Subtitles section Play video Print subtitles [SOUND] Stanford University. >> So I fit the stereotype, I'm Italian, I write operas, I attend operas. So I'm the perfect stereotype to give this lecture today. Though what you're going to hear, so if you're expecting me to talk about opera, you name it, you will be a little bit disappointed. I wanna give you a different angle to what opera is. In fact, the title of this speech is Why the Opera Changed the Course of Music? So let's focus on that. So the opera is not just these things that we enjoyed, sorry, I see so many friends, and to people that have been in my classes and I've been teaching so it's great to see them. I would like to take this approach. This is like a composition class. You are composers. You're very good composers. You know everything about music theory. You're an expert musician. You study music. So, we're gonna have a conversation among colleagues. And I'm gonna try to make in a way, that what I say, it's understood by everyone, okay? So, I'm going to go into the details of music, into the, if you like, the grammar of music, and see how music works and how and why music changed because of the opera. What we listen today, most of the music that we're listening to today is the way it is because someone in the past thought, well we should write music in this way because it's gonna serve this purpose. The purpose of the opera. That's what we're gonna talk about. And then at the end, I was going to play some music, but Sonya here, who's sitting right here in front, she approached me. She is a singer, she is an alum, contacted me and said, why instead of playing music, we don't get to perform it live? Sonya and I will be performing a couple of areas from the standard repertoire of the opera. Okay? So the first concept we need to understand that music is a language, all right? Nothing else but a language. So, like a language, there are rules that in the course of history that been changed. Music is a language that develops through time. It moves through times. This is a concept that it needs to be clear since the beginning. If we go back into the ancient Greeks, they divided the arts into two categories. The categories of the arts that moved that develop into space, like architecture, paintings, and sculpture. So a sculpture needs space. It's this big, all right, or it's this big. A building needs space. And then they would categorize arts that would develop in time. Meaning, music needs time. Music is not a meter tall. Music, it's five minutes long. Music develops through time. Music has motions, and I will demonstrate that, what I mean with that. Same we can say with words, with poetry. And also the same has to do with dancing. So all these arts, they move through time. What do I mean? Let's say, if I say, yesterday, at 7:30. What? All right, so I create that motion. I create something that needs, in time, needs to move ahead. Yesterday at 7:30 something, we need something. In music it happens exactly the same. if I play, let's say this. [MUSIC] Can I stop there? No. [LAUGH] No. [MUSIC] If I stop there everyone will be disappointed. All right. So we need. [MUSIC] [NOISE] It has to resolve. We say, this music is like, yesterday at 7:30, something. That chord, it creates some tensions, and that tension needs to be released into something else. That's what I mean when I say music moves through time. Music is nothing but tensions that is created by melodies, it's created by rhythm, it's created by chord progressions, and when you have tensions it moves the music forward. And why? What happened? Why? What happens inside the music world, into the grammar of music that makes that motions? Music, yet again, is about motion. What happens? Let's say there's two way to see music. If I play something like this. [MUSIC] So what we hear is mostly block of sounds, right? I hear the sound, and this block of sound. In music, we call them chords. So this is in music, the chord progression is what makes the music move forward. But if I play something, let's say, something like this. [MUSIC] You know, this is different, right? How it's different? It's not a block of sound and another block of sound. It's more a melody interacting with another melody. Here I have one melody here. [MUSIC] And then I added one more. [MUSIC] And then and I added one more. [MUSIC] Now I have four. [MUSIC] And so forth. So basically what's happening in this second piece that I'm playing, I have this melody here and there's another melody and there is another one and then it's another one. So what happens the music develops, creates that motion because there is the interaction of all these different melodies. So, in some historical periods that's what governed the music, it was the interaction of melody and composers were very concerned. I'd say this melody goes up and then goes down and the other one how does it interact? It follows the same pattern, they move or we say, in parallel motions, or they might say, this is moving, this one is not. Or they're going in opposite direction. >> And do you say, what do I care about that? >> Okay. >> Well, actually that was something very important. This is what we call in music, if somebody, if there were some musicians here. We call it counterpoint. How the musical lines are interacting. So the counterpoint is not a disease. >> [LAUGH] >> We'll say, what'd you have? I have a little bit of counterpoint, I don't feel good. The counterpoint is something that studies how two different musical lines are interacting. And basically, what it says, if this is moving up and that one is moving down, what happens? Well, this is what happens. If this is moving and the other one stays in the same notes, what happen? Well, this is what happens. In composition for at the conservatory, we study counterpoints for years. It's something actually very complicated. So how is the interactions? So, and I'll take questions at the end. So how are these things interacting? What makes it the music to move forward, to go to the next level, to have that beautiful sense of motion that we all enjoy while we listen to music? It's two things. This block of sound or the interactions of melodies. So let's have this example. If I say, I have one melody. So this melody goes like that. [SOUND] Beautiful. Then this is gonna be my melody, I'm gonna write another one here. So this is my second melody. [SOUND] If I put them together, this is what happens. [SOUND] We're gonna add one more, because we're good composers, we can handle at least three. >> [LAUGH] >> So I'm gonna write it here, I'm gonna do something like this. Now we have three lines, one, two and three. So the last one, it goes like this. [SOUND] So three melodies. If I play them all together, you'll see they generate. [MUSIC] So the first one was. [MUSIC] The second. [MUSIC] And the last one. [MUSIC] Now this three melodies, if I look at them say, how is this melody moving? It goes up and then it kinda jumps up. This is moving more like that. This is definitely jumps down and then it moves down. So composers were very concerned on how these things were interacting, but there is one other way to look at it. Let's say, so now, we're looking in that direction. So now, we're gonna see what happens here in a more vertical sense. We'll say, what happened? This is a block of sound. The block of sound is this one [SOUND] and that is a music we call a chord. So if you know something about music, you would call this is a C major. So here's a C major chord or you can call it, it's a block of sound. It's a combination of three sounds. Now, what happens here? There is another chord. We call it that half major. And what happens here? We go back to the initial chord slightly different. We're not gonna go into the details of that chord being in first inversion. First inversion, we don't have to talk about that. So now I see, we have three blocks of sound or three melodies, which is? Which is the one? What's the most important? So you're the composer, where would you start? By saying, I have three chords and these three chords are generating three melodies or you can say, no, no, no, no. I had three melodies that have generated three different chords. >> [LAUGH] >> The chords. So some music is generated by chord progressions, others are generated by this interaction of melodies. And sometimes, it's a combination of both. And that interaction of how chord they progress and the motion of the melodies, one going up and other going down. All of that, it creates these motions that we're looking for. Let's say in the 15th century, composers. Oh, it's clear that lets say, if I'm adding one more melody to three to make it four, thing they get more complicated. Every time we're adding something, the problems are solving it becomes like solving a problem. The problems of interacting this melody, they multiply. So if I have four voices, a counterpoint with two voices is relatively simple. Three, gets complicated. Four, it's hard. More than that, things get very hard. In the 15th century, composers were so good and making these lines to interact. That they were capable of writing songs that had 4 voices, 8 voices, 16 voices, 30 voices. We are example of polyphony. That polyphony means more than 1 line of 40, 42 different lines interacting. Imagine what probably today would need a very good advance computer to make sure this line are interacting in a way that creates motion and at the same time is sort of follow the rules of counterpoint. So one thing that is very important to remember and I'll get to the opera, eventually. I warned you before. One thing that it's important to understand is that all these lines of the music, working together, they were all equal. It's not like the top line is more important. It's not like the middle line is less important or the bottom line is more or less important. Have you ever sung in a choir? Raise your hand. Oh, most of you. Good. So you know that I'm a soprano, I get the good line. [LAUGH] >> I'm an alto. Oh, alto lines are so boring and reflects on the people. >> [LAUGH] >> They are boring, as well in their life. They become boring, because they see these boring lines. Well, if you were an alto, let's say in the renaissance, in the 15th century or 16th century that was not true. All the lines were good. All the lines were interesting. All the lines were one word that is crucial, equal. It's not like the soprano was more important. All the lines were equal. The equality of these lines involves the interaction of this counterpoint. Again, that what makes the music to develop the way we know it The fact that all these lines were interacting though created especially when you put 8, 16, 20, you name it. It created a big problem. Let's not forget that most of the music back then was vocal. Vocal music. It's not like the instrumental music didn't exist, but most of the music that they were composing was vocal music. And vocal music, there is a text involved in the vocal music. As you know, when we sing, we go to the opera, right? And then, it's hard to understand what they're saying. Even if they sing in English. If they sing in German and Italian, forget it. You need those super. It's hard to understand with just one vocal line. Imagine, a choir singing, all these line interacting together. That was a problem, so the text kind of was second, it was not so important. They were so into the music. Well that was a problem for the church. Church is certain place that. Look, you're coming here. You're singing all these beautiful songs. But we don't understand a damn thing you're saying. All right? That's not good. So somehow. In the following century, the 16th century, now in the Renaissance, the church said, no more of that. Music needs to go back, needs to have a step back. We need to have some kind of polyphony that it's a little bit clearer. It's somehow simpler. The text needs to be understood. The Catholic church had the Council of Trent. Do you know what the Council of Trent is? Is when all these bishops, all these cardinals they get together and discuss about things. That was for the first time, from all over the world, they gather in Rome to talk about things. By the way, number 2 was about 500 years later. So when they get together, if they get together once every 500 years, it must be important, right? The second one was in 1963 or 64. It lasted for a few years. In this Council of Trent, they discuss a lot of things among that music. And one of the problem was look you really, we composer you really need to go back to some kind of music that is a little bit more clearer. It cannot be complicated. The interaction of all these lines it needs to go back to some kind of purity. It needs to go back into a way that is easier to understand. At the same time, that problem came up in Florence among a group of philosopher, a group of poets. A group of musicians, a group of artists. They will get together and talk about music, talk about art, and talk about you name it. That was called [FOREIGN] so it was a group of people. They will gather and will talk about things, mostly art. And also, they had that problem. Also for them, the fact that the text wasn't understood was a problem in the music. They wanted to go back to some kind of music that had again some purity. All these line interacting, no more. Plus they had in mind, they wanted to go back to the Greek tragedy. So they were interested into the classics. They were interested again. They wanted to rediscover that purity of the drama in the theater. But not only that, they were interested on the fact that these show now. The show of the drama, of the tragedy, of the Greek tragedy needed to have some kind of music. Say, why don't we insert some music? So this drama, we want some music not just spoken words, and in order to do that, the drama, the tests, it needs to be understood. So, that polyphony, all these line movings, interacting. It was not good enough. They needed to have maybe one line that was, I don't like to use this word, simple but clear, okay. Music that is simple it doesn't mean that it's bad, by the way. Things that are simple, they are not necessarily bad. So, they wanted o go back into some kind of music that was simpler and melodically that it was easy to understand, easy to follow. But the most important things. Not all the lines. Not all the lines underneath. They needed to be equal. So, this top line, that top line needed to be more important. The top line needed to be the melody and everything else underneath. Needed to be what today we call the accompaniment. Okay. So that interaction of light, no more. Polyphony, counterpoint, the way it was intended for a century, didn't work anymore. They really had this idea, they were changing the way composers needed to think about music. We needed to have a drama with a melody. We needed to have a melodrama. That's when the opera was born. The opera was born with the intent, also, to change the way music was composed. No more of these. [MUSIC] And maybe we have a melody. [MUSIC] So you go home and this is what you're going to sing. [MUSIC] Do not go home and sing this. >> [LAUGH] >> Right, so that means that these two elements in music, they're not equal. The top line is more important. It seems like a dumb thing because today after that, the first opera was written in the year 1600. So about 400 years, 400 and something years has gone by, it seems easy for us to go, oh sure. Well that's how music it is. Because all the songs that you hear, you probably go home and you listen to the tonality. You go to the opera and you sing soprana. You're not going to go home and sing the second bassoon part, do you? With all the respect for the second bassoon. >> [LAUGH] >> All right, so these music lines, they're not equal, they're not meant to be equal. They're all necessary, that you all need that. But, there is something that carries more weight. And that idea, the melody and that idea that music needs to be written with a top melody and some accompaniment. Is because, this composer that wanted to, they invented a new show. And this new show was called the opera. As simple as that. Where'd that happen? Well, that happened in Florence, all right? So, the first opera was written in Florence in the year 1600. It was called [FOREIGN] the music was by composer [FOREIGN] In the [FOREIGN]. It was preformed in Florence exactly in the year of 1600. And if you listen to this opera, the early opera, really what you hear is this pure melody. As far as they're concerned, they're almost as pure as the Gregorian chant. If you know anything about the Gregorian chant, the top things about the Gregorian chant was that these melody, they were so pure, okay? So pure in fact they didn't need any accompaniment. They were monophonic. So Ulma, they could've gone back to that, but that music by then, it couldn't be monophonic anymore. All right? So this melody needed to be as pure almost as that with a little bit of accompaniment underneath, and that's how the first operas were. All of this there were a few instruments accompanying this gorgeous yet very simple melody of the early opera. That idea that the text needed to be understood, it didn't last very long. >> [LAUGH] >> Because that idea of having this pure melody, it lasted very little. Have you ever heard some opera written in the baroque time? So we don't think of the baroque era as a time for operas, right? Well, Vivaldi wrote about 46 operas. Have you ever heard any of them? I'm going to lower my voice because they are not very good. >> [LAUGH] >> And what happens in the Baroque time, the music became almost a show off for the singers. These musical lines as we talk, they needed to be so pure, so nice, so understandable. That disappeared right away. It was a show off, they were so virtuoso like so it will show off for the singers. And the text, they could have sung anything, it didn't matter. What was important was the fact that they could do all these great coloratura you name it, all this great virtuoso singing that we hear in those kind of operas. In the 19th century, things got back a little bit to normal. Composers like [FOREIGN], Verdi, certainly Puccini, [FOREIGN]. So things were a little bit in between, the text, the drama, gained back some importance. Puccini was very concerned to make sure that his musical lines were understood by the audience. They were very concerned about that. What's the opera? The opera basically is the conflict of love, passion, hate, and sex and blood, all right? The common character of the opera is the woman in love, is the man that is in love, there is the tyrant, there is the father. It's that. The libretto, I wouldn't say a if I say who wrote La Boheme? Oh everybody knows, oh I know that. Who wrote the libretto? I'm sure that everybody knows here who wrote La Boheme. But the Libretto, if we do a survey probably, who wrote? Verdi, who write? I don't know. Anyone? >> No. I'll leave it to you for you to research. Okay? >> [LAUGH] >> See? That's a sign. That's a sign that the music always carried a little bit more importance. And that was not the intent of this first composer. That was not the intent of La Camerata DiVardi. Okay? So, I'm going to move on to the next phase of this lecture and I'm going to have some help here from Sonia. We're going to sing two beautiful arias from two different operas. And that is the demonstrations, those are typical example of how music is constructed by these top melodies, these memorable melodies, that will be remembered forever. And that you go to the opera, you enjoy because the composer knew how to write them, they knew how to get your attention. So composer like Verdi, composer like Puccini, they were so good at writing these melody with that accompaniment underneath. They took,again, that tradition from the beginning of the opera. They were so good. Puccini could manipulate. He was a man that breeded it inside the theatre. He was a man that could manipulate everyone. The singers, he could manipulate the orchestra, the audience, everyone. He was in charge, he knew exactly how to do it. He knew how to write this melody with that accompaniment that you go and enjoy and you go home and you sing them for the rest of the week once you go to those operas. No composer were able to do that. Composers such Verdi, Puccini, of course Don Ozzetti, Rossini mostly those Italian composers. The Germans were more into the block of sounds, all right? You go, I'm gonna lower my voice again, just in case somebody hears that, you go to these German operas. You sit there for two or three hours, you kinda got tired. You go home, and you don't remember a damn thing. >> [LAUGH] >> In Italian operas, you get your money's worth in. >> [LAUGH] >> You go to this opera, you listen to this melody, they're repeated, they're beautiful, they stick in your mind, you go home and you take them with you. It's this melodies, this idea of that line, that beautiful line that is on top. Most of the music that we hear today is like that. I heard a saying, in the 20 and 21st century, composers, they tried other systems. Today things are getting a little bit out of hand with modern music. So we do some crazy things, the electronic music, so this idea of melody and accompaniment, it's been challenged, I say, by modern composer. Modern music today does a lot of crazy things. If you are here, we have, even at Stanford, we're very avant garde for as far as composition. I don't think none of my colleagues will say, oh, what did you write today? Oh, I wrote a beautiful melody with the accompaniment underneath. Probably no one does that anymore. Especially we have this computer center of CCRMA, we call it, C-C-R-M-A, Computer Center Research Music and Acoustics, where the idea of composition is taken to the next level. For good or for bad, it's not up to me to say. History will tell. All right, let's move to the next level. And I have Sonya that she will say a few words on the, The higher that we are going to sing. >> The first piece is O Mio Babbino Caro from Gianni Schicchi by Puccini. In a nutshell, Lauretta is pleading with her father Gianni Schicchi that she wants to marry Rinuccio, I believe, who's supposed to inherit a lot of money. But that point is not certain. But it's a plea. The second aria is from La Boheme, Musetta's Waltz as it's more commonly known or [FOREIGN]. And Musetta has arrived back in town and she wants to rekindle her love affair with Marcello who at first resists but then capitulates. So, >> We always capitulate don't we? >> [LAUGH] >> [INAUDIBLE]? >> Sorry? >> He asked why do we? >> I don't know, I don't know. >> [LAUGH] >> Okay. O Mio Babbino Caro, this is a famous Aria. I'm sure most of you have heard it before. It's from [FOREIGN]. [MUSIC] >> [FOREIGN] >> [APPLAUSE] >> [MUSIC] >> [FOREIGN] >> [APPLAUSE] >> For more, please visit us at stanford.edu.
B1 music melody opera interacting chord composer Giancarlo Aquilanti, “Why the Opera Changed the Course of Music” 59 6 songwen8778 posted on 2016/07/31 More Share Save Report Video vocabulary