the mind and body.
Rather than stewing in hatred, we should focus our energies on spreading the truth, as truth
is one of the greatest weapons against evil – hence why Satan is often referred to as
“the father of lies”.
We should call out the hypocrisy of the political malignant narcissists, expose their lies,
mock their overweening moral pride, and watch on as the truth renders their behavior increasingly
desperate, erratic, and eventually self-destructive.
“Pride goeth before the fall”.
Or as M. Scott Peck concludes:
“The evil hate the light—the light of goodness that shows them up, the light of
scrutiny that exposes them, the light of truth that penetrates their deception.”
(Peck)
M. Scott Peck, People of the Lie