Subtitles section Play video
When investors think of financial markets, the
first thing that likely comes to mind is the stock
market. But there's actually a bigger, less
flashy counterpart to the equity market: the bond
market. Probably the biggest market out there
when it comes to capital markets, you hear a lot
about the equity side, but in reality the bond
market is much, much bigger.
At the heart of it lies one of the safest assets
in the world, U.S.
Treasury bonds. As interest rates have risen
over the past few years, treasuries have offered
some of the highest yields in decades.
The US Treasury market is a large market in the U.S
. fixed income world, it's giving you higher yield
than it has in the last 20 years.
The yield levels and the income opportunity is is
much, much more interesting and attractive
today than 12, 18, 24 months ago.
We've been used to having incredibly low yields here
in the US and globally.
Buyers of US treasuries have been changing, and
the shift could have broad implications for the
US economy.
We've seen over the last couple of years is we've
seen a declining appetite for US government debt,
which is really unusual.
The US sort of stood out across all the other
countries as being so dependent on foreign
investors.
China's pulled back as a buyer, Japan has pulled
back as a buyer.
China and Japan have not over many, many years been
huge buyers. I feel like we have not paid attention
to the treasury market because it was a market
for foreigners or for the
Fed. Now it's a market for all of us and it's giving
you better yield. So it's something which we should
not ignore.
So why are major buyers fleeing the Treasury
market? What's the impact on yields and the economy
at large? And just how can investors best
navigate the market going forward?
So we have a really healthy overall bond
market in the US.
It comprises of US government bonds,
corporate bonds, mortgage bonds.
Treasuries is a key one, which is basically the
federal government issuing debt for their
funding needs.
Almost half the bond market is the US Treasury
market, according to the Bloomberg Aggregate Bond
Index, which tracks the performance of US
investment grade bonds and is widely considered
to represent the bond market as a whole.
Us treasuries account for over 42% of the index.
So I almost view the Treasury market as the
benchmark bond market, which is used for every
other corporate bond.
And sets the tone as sort of the risk free rate for
all the other investments in the bond market.
So those bonds are considered to be very,
very safe investments because they're guaranteed
by the US government.
If you're going to invest a dollar into Treasury
bonds, you're going to get that that dollar back.
While the Federal Reserve doesn't directly control
Treasury yield levels, their actions on
short-term borrowing rates or the Fed funds
rate can indirectly feed its way through the
market. That's another thing that we've seen
consistently over the past year and a half or so
that as the Fed has raised its benchmark
borrowing rates, say by a quarter point or half a
point, the Treasury market has generally
followed in kind. If the Fed's going higher, bond
holders generally say, okay, we want more yield
as well. US Treasury buyers can generally be
classified into one of two sub categories:
domestic and foreign.
On the one hand, you have your domestic buyers, of
which the Federal Reserve is one of the largest
buyers of treasuries.
Just a year ago, the Fed was a big buyer.
But the Fed steps in when they are doing QE,
quantitative easing, is where they step in as a
buyer. You have pensions, insurance companies, money
market funds, real money investors as well as banks
that buy treasuries.
And on the foreign side, we see pretty good demand
from a variety of countries for for
treasuries, both Japan as well as China are very
large holders of Treasury bonds.
Foreign investors are a big buyer base.
It's a much smaller buyer base today than it was
ten, 15 years ago, but it's still a solid source
of demand. Historically, perception has always been
that given the fact that treasuries are very
desired by both domestic as well as foreign
investors, that there's always demand for
treasuries. But that thesis was put to test
late last year, when we saw the surge in Treasury
supply because of of an increase in both bill as
well as coupon issuance.
In the last few years, so I'm talking about the last
couple of years, really since Covid, we've seen
foreign demand for treasuries declining
significantly. There's been a pretty major shift
in the buyer base of treasuries away from some
of the more traditional players, like the foreign
governments in general and even the Federal
Reserve themselves.
Demand from global central banks,
particularly Japan and China, are huge buyers of
US debt. They have pulled back, particularly China
has pulled back quite a bit.
Their holdings are now less than $1 trillion,
which is the first time that's happened in a
number of years.
Both Japan and China, while still ranked as the
top two foreign holders of US treasuries, have
seen their respective holdings decline in recent
years, right around the same time the Federal
Reserve began raising interest rates in March of
2022. For example, Japan has historically been a
very, very large buyer of the US treasuries.
They had a significant yield pickup by buying US
treasuries for a very long time, compared to
what they can find at home. That has been
eroding of late, because if I am a life insurance
company in Japan, my liabilities are in yen.
And so if even if I earn a lot of dollars on my
Treasury position, I need to hedge it back to yen
because my payment is made in yen.
Their cost of buying treasuries on a currency
adjusted basis has gone up quite meaningfully over
the last six months.
Two other big buyers that emerged in the last few
years was the Fed that was doing QE to try and be
stimulative to the economy. Well, QE is over.
We're actually undergoing quantitative tightening.
So the fed is not buying.
They're actually letting their portfolio shrink.
There's still very large holders of US treasuries,
but they're not as actively buying.
And the other one was banks. Domestic banks very
big buyers of treasuries since Covid because
deposits grew significantly and loan
demand wasn't high, well deposits have been
shrinking. The Treasury has had to rely on other
market participants to step in and take down that
additional supply.
And so now the new marginal buyer is really
US domestic investors.
And who's that: that's mutual funds, households,
pension, insurance.
And they've been kind of picking up the slack to a
certain extent as these, you know, foreign kind of
demand and buyers have been stepping away.
So when I think of the natural buyers of
treasuries, those that would buy treasuries, you
know, not necessarily because they expected it
to work in a portfolio sense, those buyers are
gone. As we're seeing a shift towards some of
these more domestic investors, be it, again,
hedge fund mutual funds, individual investors, uh,
what we're observing is that there are a lot more
price sensitive.
They're just not quite as as sticky.
So we would expect to see a little bit more
volatility here going forward.
That's why you look at the Treasury market.
Now we're moving even when the Fed's not doing
anything. The fed hasn't hiked rates or cut rates
um in the last six months.
And yet the ten year moves 7 to 8 basis points
on a daily basis.
And then also this other concept of what we call a
term premium, which means the extra yield that
investors want for holding longer-term
securities. Investors want to be compensated for
taking down that additional supply.
That's played a significant role in the
rise so far in Treasury yields, which now we've
seen the ten year yield actually eclipse 5% at one
point. Elevated Treasury yields, in particular the
ten year yield, can have a ripple effect on the
broader economy.
The ten year is considered a direct feed
through to certain parts of the market,
particularly mortgage rates.
As the ten year yield rises, mortgage rate
generally rises in tandem.
It sets the floor for interest rates and then
every other the mortgage rate is going to be higher
than that, and the corporate rate is going to
be higher. For instance, when the ten year yield
was close to 5%, mortgage rates were north of 8%.
So that's why we sort of call it the benchmark ten
year. Note that it is something that markets and
also lenders, banks, that kind of thing position a
lot of their other rates off.
You can see a scenario where the Fed's cut rates
to 3% and the ten year is still at 4%, because we
just don't have enough buyers off the ten year
within the US domestic space.
Similarly, high Treasury yields can also have an
impact on the stock market.
If, for example, the risk free rate or say, the ten
year yield from a from a Treasury perspective is
very, very high and you as an investor just feels
like all I need is a 5% return on my savings.
Well guess what? That's where you're probably
going to just put it into treasury yields.
Because again, if your risk free rate is this,
then the moment I start to take on risk, I should
get paid more. You want to make sure that you get
some return on top of that risk free rate.
I would say in general I am positive on bonds.
Fed is done.
It's a good hedge against risk assets and there's
likely to be money moving out of money market funds
and bank deposits into bonds.
Our view is that we should expect a little bit
more of a stable environment coming into
2024. The Federal Reserve, we think, is done
from their, you know, hiking cycle.
We don't expect them to hike rates anymore.
So we expect Treasury yields to decline
gradually during the course of this year, as
the expectation in the market is for the fed to
cut rates. And when the fed starts to cut rates
normally, that's the start of a bull market.
If the fed continues where some of the ending their
cut, as we call it, or the FX hedging costs
starts falling, and some of these foreign buyers
and the Federal Reserve's perhaps start stepping
back in at some point, then that could, you know,
absorb some of those price sensitive buyers
volatility. Yields look quite attractive.
Ten year yields are still slightly north of 4%.
We like to stress to investors that the yield
and therefore the income is the vast majority of
the returns for fixed income.
So at these high levels, you have a much better
opportunity. As for investors who may have
missed out on the 5% Treasury yield back in
October of 2023.
Owning the ten year at 5% now, in hindsight, looks
like a great trade. But had the fed raised rates
again in December, that trade would have
underperformed. I would say that if you go back in
history, these yields are still very, very
attractive compared to what we've seen for the
past 15, 20 years.
So to say, I think a lot of things have to go a
certain way for that ten year to be a bad
investment at 4%.
You missed a little bit of that, but I think
there's still a lot of room and carry.
If you were to buy the ten year here, there is a
lot of good opportunities out there and particularly
if you take a medium to longer-term perspective,
this is an attractive entry point, all in all.