Subtitles section Play video
Hello, my name is Julie Novak,
and I'm thrilled to be speaking with you today
about my topic, which is utilizing music therapy
to teach language skills for students, who are Deaf
or hard of hearing. I'd like to start with telling you
a little bit about myself. I was previously
the music therapist and music educator at the Colorado
School for the Deaf and the Blind. I worked for 10 years
with the School for the Deaf preschool through eighth
grade programs. I currently work for the Center for
Hearing and Communication in Broward County, Florida,
and now my focus is high school students.
I would like to briefly share with you
what music therapy is. Music therapy is a field
that requires a degree. It requires a Board Certification
and an internship. I like to define music therapy
as "the use of music for non-musical goals."
You can find music therapists in many types of settings.
You can find them in clinical settings, in hospitals,
in hospice services. You can also find them
in educational settings. A lot of times school districts
hire music therapists in special education settings.
Research has indicated that music can aid
in memory/attention. It provides motivation and
reinforcement, and helps establish
a positive learning environment.
Oftentimes, when I talk about Deafness and music,
I sometimes get a quizzical response.
One could hypothesize, that students who are Deaf or
hard of hearing: Why would they be good at music and
why would they enjoy music? I always, when I get that
kind of response, I like to highlight Gardner's Theory
of Multiple Intelligences, which states that all
of our brains are wired certain ways, in different ways,
and all of us have gifts.
My theory and Gardner's theory is that, just because
someone's hearing mechanism doesn't work like
the typical hearing population, it doesn't mean
that their brain is still not wired and gifted for music.
In my studies and in my experience at the School for the
Deaf and the Blind, I have known profoundly Deaf
individuals, who are rooted in the Deaf community,
but still enjoy any type of feedback they get from music.
They have speaker systems at their house,
they use earbuds, and even though what they're
experiencing is vibrational, they still get reinforced and
motivated by the rhythms of the vibrational feedback.
May I add, just like the hearing population there are
some hearing people, who don't enjoy music.
Music is not their thing, they don't enroll in any classes
in music. They are just not connected to music.
I think similarly to the Deaf community, there are some
Deaf members, who don't identify with music at all.
Research has indicated strengths and preferences
for children, who are Deaf or hard of hearing.
Let me give you a few seconds to read these bullets.
It states that music should be appropriately
amplified. It is important for a teacher or parent to
realize, that for a student who is Deaf or hard of hearing,
a Fisher Price boombox is not going to do justice
to the music that they are going to hear.
You want to make sure the sound equipment
is legit, and that it's high quality.
Children, who are Deaf or hard of hearing, require more
exposure, which makes sense, because maybe their
musical experiences aren't as vast as someone,
who had a lot of experiences previously.
Rhythmic tendencies tend to be stronger than
pitch-related abilities. It's really interesting
in a lot of the research, the students, who are Deaf or
hard of hearing, do just as well as the hearing subjects,
when it comes to rhythmic testing.
So rhythmic tends to be very salient
for the Deaf population.
Finally, sustaining instruments give more
aural feedback, are more reinforcing than percussive
instruments. This is an interesting finding, because
a lot of times in the Deaf community, you'll see big bass
drums at football games and at pep rallies.
While that instrument is very reinforcing for the Deaf
community, the research found that low-frequency
instruments like a trombone, that sustains a low pitch,
tends to be more be reinforcing
and gives more feedback. Another example is
a bass guitar, when you strum the string
or when you pluck the string,
the sound going through the amplifier is reinforcing.
It's important here that I mention, that preference is
very important. As you know in the Deaf or
hard of hearing population, that lot of times
the hearing varies. There's high frequency loss,
low frequency loss. So it is important to match
preferences with the hearing loss. For example,
the soprano recorder, which is a small high-pitched
instrument, a lot my Deaf students didn't like that
instrument, because it wasn't low pitched.
They would actually detested that instrument.
But occasionally, I have one or two students,
who would just fall love with the soprano recorder.
So you really do you have to pay attention
to preferences.
I'll give you a second to read the slide.
Is music a part Deaf culture?
I think, if I would ask a member of the Deaf community,
they would probably say, "No," that it is not part of
Deaf culture, and that it is more part of hearing culture.
I have in working with the Deaf community,
I have found big examples of ways that music
is utilized in the Deaf culture. If you remember,
for example, the creation, performance, significance,
and even the definition of music varies according
to culture and social context. Music in America
is very different than, let's say, music in tribal Africa.
I would like to make the same comparison that music
in mainstream hearing culture, might be different
than music that's found and created
by the Deaf community. One example, I love to use is
the Gallaudet Fight Song. The song has strong rhythmic
examples inside of it. It has a calm response
type of feel, and it is used by the Deaf
and passed from generation to generation,
much like a folk song is passed down
from generation to generation in the hearing culture.
Another example of music in the Deaf culture
is D-PAN, Deaf Performing Arts Network, d-pan.com
is a website, where Deaf people can perform.
There's a performer there named Sean Forbes,
who actually creates raps and
incorporates ASL sign into his raps.
My last example of music in Deaf culture is Rathskellar,
which is a Deaf performing arts group that travels
around United States performing rhythmic chants,
performing dance, and performing all kinds
of instruments or actually it's more
geared towards movement in sign.
I'll give you second to read this slide.
For my graduate studies, I looked at the use of music
to teach vocabulary. I chose 24 target words, and
I really focused on children age three and four years old.
I had a hearing sample and a group of students
who were Deaf or hard of hearing.
I targeted words in six different categories to teach
them. I made sure before I started the testing
that they were unaware of the vocabulary,
that I was introducing.
In this project, I had four conditions or four situations
that I taught in. One was, I paired music with visual
aids and sign language. So I used song to teach
vocabulary. In my second condition, I used rhythmic
chant paired with visual aids and sign language.
My third condition, I just used conversation paired
with visual aids and sign language. Finally, my fourth
condition was a control condition,
which I didn't teach words at all in the session.
I found that the preschoolers, who are Deaf or
hard of hearing made the most gains in the rhythmic
condition, that the rhythmic chant helped aid teach
vocabulary most out of the melodic conversation
and the control group.
I will give you a second to read the slide.
This finding corroborates with previous research
that states, "Rhythm is very salient for people
with hearing loss," and the results could implicate
that rhythmic chant could be used in preschool
classrooms. In music classrooms, it may be beneficial
to use rhythmic chant to teach vocabulary.
In this next clip that I'm going to show.
It's an example of how I use rhythmic chant to teach
vocabulary. This is a chant that actually teaches
opposites. I'm going to show the clip for you now.
"To my rap, tell me the opposite, when I snap.
Listen, I say, 'Yes,' you say, 'No.'
I say, 'Fast,' you say, 'Slow.'
I say, 'Hot,' you say, 'Cold.'
I say, 'Young,' you say, 'Old.'
I say, 'Wet,' you say, 'Dry.'
I say, 'Hello,' you say, 'Bye-bye.' "
"Good job!"
"Who wants a turn? Dionte!"
"Listen, listen to my rap,
tell me the opposite, when I snap.
I say, 'Yes,' you say, 'No,' 'No.'
I say, 'Fast,' you say, 'Cold,' 'Slow.'
I say, 'Hot,' you say, 'Cold.'
I say, 'Young,' you say, 'Old.'
I say, 'Wet,' you say, 'Dry.'
I say, 'Hello,' you say, 'Bye-bye.'
Bye, Dionte."
"Yeah! Good job!"
Music is connected to language and may be
a reinforcing way to teach and reinforce standards.
For example, a common kindergarten English standard
is: Remember key details from a story.
A lot of times songs are stories, and we call them
story songs. A lot of times folk songs embed stories
in them. Parents and teachers can help students,
who are Deaf or hard of hearing, with temporal language
by asking them, "What happens at the beginning
of this song, what happens in the middle,
and what happens at the end?" A lot of songs have
a sequence, and the music is a great memory aid.
Plus, it gives students an opportunity to act out songs,
so that they can not only have an auditory aid
with the music, but a kinesthetic aid with acting it out.
An example, that I like to use in my kindergarten
classes is a song called "Grizzly Bear."
I'm going to sing it for you right now.
"A grizzly bear, a grizzly bear is sleeping in a cave.
Please be very quiet, very, very quiet.
If you wake him, if you shake him, he gets very mad."
In a kindergarten setting, after I taught the song
to the students, I would ask questions like,
"Who is in the cave? What is the bear doing?
When does the bear get mad? Where is the bear?
Why should you not shake the bear or wake him?"
These are great examples tied to that kindergarten
standard, and it's a lot of fun for the students.
Song books are another avenue, where music is tied
to literacy. A lot of the story songs, that I talk to you
about have been made into beautiful books with visual
aids, and the song serves as an auditory aid,
memory cue for the students, who are reading the book.
So just a reminder about story songs that are illustrated.
Moving on to an older grade, fourth grade English
standard, and a common standard is: Identify and
use common types of figures of speech.
I'll give you a second to read the slide.
Research has indicated that students, who are Deaf or
hard of hearing have less use of imaginative language,
have difficulty understanding figurative or symbolic
language, and because of this are delayed
in other subjects. Well, music and song lyrics are rich
in figurative language. Every popular song imaginable
has some sort of figurative language
incorporated into it.
Music has similes, metaphors. Tons of songs
use idioms and all different kinds imagery.
Sometimes, songs are good examples for language.
Other times, there're songs with lyrics that are
not good examples of the English language.
Again, that is a good non-example to point out
to students of what kind of language use is
inappropriate here, or what kind of language
use is appropriate. So figurative language
in popular music is a wonderful way to analyze
figurative language.
I'll give you a second to read the slide.
In this slide, I give you ideas to utilize
when listening to music with students. For example,
music can be used to identify parts of speech
used in the song. Find all the adjectives in the song
lyrics. Find all the verbs. You could also identify
synonyms that could be substituted for specific words.
This is a great way to expand vocabulary, picking out
certain words in songs and asking students
to substitute a word that has a similar meaning.
You can ask them to substitute words within
the same class, different adjectives, nouns, adverbs.
You can ask them to identify errors
in a word class use within the song.
Writing songs with specific directives that target
language composition objectives.
Finally, just by describing the music can help students
expand their language, when talking about music
and poetry, because lyrics to songs are really poetry.
Here, I'd like to give you some examples
of popular music or popular songs that use figurative
language. For example, Katy Perry's "Firework".
She states, "Do you ever feel like a plastic bag
drifting through the wind, wanting to start again?"
"Do you ever feel so paper-thin, like a house of cards,
one blow from caving in?"
Here you can talk to the students, "What is the meaning
that she's trying to convey here?"
Obviously, she's saying, "Do you feel sometimes
that you don't matter, that you're not important?"
Let's look at some the similies she uses.
Let's look at some of the metaphors.
"Like a house of cards" would be
a great example of a simile.
So after the verse feels very hopeless,
she then brings us the chorus of Firework,
which she uses a simili. "Just open up
like the Fourth of July." Then the main chorus
is the metaphor, "Baby you're a firework."
It would be interesting to talk with students,
"What do you think she means by you're a firework?"
and "What does that describe?"
Discussion can be opened up from there,
because song lyrics are really poetry.
Another popular song, that I chose for an example is
Ferge's "Big Girls Don't Cry".
She uses figurative language like
"We've got some straightening out to do."
It'd be an interesting conversation.
What does "straightening out" mean?
How would you sign that ASL?
"I'm going to miss you like a child misses their blanket."
What is that concept trying to convey?
"But I've got to move on with my life."
Does she literally mean I've got to move
into a different house or that I need to proceed
forward in my life?
So these are examples of figurative language
used in popular songs.
I just took the beginning of Adele's, "Rollin in the Deep".
She starts with the lyric, "There's a fire
burning in my heart..." Of course, you'd have
to rely on context to know whether it's a passionate,
loving fire or one that is full of misery and festering.
This would be a nice phrase to think about ASL versus
English. In English, this is how we would say it.
Is there an ASL idiom that closely matches
with this English phrase or this poetry?
Online now, it's a pretty amazing, all of the different
postings of people and their interpretations of songs
into ASL. With every popular song, there's about
200 translations of people's imaginative gloss.
Some of them are really bad, and some of them
are ingenious. Someone, that I'd like to point out,
whom I think is a genius, is Kelly Greer,
K-E-L-L-Y G-R-E-E-R. She does a beautiful interpretation
of "Rolling in the Deep". So this would be a good
example to kind of compare language,
the two languages English and ASL.
Here's the English on the board, here is the ASL
interpretation by Kelly Greer. Let's compare the two.
This brings us into talking about the Bilingual-Bicultural
model. By analyzing English lyrics, it's a great way
to discriminate between the two languages.
It gives the students a real visual cue of here's English,
here's ASL. Here's "Rolling in the Deep" by Adele,
here's Kelly Greer's ASL interpretation.
It has students compare language models.
I again state, "Pick one popular song.
Evaluate performers of this song in ASL.
Who did the best job in performing the song
by reflecting ASL structures and rules?"
Here you can have middle school or high school
students discriminating good language models.
Who justifies ASL and expresses it in a beautiful,
conceptual manner, and
where is ASL badly represented?
What is not American Sign Language?
So it would be a good practice for students
to figure out what is a good language model.
In my middle school classes, I would assign
a song project. In following the Bilingual-Bicultural
Model, I would have students analyze song lyrics
and create a gloss for the ASL.
Another good practice is to take a song
that is mostly performed in ASL, for example,
the Gallaudet Fight Song or the CSDB Fight Song,
that the Colorado School for the Deaf and the Blind
uses and figure out ways to translate ASL to English.
It's quite challenging and a great exercise
for discriminating between the two language models.
Over the years with the song project, I had
many students perform some brilliant pieces,
where they were able to gloss the ASL independently
and perform it artistically.
I'm going to show you an example of a student,
who performs a song that he glossed and
performs it with great artistry.
(instrumental music)
Well you can tell by the way I use my walk
I'm a woman's man, no time to talk
Music loud and women warm
I've been kicked around since I was born
And now it's all right, it's okay
And you may look the other way
But we can try to understand
'The New York Times' effect on man
Whether you're a brother or whether you're a mother
You're stayin' alive, stayin' alive
Feel the city breakin' and everybody shakin'
And we're stayin' alive, stayin' alive
Ahh haa haa haa stayin' alive, stayin' alive
Ahh haa haa haa stayin' alive
Ohh get it more
(instrumental music)
Well now I get low and I get high
And if I can't get either I really try
Got the wings of Heaven on my shoes
I'm a dancin' man and I just can't lose
And now it's all right, it's okay
I'll live to see another day
But we can try to understand
'The New York Times' effect on man
Whether you're a brother or whether you're a mother
You're stayin' alive, stayin' alive
Feel the city breakin' and everybody shakin'
And we're stayin' alive, stayin' alive
Ahh haa haa haa stayin' alive, stayin' alive
Ahh haa haa haa stayin' alive
(instrumental music)
Another project, that I'd like to share with you,
is in the elementary school. We talked about
the Star Spangled Banner, which has very difficult
vocabulary even for adults to analyze.
So we took the English, we analyzed what the meaning
was, and then we created an ASL gloss
to the Star Spangled Banner.
Victoria does a beautiful job of expressing the gloss
in a very musical, artistic way.
I'd like to share that with you now.
O say can you see, by the dawn's early light,
What so proudly we hailed
at the twilight's last gleaming?
I'm going to give you a few seconds
to review the last slide.
In conclusion, I would like to emphasize
the following points:
Music is highly reinforcing and can be reinforcing
for students, who are Deaf or hard of hearing,
it should be utilized to teach non-musical goals,
when working with Deaf or hard of hearing populations,
it is important to remember that preference matters,
so if the student is reinforced by a certain kind of music
or a certain instrument, it is important
for educators and parents to support that preference.
Another important point is that rhythm is important
to the Deaf population. Rhythm is very salient.
A lot of studies done with Cochlear Implants also
state that rhythmic is the most salient characteristic
of music for those with Cochlear Implants.
It is important to focus on rhythm.
Music often requires the use of language
and teaching children, who are Deaf to talk or write
about music gives them a non-threatening, enjoyable
opportunity to practice language skills.
Finally, discussions about meanings in music can also
be structured to increase vocabulary
and word class usage skills.
I hope that you gained some knowledge
from my presentation today.
If you have any questions or comments
about the presentation, feel free to contact me
at my email, which is julienovak_77@yahoo.com.
I look forward to reading your feedback. Thank you.