Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • We are rapidly approaching the 30th published book  in the series, so even though we haven't gotten  

  • close to the present in terms of Warriors contentit's safe to say we've learned a lot about  

  • this world, its stories, and its characters. One  element that has been around since the first book,  

  • ingrained into nearly every choice the clans makein thewarrior code.” One of our protagonists of  

  • the last arc, Hollyleaf, was fixated on the codesometimes to the point of obsession. However,  

  • in the main series, what that code is has been  entirely nebulous. We've heard a couple of  

  • specific rules from it thrown out, such as that  you must feed your clan before yourself, that the  

  • safety of the whole clan is more important than  the safety of any one cat, that kits can't leave  

  • the camp without permission, and that strangers  must be driven from clan territory. However, only  

  • Secrets of the Clans, the first field guide, told  us exactly what rules are in the Warrior Code,  

  • and today, in this field guide, we will hear more  about what it is and, perhaps, how it came to be.

  • Code of the Clans came out on June 9th of  2009, the same day as Return to the Clans,  

  • over a month after Sunrise, and a year after the  last field guide: Cats of the Clans. As with that  

  • previous field guide, this one was written by  Victoria Holmes herself and illustrated by Wayne  

  • McLoughlin, though his illustrations aren't as  prominent as before, instead now being black and  

  • white pictures depicting scenes being written  about and mostly serving as decoration for the  

  • pages of writing rather than being the centerpiece  on their own. The way this book is divided is  

  • also quite interesting. Rather than going clan by  clan as the previous two field guides have done,  

  • this one goes one code at a time and tells  us either one or two stories about that code:  

  • what events inspired its formation, and  potentially also a more modern case where  

  • that code came into play. It will be interesting  to discuss how those stories fit into the Warriors  

  • world but that will have to wait until  we have laid down the book's contents.

  • We begin with a brief and condensed version  of the same origin of the clans story told  

  • in Secrets of the Clans. However, unlike  in that book where it was said that cats  

  • lived in small scattered groups all across  the territories until they met, fought,  

  • and were asked by their fallen friends to become  clans, here there is one group of cats who moved  

  • into the forest and split up according to  their living preferences, and they began  

  • fighting with each other only because prey was  scarce in leaf-bare. They then vowed over their  

  • fallen friends that they would end the fighting by  becoming five separate clans. Oh yeah, by the way  

  • there are five friends. In addition to Secrets of  the Clans' Thunder, Shadow, Wind, and River, this  

  • story introduces a fifth, Sky. None of them say  anything though because the story is too short.

  • Then, right off the bat, we get the list of  the rules in the Warrior Code, carried over  

  • from Secrets of the Clans with a different font  and presentation. To avoid reading off this list  

  • verbatim, I'm just going to leave it on the screen  while I say this so you can read it yourself,  

  • or pause if you need more time. Most of it is  probably familiar to a lot of you anyway if  

  • you're already familiar with Warriors as a series  but because some pieces have changed with time  

  • and it might have been a while since you read  parts of it, I figure a refresher is warranted.

  • From there, we begin with our framing  device for the book: you, the reader,  

  • are a loner or kittypet visiting Thunderclan  to learn about the warrior code and clan life,  

  • as agreed to by Firestar. Leafpool welcomes you  and says she will be telling you the stories-well,  

  • she calls it history rather than storiesof each code. The reader insert might not  

  • understand or agree with the code at first but  Leafpool explains that, having grown up in it,  

  • it's natural for them and there are a lot of  benefits like valuing and taking care of the sick,  

  • injured, and old and being strong enough  as a group to fight off common enemies.  

  • At the beginning of each code story, Leafpool  shares a short introductory blurb on the code  

  • and transitions us into the past, but I will  mostly be focusing on the stories themselves.

  • Up first is the tale of Ryewhisker and Cloudberry,  a Windclan and Riverclan cat respectively who were  

  • in a relationship many, many lifetimes agoBoth of them were happy to find out they were  

  • going to have kits despite some worries over  where they would grow up. Friendship across  

  • borders were nothing new, so that wasn't a  problem. However, a war starts between their  

  • clans over some stolen fish and Ryewhisker jumps  in to defend Cloudberry, and their unborn kits,  

  • from a clanmate. While they're arguing, a  Riverclan cat comes over and murders Ryewhisker  

  • himself. At a gathering of the leaders, they agree  that Ryewhisker's fate could have been avoided if  

  • he wasn't in a relationship with Cloudberry, and  they vote on the first rule of the warrior code,  

  • after agreeing to meet every moon for a night  of truce so they don't lose contact completely.  

  • I um…I don't think Ryewhisker's fate really had  anything to do with his relationship. Really it  

  • had to do with the established guideline that  killing cats randomly in battle when you aren't  

  • even fighting each other is perfectly  fine. But sure, this is where they got.

  • The second code story takes place three seasons  after the first, and at another gathering. This  

  • time the leaders are arguing about stealing  each others' prey, and one leader, Brindlestar,  

  • argues it's not stealing since they need it, and  can't currently find enough prey on their own  

  • territory. As the other leaders argue that each  clan lives where they are best suited and they  

  • need to find prey on their own territory, they  hear a crash and a tree falls into the middle  

  • of the crowded clearing below, managing to just  barely avoid all of Shadowclan and Thunderclan  

  • despite falling directly on top of them. They  take this as a sign that the clans will always be  

  • separate and make the second code, that cats can't  hunt or trespass on other clans' territories.

  • This code comes with an extra, more modern  story where Dappletail and White-eye,  

  • who would eventually become One-eye, sneak  onto Riverclan territory just to try tasting  

  • some fish. Unfortunately, White-eye falls in and  needs to be saved by Riverclan. Both Hailstar,  

  • Riverclan's leader, and Pinestar and SunfallThunderclan's leader and deputy, show up,  

  • thoroughly embarrassing both young she-cats. Assort of punishment for the foolish cats, Riverclan  

  • lets them try a fish and they quickly realize it  would not have been pleasant to begin with. It's  

  • actually a really funny scene, with the sarcasm  practically dripping off of Sunfall's responses  

  • to them. But they learn a valuable lesson  together that the code is there for a reason.

  • Code three's storyis one I have grown  unnecessary attachment to. Ahem. It  

  • tells the story of one of the first battles of  Sunningrocks from the perspective of Splashtail,  

  • a Riverclan warrior who knowswithin the elders' lifetimes,  

  • the river flowed around Sunningrocks rather than  past it. Now that it is accessible from the land,  

  • though, Thunderclan has tried to lay claim to  it. He notices Thunderclan intruders and soon,  

  • a battle begins. A she-cat with blazing green eyes  tells him that Starclan changed the course of the  

  • river and Sunningrocks is theirs now (ah hello  cat-who-would-become-my-oc). Riverclan seems  

  • to be losing but Darkstar says it is only lost  when they stop fighting, so they keep fighting  

  • and win. As Thunderclan runs, Splashtail sees  a Starclan spirit, Aspentail, who says they are  

  • kin who also fought for these rocks and they  will keep fighting until Thunderclan learns  

  • who Sunningrocks belongs to. Splashtail decides to  dedicate this battle to the elders who came before  

  • and the kits to come and then promises himself  that, if ever he became leader, he would make  

  • this a part of the warrior code. This is probably  the most tenuous as far as connections between the  

  • story and the code that it inspires but heyit inspired me. That counts for something.

  • This code also comes with a modern-ish  story, of Longtail and Darkstripe hunting  

  • for the clan while many of the warriors are  sick. They first manage to catch a squirrel,  

  • and because they are already starving and it won't  taste nearly as good when brought back to camp,  

  • they decide to share it in the forest to keep  their energy up. Unfortunately, they don't catch  

  • much other prey and one of the sick cats ends  up dead. Though Darkstripe is still defending  

  • their choice, Longtail feels very guilty, but  knows it is too late to change things now.

  • Code 4's story is about a couple of kits who  played with the last of their clan's prey until it  

  • wasn't fit to eat. Suddenly, an owl came and took  the prey away, though thankfully not the kits. The  

  • leader, Lilystar, took it as a sign that Starclan  gave them their prey and can take it away too,  

  • and decided to propose a new code that they  thank Starclan for their prey and its life.

  • Code 5's story is about a queen  named Daisytail who joined together  

  • with other mothers to put a stop to  cats too young fighting in battles,  

  • stopping a war between their clans to  remove all cats who looked like they  

  • wouldn't stand a chance. The young apprentices  were upset but their mothers knew it was right,  

  • and they proposed a code that kits can't  train until they reach their sixth moon.

  • As an addendum for this code, there ismore modern story of Brokenstar's reign,  

  • where he flagrantly broke this code. This  story focuses on a tom, far too young,  

  • named Badgerpaw and his mentor Flintfang in the  battle where they drove Windclan from the moor.  

  • Unfortunately, it also led to Badgerpaw's deathand Flintfang, trying to hold back his grief,  

  • let Badgerpaw pick his warrior nameBadgerfang, as he headed to Starclan.

  • The sixth code story is about a Riverclan medicine  cat who is frustrated by the number of injuries  

  • he has to heal after foolhardy young warriors  make dares to and play pranks on each other.  

  • They don't seem to understand the gravity of  being a warrior now, rather than an apprentice.  

  • He speaks with Starclan and has a vision of  responsible and mature warriors and gets the  

  • idea for a night of silent vigil to listen and  protect, which they enact. After that night,  

  • the same young warriors play out the scene  from his vision and Meadowpelt resolves  

  • to suggest a new warrior code, that this  same vigil be given to every new warrior.

  • As a bonus, we then get to hear Squirrelflight  talk about her own vigilwhich never happened  

  • since they had just arrived at the lake, but  fine. She gives us advice on how to avoid  

  • getting bored or annoyed by snoring or tense  from standing still all night, and generally  

  • it's a nice comedic interludetoo  bad it couldn't possibly be true.

  • Code 7's story is about a leader named  Featherstarahem, and her new deputy Acorntail  

  • who hasn't had an apprentice. Though she loves and  trusts him as he was her old deputy's apprentice,  

  • he has a hard time taking to the duties since  he has never been in charge of anyone before,  

  • and soon he admits he doesn't think he  can do the job. Featherstar realizes the  

  • skills cats learn when they become mentorspromises him Pricklekit as an apprentice,  

  • and vows to add a new rule to the code saying  deputy candidates have to have been mentors.

  • The story for code 8 is about a time in  which leaders were apparently chosen based  

  • on bloodline rather than the deputy ascending to  leadership. The current leader's son, Mothpelt,  

  • takes over after his father's death and both  he and the clan quickly realize he isn't as  

  • cut out for it, having not trained in the  job. Meanwhile, Maplewhisker, the deputy,  

  • is able to easily rally the clan and understand  what would best help them. Soon, they decide to  

  • let Maplewhisker take over as leader and makenew warrior code that the deputy becomes leader.

  • This code also comes with a bonus story, of  Tallstar talking to Bluestar about whether or  

  • not he made the right choice in switching who  would become leader so soon before his death,  

  • but he decides he agrees with his  choice, even if it causes a rocky future.

  • Code 9's story is one of the most famous from this  book. It's about a clan whose leader and deputy  

  • both grew ill together. After the leader diedthe deputy wasn't fit to go to the Moonstone,  

  • and soon she dies too, leaving the clan without  leadership. Two warriors: Mossfoot and Jumpfire,  

  • are nominated as potential leaders and  fight to the death to claim that spotand  

  • I do meanto the death.” They both dieThe medicine cat is given permission by  

  • Starclan to fake a sign to choose the new  leader, Flowerstem, and their first act  

  • as a pair is to make a new code that the  new deputy must be chosen before moonhigh.

  • The story for the tenth code is about a leader who  broke the existing full-moon truce, Ripplestar,  

  • by attacking everyone at a gatheringStarclan then effectively killed him  

  • by sending a bolt of lightning to  hurtle him off a cliff. The clans  

  • then decided to make honoring the  full-moon truce part of the code.

  • Story 11 tells us of a time when cats didn't mark  their boundaries, or frankly visit them often,  

  • and an apprentice, Mottlepaw, got in  trouble for stumbling over the line. When  

  • the other clan came to camp to complain about  Mottlepaw, his mentor, and mother, Poppycloud,  

  • suggested that maybe the code should tell clans  to mark their borders, and challenge trespassers  

  • since they could then be sure it wasn't a mistakeThe clans make it official at the next gathering.

  • One of my favorite supplemental  stories accompanies this chapter,  

  • as Whitestorm teaches Firepaw, GraypawRavenpaw, Sandpaw, and Dustpaw about  

  • border tactics. The information about how  to travel along and mark a border isn't new,  

  • but it's just a delightful comedic scene oozing  with character and I love seeing all the little  

  • details woven in. Oh also, Whitestorm  is still very canonically old, here.

  • The twelfth code story is about a medicine cat  called Graywing, no not that one, who stopped  

  • a clanmate from intervening as three kits from  another clan fell into and subsequently drowned  

  • in the river, as she didn't want to risk their  clan's lives to save another clan's kits. Later,  

  • she receives a vision of all three kits grown  up, one of them becoming a leader, and they  

  • tell her kits' lives are always precious. She  goes out to find the kits' bodies and bring them  

  • to their clan and vows to help make it a rule in  the code that every warrior help kits in danger.

  • The addendum to this story is aboutShadowclan patrol who decided to save  

  • tiny and innocent little Tigerkit of Thunderclanwho would of course go on to do horrible things,  

  • from a fox. As he is saved by them, he says  he won't ever forget this and Shadowclan will  

  • always be his friendswhich I don't know if  I believe considering how Thunderclan-Only  

  • he was until he was exiled but it does  make a haunting bit of foreshadowing.

  • The thirteenth tale is about a Skyclan leader  named Darkstar who decided in the middle of a  

  • gathering to give up a large piece of their land  to Thunderclan, without his deputy, Raincloud,  

  • even being consulted. As she pleaded for  him to reconsider or at least talk to his  

  • clanmates about it, Darkstar proposed  a new code that no one could question a  

  • leader's decision and, surprise, all the clan  leaders liked that idea and set it in stone.

  • As if to hammer in how bad a decision this  was, the bonus story here is from Cloudstar's  

  • perspective, the last Skyclan leader before  they were banished from the forest. He is  

  • trying to make the best of the gorge home  they have settled in but is clearly losing  

  • hope and the health of his clanmates. Howeverhe reassures himself that it will be okay, that  

  • Skyclan will exist as long as he does, because  the word of the clan leader is the warrior code.

  • And now we learn that it apparently took  fourteen codes for the clans to decide killing  

  • unnecessarily is a bad idea. In this story, the  medicine cats from clans that have been engaged  

  • in a very bloody war consult Starclan and are  each visited by a warrior who died unnecessarily,  

  • with their attacker continuing to hurt them  when they had already given up. Seeing this  

  • united brutality, the medicine cats decide  to demand a new code at the next gathering:  

  • that cats don't have to kill to  win battles, with some exceptions.

  • Finally, and most recently, we get to  the fifteenth code story, about Pinestar,  

  • the leader when Lionheart was an apprenticesneaking off repeatedly to spend time with the  

  • kittypets on his ninth life. Lionpaw discovers  this and Pinestar, after first just lying,  

  • eventually admits that he wants to be a kittypet  rather than a clan leader now. At Lionpaw's  

  • demand, Pinestar comes back to announce  this outright to the clan, and eventually,  

  • because of this, the clans make the rule  that warriors reject the life of a kittypet.

  • Sandstorm, young Sandstorm, gives us  the supplemental story for this one,  

  • telling us about how careless Fireheart ishow he's such a troublemaker, and how Dustpelt  

  • always tells her he'll never belong since he's  a kittypet. But after Tigerclaw was found out,  

  • by him, when even Bluestar couldn't tell, she  begins to think he had a clearer perspective  

  • *because* he was a kittypet and that Fireheart  himself has rejected the life of a kittypet just  

  • like the warrior code says. Maybe it's okay that  she loves him more than she's ever loved anyone.

  • To round us off at the very end, Leafpool tells us  about a few codes that were proposed but rejected:  

  • namely that only pure-blood forest cats could be  warriors, suggested by the same Featherstar from  

  • code 7's story, that clans should only eat  the food they were most suited to hunting,  

  • and that every clan cat mush  worship Starclan. With that done,  

  • Leafpool escorts us out of the  territory and concludes our book.

  • Even speeding through each story at a truly  extreme pace while ignoring most of the details,  

  • this video has already been going for quite  a while, so it should be obvious that this  

  • book is packed with information and, if you  read it or have already read it yourself,  

  • I'm sure you could come to enjoy many of  the stories and the little intricacies added  

  • to each one. The tones range from light and  comedic to grim and solemn and each has some  

  • character moments worth looking into. With  that said, let's get into the notes I have.

  • First of all, given what we've heard in previous  books, there are some times cats have mentioned  

  • things being against the warrior code that  don't now seem to align to any of the codes.  

  • Most obviously, medicine cats not being allowed to  take a mate or kits is not listed here anywhere,  

  • and other than the words of the medicine  cat ceremony being slightly different,  

  • there never has been and, in fact, never will  be, an indication that there is such thing as a  

  • medicine cat code. Medicine cats definitely  live by different rules than warriors,  

  • but their rules have never been pinned down as  distinctly as the code of the warriors' has,  

  • and medicine cats are still expected to follow  most of the rules in the warrior code. In fact, in  

  • this book, medicine cats were the key figures who  invented the codes in four of our fifteen stories.  

  • So where the rule that medicine cats can't take  a mate or have kits goes is anyone's guess. Aside  

  • from medicine cats, though, the first arc said  things like forcing another leader to share land,  

  • attacking cats on a mission from Starclan or for  all the clans, kits hunting, joining with one clan  

  • to drive out another, and feeding enemy warriors  are all against the warrior code and that it is  

  • part of the code that cats must protect the whole  clan over any one member and show compassion. None  

  • of this is mentioned in the code we now haveso it's up to reader interpretation to say how  

  • much of it is real, guideline, difference between  clans, or otherwise. Considering the code itself  

  • is never quoted in full within the main seriesand never will be, it's a matter of debate.

  • Secondly, we have to talk about what exactly  the stories in this book are. Yes, Leafpool  

  • plainly introduces us to the book by saying she's  telling us the history of how pieces of the code  

  • came to be. But this is Leafpool, a very very  modern cat who wasn't alive for even the most  

  • recent of the code stories, the one that had to  do with her leader's leader's leader, Pinestar.  

  • The previous field guide, Cats of the Clanscame from an ancient and seemingly omnipotent,  

  • though no less biased, narrator: Rockbut Leafpool doesn't have any of that  

  • omnipotence or perfect knowledge of ancient  history. Meanwhile the first field guide,  

  • Secrets of the Clans, had no one overarching  narrator and instead began by mentioning that  

  • these stories and information were passed down  over generations and generations of warriors,  

  • openly admitting that details could have been lost  or invented over time. I bring up this skepticism  

  • because I don't believe these stories tell an  objective truth about how each code was invented,  

  • and the order in which they were. Even without  bringing in foreknowledge that will be solidified  

  • in the future about some of these codes being  created or practiced long before any of these  

  • stories take place, the stories themselves  don't always make sense. Why specifically  

  • does fighting over generations for Sunningrocks  inspire Splashheart to feed the elders and kits  

  • before apprentices and warriors, rather than any  other reaction? If clan leaders were chosen by  

  • blood rather than by their deputy succeeding  them before the deputy code was cemented,  

  • why does that idea never appear in any of the  code stories before or in Secrets of the Clans?  

  • If cats weren't allowed to hunt or trespass  on others' territories since the time of the  

  • second code story, why did it take so many  generations, until the eleventh code story,  

  • for even one cat to consider enforcing that ruleIf, in the first code story, the clans hadn't  

  • developed a lack of empathy for cats across the  borders yet, why did everyone immediately blame  

  • Ryewhisker's fate on his relationship instead  of on the random warrior who killed him without  

  • a fight while he was having a conversation, and  not attacking anyone? If they had already agreed  

  • on a full-moon gathering with a truce so long agowhy did it take so long to cement it in the code,  

  • or why was a code for it needed when it was  already an established guideline? Why did  

  • no one ever suggest until the fourteenth code  that unnecessary and consistent murders were a  

  • bad idea? If the clans only set down the rule that  warriors reject kittypet life after Pinestar left,  

  • why were they so hated before that point? Why  did Pinestar have to lie to avoid the shame of  

  • just spending some time with some kittypetsWhy are so many of these codes only about  

  • the cat who inspired the code and stop before  the actual vote of the leaders to cement it?

  • All across the book there are small moments like  this that prick at my suspicions, either seeming  

  • entirely implausible, illogical things for cats  to have thought of in the moment, or improperly  

  • timed in the history. The book doesn't say as much  but given who our narrator is, I believe these may  

  • be closer to the stories the clan cats tell each  other about why each code was formed, rather than  

  • objective truth. It's definitely possible for the  leaders to vote in a new code and it's entirely  

  • possible that even some of these stories are  true or almost true, but I don't think all of the  

  • codes listed here came about in response to these  stories, and I don't believe every detail in these  

  • stories to be true. That's not to say I think the  book goes against or just isn't canon, but I do  

  • believe that, much like Secrets of the Clans, it  alludes to clan folktales more than clan history.

  • The warrior code always has been and likely always  will be a contentious subject in the fandom,  

  • and though Secrets of the Clans was strictly  the first book to introduce it in list form,  

  • it is often this book that bares the heaviest  analysis and critique as we wonder why the clans  

  • came up with some of the counterintuitiveignored, or harmful rules they did. Even so,  

  • considering it didn't invent the code, I am  happy to see how well Leafpool's commentary  

  • and the stories she shares explains some of how  that code is justified in the clans' history,  

  • and taking this book as a piece of clan folkloreit becomes even more enjoyable to think about. As  

  • long as, one day, the clans realize their code  may need even more augmentations. For us though,  

  • as a book, the stories, both those  far in the past and more recent,  

  • are all very entertaining tales worth digging  into for how cute, funny, heartbreaking, dramatic,  

  • or even scary they can be. Of course, many of  those more recent stories did drop the names  

  • and dynamics of someinteresting new catsones we of course don't know yet. A month  

  • from the release of this book, though, we would  finally get some larger context for that world,  

  • long before Firestar joined the clansand that mess of a period is what we will  

  • be digging into next when we return forfuture episode, of our trip through time.

We are rapidly approaching the 30th published book  in the series, so even though we haven't gotten  

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it