Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • Shwmae Bethany

  • As a joking afterthought at the end of your last video

  • you asked me what came first

  • the chicken

  • or the egg?

  • and the answer is much simpler than most people think

  • and also far more complicated

  • the answer is the egg

  • the egg that would have hatched the very first chicken

  • would have been laid by a creature that was very, very similar to a chicken

  • but not quite

  • the more difficult question is what is a chicken?

  • At what point would a creature that was very much like a chicken

  • but not quite

  • tip over into being an actual chicken?

  • It wasn't until I was out of University that I had any understanding

  • of the theory of evolution

  • through reading articles and watching youtube videos

  • and while I don't claim to have an amazing amount of knowledge

  • please allow me to butcher some very basic evolution for you here

  • the distinction between what is a chicken

  • and what is almost, but not quite a chicken

  • is decided by humans

  • we like grouping things

  • this is this

  • that is that

  • these are the ways that they are similar

  • and these are the ways <garbled> different

  • we see the progress of evolution through periodic markers of change

  • the most famous image image relating to evolution is called 'The March of Progress'

  • its the one that looks like this

  • it was created by an artist called Rudolph Zallinger

  • that's not particularly important to what I have to say today

  • but 'Rudolph Zallinger' or 'The March of Progress'

  • is bound to be the answer to a trivia question one Christmas

  • and when that question is asked we'll look at each other and go

  • "aaah"

  • but we view progress as this becomes

  • <chwnk>

  • this

  • which in turn

  • <chwnk>

  • morphs into this

  • like a pokemon turning level 16

  • the metamorphosis occurs

  • this one isn't a chicken

  • this one is

  • that isn't how this works

  • in the many millions of years it takes for this version

  • to become this version

  • so many millions exist in the middle

  • this isn't mk. I -> mk. II

  • in reality there were innumerable different forms between the two

  • it was less a progress of incremental forms and more like

  • a Hollywood-LSD mesh of 'bleeeeurgh'

  • morphing onwards through millions and millions of years

  • and that's fun

  • bleeeeeurgh

  • so why do we decide that this one is not a chicken

  • and that this one is

  • I don't know the details

  • I'm not a scientist

  • and anyway

  • neither of them are chickens

  • they're my hands

  • <buk buk buk buk>

  • I'm just a bit disappointed that I didn't get more of an evolutionary

  • education at school

  • although to be fair a lot of that responsibility may lay with my class

  • it might be our fault

  • one time we were in a biology classroom

  • and we were meant to be learning about osmosis

  • now to do this we had potatoes and we were meant to be

  • taking samples from them to see how water passed through them

  • and instead of doing this

  • we threw them across the room at each other

  • we were the top set of triple science

  • we were 28 years old

  • and we were also the teachers

  • and the potato was my mother-in-law

  • Anyway now you know that the egg came first

  • maybe that's why the chicken crossed the road

  • Ffarwel!

  • <buk buk buk buk>

Shwmae Bethany

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it

A2 UK

雞和蛋哪個先來?(基礎進化論) (Which came first the chicken or the egg? (Basic Evolution))

  • 132 8
    毛毛 posted on 2021/01/14
Video vocabulary