Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • So, here we go: a flyby of play.

  • It's got to be serious if the New York Times

  • puts a cover story of their February 17th Sunday magazine about play.

  • At the bottom of this, it says, "It's deeper than gender.

  • Seriously, but dangerously fun.

  • And a sandbox for new ideas about evolution."

  • Not bad, except if you look at that cover, what's missing?

  • You see any adults?

  • Well, lets go back to the 15th century.

  • This is a courtyard in Europe,

  • and a mixture of 124 different kinds of play.

  • All ages, solo play, body play, games, taunting.

  • And there it is. And I think this is a typical picture

  • of what it was like in a courtyard then.

  • I think we may have lost something in our culture.

  • So I'm gonna take you through

  • what I think is a remarkable sequence.

  • North of Churchill, Manitoba, in October and November,

  • there's no ice on Hudson Bay.

  • And this polar bear that you see, this 1200-pound male,

  • he's wild and fairly hungry.

  • And Norbert Rosing, a German photographer,

  • is there on scene, making a series of photos of these huskies, who are tethered.

  • And from out of stage left comes this wild, male polar bear,

  • with a predatory gaze.

  • Any of you who've been to Africa or had a junkyard dog come after you,

  • there is a fixed kind of predatory gaze

  • that you know you're in trouble.

  • But on the other side of that predatory gaze

  • is a female husky in a play bow, wagging her tail.

  • And something very unusual happens.

  • That fixed behavior -- which is rigid and stereotyped

  • and ends up with a meal -- changes.

  • And this polar bear

  • stands over the husky,

  • no claws extended, no fangs taking a look.

  • And they begin an incredible ballet.

  • A play ballet.

  • This is in nature: it overrides a carnivorous nature

  • and what otherwise would have been a short fight to the death.

  • And if you'll begin to look closely at the husky that's bearing her throat to the polar bear,

  • and look a little more closely, they're in an altered state.

  • They're in a state of play.

  • And it's that state

  • that allows these two creatures to explore the possible.

  • They are beginning to do something that neither would have done

  • without the play signals.

  • And it is a marvelous example

  • of how a differential in power

  • can be overridden by a process of nature that's within all of us.

  • Now how did I get involved in this?

  • John mentioned that I've done some work with murderers, and I have.

  • The Texas Tower murderer opened my eyes,

  • in retrospect, when we studied his tragic mass murder,

  • to the importance of play,

  • in that that individual, by deep study,

  • was found to have severe play deprivation.

  • Charles Whitman was his name.

  • And our committee, which consisted of a lot of hard scientists,

  • did feel at the end of that study

  • that the absence of play and a progressive suppression of developmentally normal play

  • led him to be more vulnerable to the tragedy that he perpetrated.

  • And that finding has stood the test of time --

  • unfortunately even into more recent times, at Virginia Tech.

  • And other studies of populations at risk

  • sensitized me to the importance of play,

  • but I didn't really understand what it was.

  • And it was many years in taking play histories of individuals

  • before I really began to recognize that I didn't really have a full understanding of it.

  • And I don't think any of us has a full understanding of it, by any means.

  • But there are ways of looking at it

  • that I think can give you -- give us all a taxonomy, a way of thinking about it.

  • And this image is, for humans, the beginning point of play.

  • When that mother and infant lock eyes,

  • and the infant's old enough to have a social smile,

  • what happens -- spontaneously -- is the eruption of joy on the part of the mother.

  • And she begins to babble and coo and smile, and so does the baby.

  • If we've got them wired up with an electroencephalogram,

  • the right brain of each of them becomes attuned,

  • so that the joyful emergence of this earliest of play scenes

  • and the physiology of that is something we're beginning to get a handle on.

  • And I'd like you to think that every bit of more complex play

  • builds on this base for us humans.

  • And so now I'm going to take you through sort of a way of looking at play,

  • but it's never just singularly one thing.

  • We're going to look at body play,

  • which is a spontaneous desire to get ourselves out of gravity.

  • This is a mountain goat.

  • If you're having a bad day, try this:

  • jump up and down, wiggle around -- you're going to feel better.

  • And you may feel like this character,

  • who is also just doing it for its own sake.

  • It doesn't have a particular purpose, and that's what's great about play.

  • If its purpose is more important

  • than the act of doing it, it's probably not play.

  • And there's a whole other type of play, which is object play.

  • And this Japanese macaque has made a snowball,

  • and he or she's going to roll down a hill.

  • And -- they don't throw it at each other, but this is a fundamental part of being playful.

  • The human hand, in manipulation of objects,

  • is the hand in search of a brain;

  • the brain is in search of a hand;

  • and play is the medium by which those two are linked in the best way.

  • JPL we heard this morning -- JPL is an incredible place.

  • They have located two consultants,

  • Frank Wilson and Nate Johnson,

  • who are -- Frank Wilson is a neurologist, Nate Johnson is a mechanic.

  • He taught mechanics in a high school in Long Beach,

  • and found that his students were no longer able to solve problems.

  • And he tried to figure out why. And he came to the conclusion, quite on his own,

  • that the students who could no longer solve problems, such as fixing cars,

  • hadn't worked with their hands.

  • Frank Wilson had written a book called "The Hand."

  • They got together -- JPL hired them.

  • Now JPL, NASA and Boeing,

  • before they will hire a research and development problem solver --

  • even if they're summa cum laude from Harvard or Cal Tech --

  • if they haven't fixed cars, haven't done stuff with their hands early in life,

  • played with their hands, they can't problem-solve as well.

  • So play is practical, and it's very important.

  • Now one of the things about play is that it is born by curiosity and exploration. (Laughter)

  • But it has to be safe exploration.

  • This happens to be OK -- he's an anatomically interested little boy

  • and that's his mom. Other situations wouldn't be quite so good.

  • But curiosity, exploration, are part of the play scene.

  • If you want to belong, you need social play.

  • And social play is part of what we're about here today,

  • and is a byproduct of the play scene.

  • Rough and tumble play.

  • These lionesses, seen from a distance, looked like they were fighting.

  • But if you look closely, they're kind of like the polar bear and husky:

  • no claws, flat fur, soft eyes,

  • open mouth with no fangs, balletic movements,

  • curvilinear movements -- all specific to play.

  • And rough-and-tumble play is a great learning medium for all of us.

  • Preschool kids, for example, should be allowed to dive, hit, whistle,

  • scream, be chaotic, and develop through that a lot of emotional regulation

  • and a lot of the other social byproducts -- cognitive, emotional and physical --

  • that come as a part of rough and tumble play.

  • Spectator play, ritual play -- we're involved in some of that.

  • Those of you who are from Boston know that this was the moment -- rare --

  • where the Red Sox won the World Series.

  • But take a look at the face and the body language of everybody

  • in this fuzzy picture, and you can get a sense that they're all at play.

  • Imaginative play.

  • I love this picture because my daughter, who's now almost 40, is in this picture,

  • but it reminds me of her storytelling and her imagination,

  • her ability to spin yarns at this age -- preschool.

  • A really important part of being a player

  • is imaginative solo play.

  • And I love this one, because it's also what we're about.

  • We all have an internal narrative that's our own inner story.

  • The unit of intelligibility of most of our brains is the story.

  • I'm telling you a story today about play.

  • Well, this bushman, I think, is talking about the fish that got away that was that long,

  • but it's a fundamental part of the play scene.

  • So what does play do for the brain?

  • Well, a lot.

  • We don't know a whole lot about what it does for the human brain,

  • because funding has not been exactly heavy for research on play.

  • I walked into the Carnegie asking for a grant.

  • They'd given me a large grant when I was an academician

  • for the study of felony drunken drivers, and I thought I had a pretty good track record,

  • and by the time I had spent half an hour talking about play,

  • it was obvious that they were not -- did not feel that play was serious.

  • I think that -- that's a few years back -- I think that wave is past,

  • and the play wave is cresting,

  • because there is some good science.

  • Nothing lights up the brain like play.

  • Three-dimensional play fires up the cerebellum,

  • puts a lot of impulses into the frontal lobe --

  • the executive portion -- helps contextual memory be developed,

  • and -- and, and, and.

  • So it's -- for me, its been an extremely nourishing scholarly adventure

  • to look at the neuroscience that's associated with play, and to bring together people

  • who in their individual disciplines hadn't really thought of it that way.

  • And that's part of what the National Institute for Play is all about.

  • And this is one of the ways you can study play --

  • is to get a 256-lead electroencephalogram.

  • I'm sorry I don't have a playful-looking subject, but it allows mobility,

  • which has limited the actual study of play.

  • And we've got a mother-infant play scenario

  • that we're hoping to complete underway at the moment.

  • The reason I put this here is also to queue up

  • my thoughts about objectifying what play does.

  • The animal world has objectified it.

  • In the animal world, if you take rats,

  • who are hardwired to play at a certain period of their juvenile years

  • and you suppress play -- they squeak, they wrestle,

  • they pin each other, that's part of their play.

  • If you stop that behavior on one group that you're experimenting with,

  • and you allow it in another group that you're experimenting with,

  • and then you present those rats

  • with a cat odor-saturated collar,

  • they're hardwired to flee and hide.

  • Pretty smart -- they don't want to get killed by a cat.

  • So what happens?

  • They both hide out.

  • The non-players never come out --

  • they die.

  • The players slowly explore the environment,

  • and begin again to test things out.

  • That says to me, at least in rats --

  • and I think they have the same neurotransmitters that we do

  • and a similar cortical architecture --

  • that play may be pretty important for our survival.

  • And, and, and -- there are a lot more animal studies that I could talk about.

  • Now, this is a consequence of play deprivation. (Laughter)

  • This took a long time --

  • I had to get Homer down and put him through the fMRI and the SPECT

  • and multiple EEGs, but as a couch potato, his brain has shrunk.

  • And we do know that in domestic animals

  • and others, when they're play deprived,

  • they don't -- and rats also -- they don't develop a brain that is normal.

  • Now, the program says that the opposite of play is not work,

  • it's depression.

  • And I think if you think about life without play --

  • no humor, no flirtation, no movies,

  • no games, no fantasy and, and, and.

  • Try and imagine a culture or a life, adult or otherwise

  • without play.

  • And the thing that's so unique about our species

  • is that we're really designed to play through our whole lifetime.

  • And we all have capacity to play signal.

  • Nobody misses that dog I took a picture of on a Carmel beach a couple of weeks ago.

  • What's going to follow from that behavior

  • is play.

  • And you can trust it.

  • The basis of human trust is established through play signals.

  • And we begin to lose those signals, culturally and otherwise, as adults.

  • That's a shame.

  • I think we've got a lot of learning to do.

  • Now, Jane Goodall has here a play face along with one of her favorite chimps.

  • So part of the signaling system of play

  • has to do with vocal, facial, body, gestural.

  • You know, you can tell -- and I think when we're getting into collective play,

  • its really important for groups to gain a sense of safety

  • through their own sharing of play signals.

  • You may not know this word,

  • but it should be your biological first name and last name.

  • Because neoteny means the retention of immature qualities into adulthood.

  • And we are, by physical anthropologists,

  • by many, many studies, the most neotenous,

  • the most youthful, the most flexible, the most plastic of all creatures.

  • And therefore, the most playful.

  • And this gives us a leg up on adaptability.

  • Now, there is a way of looking at play

  • that I also want to emphasize here,

  • which is the play history.

  • Your own personal play history is unique,

  • and often is not something we think about particularly.

  • This is a book written by a consummate player

  • by the name of Kevin Carroll.

  • Kevin Carroll came from extremely deprived circumstances:

  • alcoholic mother, absent father, inner-city Philadelphia,

  • black, had to take care of a younger brother.

  • Found that when he looked at a playground

  • out of a window into which he had been confined,

  • he felt something different.

  • And so he followed up on it.

  • And his life -- the transformation of his life

  • from deprivation and what one would expect -- potentially prison or death --

  • he become a linguist, a trainer for the 76ers and now is a motivational speaker.

  • And he gives play as a transformative force

  • over his entire life.

  • Now there's another play history that I think is a work in progress.

  • Those of you who remember Al Gore,

  • during the first term and then during his successful

  • but unelected run for the presidency,

  • may remember him as being kind of wooden and not entirely his own person,

  • at least in public.

  • And looking at his history, which is common in the press,

  • it seems to me, at least -- looking at it from a shrink's point of view --

  • that a lot of his life was programmed.

  • Summers were hard, hard work, in the heat of Tennessee summers.

  • He had the expectations of his senatorial father and Washington, D.C.

  • And although I think he certainly had the capacity for play --

  • because I do know something about that --

  • he wasn't as empowered, I think, as he now is

  • by paying attention to what is his own passion

  • and his own inner drive,

  • which I think has its basis in all of us in our play history.

  • So what I would encourage on an individual level to do,

  • is to explore backwards as far as you can go

  • to the most clear, joyful, playful image that you have,

  • whether it's with a toy, on a birthday or on a vacation.

  • And begin to build to build from the emotion of that

  • into how that connects with your life now.

  • And you'll find, you may change jobs --

  • which has happened to a number people when I've had them do this --

  • in order to be more empowered through their play.

  • Or you'll be able to enrich your life by prioritizing it

  • and paying attention to it.

  • Most of us work with groups, and I put this up because

  • the d.school, the design school at Stanford,

  • thanks to David Kelley and a lot of others

  • who have been visionary about its establishment,

  • has allowed a group of us to get together

  • and create a course called "From Play to Innovation."

  • And you'll see this course is to investigate

  • the human state of play, which is kind of like the polar bear-husky state

  • and its importance to creative thinking:

  • "to explore play behavior, its development and its biological basis;

  • to apply those principles, through design thinking,

  • to promote innovation in the corporate world;

  • and the students will work with real-world partners

  • on design projects with widespread application."

  • This is our maiden voyage in this.

  • We're about two and a half, three months into it, and it's really been fun.

  • There is our star pupil, this labrador,

  • who taught a lot of us what a state of play is,

  • and an extremely aged and decrepit professor in charge there.

  • And Brendan Boyle, Rich Crandall -- and on the far right is, I think, a person who

  • will be in cahoots with George Smoot for a Nobel Prize -- Stuart Thompson,

  • in neuroscience.

  • So we've had Brendan, who's from IDEO,

  • and the rest of us sitting aside and watching these students

  • as they put play principles into practice in the classroom.

  • And one of their projects was to

  • see what makes meetings boring,

  • and to try and do something about it.

  • So what will follow is a student-made film

  • about just that.

  • Narrator: Flow is the mental state of apparition

  • in which the person is fully immersed in what he or she is doing.

  • Characterized by a feeling of energized focus,

  • full involvement and success in the process of the activity.

  • An important key insight that we learned about meetings

  • is that people pack them in one after another,

  • disruptive to the day.

  • Attendees at meetings don't know when they'll get back to the task

  • that they left at their desk.

  • But it doesn't have to be that way.

  • (Music)

  • Some sage and repeatedly furry monks

  • at this place called the d.school

  • designed a meeting that you can literally step out of when it's over.

  • Take the meeting off, and have peace of mind that you can come back to me.

  • Because when you need it again,

  • the meeting is literally hanging in your closet.

  • The Wearable Meeting.

  • Because when you put it on, you immediately get everything you need

  • to have a fun and productive and useful meeting.

  • But when you take it off --

  • that's when the real action happens.

  • (Music)

  • (Laughter) (Applause)

  • Stuart Brown: So I would encourage you all

  • to engage

  • not in the work-play differential --

  • where you set aside time to play --

  • but where your life becomes infused

  • minute by minute, hour by hour,

  • with body,

  • object,

  • social, fantasy, transformational kinds of play.

  • And I think you'll have a better and more empowered life.

  • Thank You.

  • (Applause)

  • John Hockenberry: So it sounds to me like what you're saying is that

  • there may be some temptation on the part of people to look at your work

  • and go --

  • I think I've heard this, in my kind of pop psychological understanding of play,

  • that somehow,

  • the way animals and humans deal with play,

  • is that it's some sort of rehearsal for adult activity.

  • Your work seems to suggest that that is powerfully wrong.

  • SB: Yeah, I don't think that's accurate,

  • and I think probably because animals have taught us that.

  • If you stop a cat from playing --

  • which you can do, and we've all seen how cats bat around stuff --

  • they're just as good predators as they would be if they hadn't played.

  • And if you imagine a kid

  • pretending to be King Kong,

  • or a race car driver, or a fireman,

  • they don't all become race car drivers or firemen, you know.

  • So there's a disconnect between preparation for the future --

  • which is what most people are comfortable in thinking about play as --

  • and thinking of it as a separate biological entity.

  • And this is where my chasing animals for four, five years

  • really changed my perspective from a clinician to what I am now,

  • which is that play has a biological place,

  • just like sleep and dreams do.

  • And if you look at sleep and dreams biologically,

  • animals sleep and dream,

  • and they rehearse and they do some other things that help memory

  • and that are a very important part of sleep and dreams.

  • The next step of evolution in mammals and

  • creatures with divinely superfluous neurons

  • will be to play.

  • And the fact that the polar bear and husky or magpie and a bear

  • or you and I and our dogs can crossover and have that experience

  • sets play aside as something separate.

  • And its hugely important in learning and crafting the brain.

  • So it's not just something you do in your spare time.

  • JH: How do you keep -- and I know you're part of the scientific research community,

  • and you have to justify your existence with grants and proposals like everyone else --

  • how do you prevent --

  • and some of the data that you've produced, the good science that you're talking about you've produced, is hot to handle.

  • How do you prevent either the media's interpretation of your work

  • or the scientific community's interpretation of the implications of your work,

  • kind of like the Mozart metaphor,

  • where, "Oh, MRIs show

  • that play enhances your intelligence.

  • Well, let's round these kids up, put them in pens

  • and make them play for months at a time; they'll all be geniuses and go to Harvard."

  • How do you prevent people from taking that sort of action

  • on the data that you're developing?

  • SB: Well, I think the only way I know to do it

  • is to have accumulated the advisers that I have

  • who go from practitioners --

  • who can establish through improvisational play or clowning or whatever --

  • a state of play.

  • So people know that it's there.

  • And then you get an fMRI specialist, and you get Frank Wilson,

  • and you get other kinds of hard scientists, including neuroendocrinologists.

  • And you get them into a group together focused on play,

  • and it's pretty hard not to take it seriously.

  • Unfortunately, that hasn't been done sufficiently

  • for the National Science Foundation, National Institute of Mental Health

  • or anybody else to really look at it in this way seriously.

  • I mean you don't hear about anything that's like cancer or heart disease

  • associated with play.

  • And yet I see it as something that's just as basic for survival -- long term --

  • as learning some of the basic things about public health.

  • JH: Stuart Brown, thank you very much.

  • (Applause)

So, here we go: a flyby of play.

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it