Alright, today I wanttotalkaboutsomethingthatpeoplehaverepeatedlyaskedmetotalkabout, and I'm justgoingtobestraightup.
A lotofyouguysprobablywon't likewhat I'm abouttosay.
Tobeclear, I don't saythingsjusttoagreewith a commonnarrative, I thinkit's incrediblydamagingwhenYouTubecreatorsonlyevertalkaboutthingsthattheyknowtheiraudiencewillapplaudthemfor, orworseyet, iftheysaythingstheydon't evenbelieveforthatsamepurpose.
Butregardlessofwhat I expecttohappen, thesearemyactualhonestopinionson a storythathasrecentlygainedquite a bitoftraction.
ThestoryisaboutBlackMythWukong, whichisanupcomingactionRPGpublishedbyGameScience, a Chinesedeveloper, with a storyoriginallytoldby a popular 16thcenturynovel.
Itlooksgood, makenomistakethere.
Itlooksfun, itlookswellmade, and I certainlyhaveaninterestinplayingitmyself.
Butfortoday, we'renottalkingabouttheactualgame, we'retalkingaboutitsdevelopers, we'retalkingabout a consultingcompanythateveryonelovestohaterightnowcalledSBI, orSweetBabyIncorporated.
Lightningfastbackstory.
SweetBabyIncorporatedhasbecomeanabsolutepariahinthevideogameindustryasoflatebecausetheytryveryhardtoinjectthemselvesintothenarrativestoryofwhateverprojecttheycan, and a lotofthosestoriesendupbeingcompletegarbageas a result.
Theiremployeestrytocancelalloftheircritics, theirdefendersrepeatedlymakeupliesorconvenientlymisinterpretargumentsinthemostuncharitablewayspossible, andforanyonewhoneedstohearthis, SBIis a poxontheindustry.
Gamingwouldbeholisticallybetteroffiftheyjustceasedtoexist, and I myselfhavebeenveryvocalaboutthatfactoverthepastfewmonths, attheveryleast, astheyperpetratebehaviorthat I feelhasnoplaceintheentireindustry.
Tobeasclearaspossible, I havenosympathyforthem.
Thisisnotmedefendingthem, thisismecritiquingtheconceptofmedialiteracyregarding a storythattheyhappentobeattachedtobecauseresponsibilityandtruthareconsistentprinciplesregardlessofwhothesubjectis.
I guesswhat I'm tryingtosayisthatSweetBabyIncorporatedis a companyownedandoperatedbypeoplewhom I considertobedeceptive, predatory, andopportunistic, butnoneofthatactuallychangeswhat I seehappeningherewithBlackMythWukong, whichiswhy I'm makingthevideo.
Justbecausetheyare a certainwaydoesnotmeanthat I havetobeoranyoneelseshouldbe.
I hopeeveryonecanunderstandthatandbearwithmeas I tellyoupreciselywhythatis.
Thisrighthereiswhat I'm talkingabout, andtoproperlydemonstrate, I'vechosenthisarticlerightnowfrom a randomwebsitecalledTech4Gamers.
Nothingagainstthempersonally, justtobeclear, there's quite a fewsimilarexamplesoutthere I coulddrawfrom, butthisoneis a prettygoodshowcaseofwhat I mean.
Ifyou're a creativeworkinginAAA, which I didformany, manyyears, putthisstuffuptoyourhigher-ups, andiftheydon't seethevalueinwhatyou'reaskingforwhenyouaskforconsultants, whenyouaskforresearch, gohave a coffeewithyourmarketingteamandjustterrifythemwiththepossibilityofwhat's goingtohappeniftheydon't giveyouwhatyouwant.
Have a coffeewithmarketingsothatyoucanabsolutelyterrifythembytellingthem, here's what's goingtohappenifyoudon't dothis.
Yeah, see, that's a validthingtocriticize, anditbasicallysoundslikethiscompanyengagesinsoftcoreextortionsotheycancramtheirdipshitnarrativeideasintoasmanygamesaspossible, whichis, again, a perfectlydeservingthingtocallout.
Butbearwithmehere.
Furtherdowninthearticle, wefindthis, quote, Accordingto a Chinesemediapressrelease, GameSciencerefusedtotakethecompany's guidanceastheydemandedanunbelievablyhigh $7 million.
Okay, soSweetBabyIncorporated, a companythatishighlyscrutinizedrightnowfortheirbehavior, which I, amongmanyothers, considertobefairlydespicablebehavior, allegedlyattemptedtoextort $7 millionfromGameScience, thedevelopersbehindBlackMythWukong, andwereshutdownintheprocess, leadingto a pressreleasebyChinesemedia, whichisnowbeingdiscussedhere.
Right?
Clear?
Excellent.
Except… No, it's not.
See, ifyouactuallygotothesourcethattheycited, it's a randomTwitteruser, namedPirateNation, with a lengthypostoftheirowntranslating a blockoftextfromChinesetoEnglishwiththecaption, quote, Chinesemedia, BlackMythWukong, refusedtobeextorted $7 millionbySweetBaby, endquote.
PirateNationdoesn't giveanydetailsonthetruesourceoftheallegationintheirpost, asidefrom a screenshot, butifyoutrackdowntheactualplacethatthisclaimoriginallycamefrom, youfindithere, on a platformcalledWeibo, postedby a usernamedTianhu.
Thisiswhere I sortajusthavetosayithowitis.
Weibois a Chinesemicrobloggingsocialmediaplatform, andTianhuis, forlackof a betterword, aninfluencer.
Hehas a sizablefollowing, sure, butneithertheplatformnorthepersononitqualifyasChinesemedia.
Whatwe'retalkingabouthereistheequivalentof a largeFacebookuserpostingtheiropinionwithzero, countem, zerocitedsources.
Noactualconnectiontothedevelopmentteam, whatsoever, andnodiscernibleauthorityonthisthat I couldfindanywhereonline.
Andbelieveme, I tried.
Somehow, a Chinesesocialmediauserwith a couplehundredthousandfollowersmakes a postwithquiteliterallyzeroevidence.
AnotheruseronTwitterpicksitupandattributesthatclaimtoChinesemedia, leadingtobloggersornewsoutletsrunningwiththestoryclaimingthatasper a Chinesemediapressrelease, whichisonestepevenfurtherremovedfromreality, SweetBabyIncorporatedtriedtoextort $7 millionfromGameScience.
Whentherealityisthattheirsourceisactuallyjust a randomTwitteruserquoting a randomWeibouser.
Justtoputthisinperspective, I hope, I don't carehowbigsomeone's socialmediafollowingis, a randompersononFacebookpostingclaimswithzerocitedsourcesandzeroevidenceisnotanAmericanmediapressrelease.
That's nothowanyofthisworks.
Sadly, thiskindofmedialiteracyisobviouslyrare.
A lotofpeoplehavedecidedtorunwiththeballhere, and I can't fullyblamethem, becauseSweetBabyIncorporateddefinitelybroughtthisonthemselvesbyactingthewaythattheyhaveandsayingthethingsthattheydo, butthisentiresubjectisgettingtwistedbeyondrecognition.
Afterthiswholethinggotstarted, a heftyamountofpeoplebeganclaimingthatthisarticlerightherefromIGNwasevidenceoftheclaimbeingtrue.
Andyes, I canseewhythepuzzlepieceskindoffit, maybe, buttheyreallysortofdon't.
Thearticleisbad, nodoubtaboutthat, okay?
I cancriticizethisthingfordays, andthetranslationisaboutasmaliciousasyoucanexpect, whichmakesitevenmorebelievablethatthiswas a hitpiecedesignedtoinflictasmuchdamageaspossible.
However, thisis a companywhousesrecruitmentpostslikethis, forexample, toadvertise.
Throughthelensofdiversity, equity, inclusion, andsensitivity, I canseewhytheygotupsetenoughtowrite a pieceaboutthiscompany, and I don't thinkithasanythingtodowithSweetBabyIncorporated.
Theentiresubjecthasbecome a rallyingcryinthedumbestwaypossible.
Afterthiswholethinghappened, I startedseeingpostsabouthowsuccessfulBlackMythWukongwillbebecausegamersrejecttheinfluenceofSBI, whichtheydo, bytheway, that's true.
And I evensawpeopletalkingabouthowthegamewasnumberoneonSteam's topsellerlistbecausegamersweresending a messageandwinningthewar.
ThisentirethingremindsmeoftheancientEgyptianlegendOuroboros, whichis a serpenteatingitsowntail.
A socialmediauserinChina, seeingtheverywell-deservedirethatSweetBabyIncorporatedhasearnedthemselveshereintheWest, decidedtothrowout a paragraphregardingIGNandSweetBabyInteractiveandmade a claimaboutSBIapproachinggamescience.
A fewdaysafterthatrandomclaimhitsWeibo, a userwhofeelsthesamewayonTwittertranslatesitoverandsaysChinesemedia, leadingtobloggersandinfluencersheresayingthat a ChinesemediapressreleasehassomehowhighlightedSBI's extortionschemeplainasday, whichwasreallyjust a personwhoprobablysawthenewshereandthenstartedconnectingsomedots, whichisfine, butweshouldlookatthestoryforwhatitreallyis.
I mean, comeon, guys.
I'm tryingtokeepittogetherhere, butcomeon.
Chinahasanentireethicspanelforvideogames, whichwasestablishedtoimplementthespiritofnationalpropaganda, including a directivetoblockgamesthatincludehomosexualityorpregnancybeforemarriage, amongmanyotherthings.
That's notveryDEIofthem, andspeakstotheextremelyrestrictiverealityofgamepublishingintheChinesemarket, whichmeansthatevenifSweetBabyIncorporatedsomehowdeludedthemselvesintothinkingthattheywouldbeallowedtohaveanysayinthenarrativeof a Chinese-centeredvideogame, theywouldbeshutdownimmediately, becausehalfthestuffthatthey'redeterminedtoforceintothesegames, theDEIagendas I mean, isspecificallydeniedonprinciplebytheChinesegovernment.
What I'm tryingtosayisthatSweetBabyIncorporatedsucks.
Theiremployeesoftenusedeceptivetacticstogetwhattheywant, theycertainlyhaveanimpacthereintheWesterngamingmarketwhenitcomestovideogamenarrativesthatthey'reemployedtoworkon, andtheyshouldn't, andit's annoying, andthere's a never-endingparadeofreasonstocriticizethem, validreasons I mightadd.
Butthis?
Thisdoesn't appeartobeoneofthem.
Andwhile I understandthat a lotofpeoplearepassionateaboutthisstuffgenerallyspeaking, I thinkit's importanttoanalyze a storyforwhatitreallyis, notjustwhatwewishitwere.
Endoftheday, I don't thinkthestoryisreal.
Everysingleinstinctthat I haveisscreamingatmethatthisstoryisjustfull-sendfabricationentirely.
Andsince a goodnumberofpeoplehaveaskedmetotalkaboutit, theydirectlyaskedmetodiscussthis, forbetterorforworse, I did.
Thisismediscussingit.
I know a lotofyouwon't likewhatyoujustheard, butit's myactualGod's honestopiniononthings, andthat's whatthischannelis.
That's it.
Ifyouwanttosupportanythingthat I do, oranythingthat I willdointhefuture, linksaredownbelow.
PatreonandLocals, monthlysubscriptions, that's a greatway, aswellas a specialVPNdealforanyonewhowantsit, it's a reallysoliddealdownbelow, linkedinthedescription.
But I'llcutitthereandstoprambling.
Asalways, thankyouallforwatching, thisisParticularFittingfortoday, questioneverything, andhave a nicenight.
Alright, today I wanttotalkaboutsomethingthatpeoplehaverepeatedlyaskedmetotalkabout, and I'm justgoingtobestraightup.
Subtitles and vocabulary
Click the word to look it upClick the word to find further inforamtion about it