Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • In a theological debate, an atheist may  propose a circular argument by asserting,  

    在神學辯論中,無神論者可能會提出循環論證,聲稱

  • "God is merely a man-made concept because all  notions of God are inherently created by humans." 

    「上帝只是一個人造概念,因為上帝的所有概念本質上都是由人類創造的」。

  • This line of reasoning is inherently circularas it employs the premise of God's concept being  

    這種推理本質上是循環論證,因為它採用上帝概念是

  • human-generated as proof of its artificialityThe argument essentially concludes that God  

    人類產生的前提來證明其人為性。這個論證的基本結論是,上帝

  • is a man-made construct on the basis that  concepts of God originate from human thought

    是一個人造的概念,其基礎是上帝的概念源自於人類思想。

  • However, this reasoning is circular  because it assumes what it seeks to prove:  

    然而,這種推理是循環的,因為它假設了它想要證明的東西:

  • the premise that all ideas of God are human  creations is used to substantiate the conclusion  

    上帝的所有想法都是人類創造的前提被用來證實

  • that God, therefore, is a fabricated concept. This approach neglects to consider the possibility  

    上帝是一個捏造的概念的結論。這種方法忽略了考慮

  • of a divine entity existing independently of  human conceptualization, presupposing instead  

    神聖實體獨立於人類概念化而存在的可能性,而是預設人類

  • that the very act of human conception of God  invalidates the existence of a divine being

    對上帝的概念本身的行為使神聖存在的存在無效。

  • Such an argument fails to provide  external verification for its claim

    這樣的論點無法為其主張提供外部驗證

In a theological debate, an atheist may  propose a circular argument by asserting,  

在神學辯論中,無神論者可能會提出循環論證,聲稱

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it

B2 上帝 概念 人類 循環 神聖 結論

上帝是人造的概念嗎? 無神論者如何使用循環推理來反駁上帝的存在(Is god a man made concept? How athiest use circular reasoning to argue against god's existence)

  • 31 0
    Jay posted on 2023/11/24
Video vocabulary