Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • This just in:

  • "Thief robs town with world's largest chocolate bunny."

  • Wait, so are we talking about this,

  • or this?

  • That's a classic case of a misplaced modifier,

  • a common grammatical mistake

  • that can dramatically change the meaning of a sentence.

  • And lest you think this is a bit far-fetched,

  • confusing headlines like this appear all the time.

  • Modifiers are words, phrases, and clauses

  • that add information about other parts of a sentence,

  • which is usually helpful.

  • But when modifiers aren't linked clearly enough

  • to the words they're actually referring to,

  • they can create unintentional ambiguity.

  • That happens because the modifying words,

  • in this case, "with world's largest chocolate bunny,"

  • modify the wrong thing, the robber's actions instead of the town.

  • To correct this particular sentence, we simply rephrase

  • to make it clearer what the modifying phrase is talking about.

  • "Town with world's largest chocolate bunny robbed by thief."

  • Now, at least it's clear

  • that the thief wasn't armed with a giant chocolate animal.

  • Sometimes, modifying words, phrases, or clauses

  • don't appear to be modifying anything at all.

  • That's called a dangling modifier.

  • "Having robbed the bank in record time,

  • it was possible to make off with the town's chocolate rabbit as well."

  • The modifying phrase in this sentence seems unrelated to anything else,

  • and so we're clueless about

  • who the chocolate-loving criminal could possibly be.

  • Giving the modifier something to modify will solve the problem.

  • Then there's another group called the squinting modifiers

  • because they're stuck between two things and could feasibly refer to either.

  • Often, these modifiers are adverbs, like the one in this sentence:

  • "Robbers who steal chocolate bunnies rapidly attract the outrage of onlookers."

  • "Rapidly" is the modifier, here, but what's not clear

  • is whether it's referring to the speed of the chocolate thievery,

  • or how quickly it alerts the furious onlookers.

  • To clarify, we can either put the modifier closer to its intended phrase,

  • which works in some cases,

  • or we can entirely reword the sentence so that the modifier no longer squints,

  • but clearly applies to only one part.

  • "Chocolate bunny-thieving robbers rapidly attract the outrage of onlookers."

  • Justice will eventually come to the chocolate thief,

  • but in the meantime,

  • our task is to avoid verbal ambiguity

  • by making it clear which parts of the sentences modifiers belong to.

  • That way, we can at least maintain grammatical law and order.

This just in:

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it