Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • It's easy to grow up with a sense that our feelings are reliable guides

  • to ourselves, the people around us, and the world at large.

  • We can call this optimistic thesis the 'clear pane' theory of the mind,

  • iImplying that we are able to look out onto the world

  • pretty much as if through an undistorted, and blemish-free pane of glass.

  • Yet a long tradition in philosophy has sought to warn us of a far trickier truth.

  • The school of thought, known as skepticism, that began in Ancient Greece in the third century B.C.

  • proposed that a great many of our solid-seeming sensory first impressions

  • should not be assumed to be accurate

  • and must instead be submitted to the laborious process of rational unscrambling.

  • Far from our minds being clear panes, they're full of scratches, blind spots and warps.

  • To be wise, therefore, means for the skeptics to strive to be permanently vigilant

  • no matter how much we're inclined to misunderstand reality

  • by trusting our first feelings.

  • One tiny instance of our distorting minds that particularly fascinated the Greeks

  • was a strange phenomenon that occurs when a stick is partially submerged in water.

  • It immediately seems as if the stick angles into a "V" just at the point where it meets the surface.

  • But, if we pull the stick out, we'll see that it's of course, still straight.

  • The skeptics took this tiny example as a gateway to a vast truth:

  • that our senses are humbling fallible.

  • The way things appear to us is often simply not how they, in fact, really are.

  • Skeptical ideas were to be the leading force behind the development of modern science.

  • In the middle of the 16th century, the Polish philosopher and astronomer Capernicus

  • demonstrated that whatever our senses might have suggested to us for hundreds of thousands of years,

  • according to logical reasoning, the truth is that the sun does not, in fact, revolve around the earth.

  • But the skeptics weren't only interested in the errors we fall into when doing astronomy--

  • they were fascinated by our tendencies to fall into error in our personal lives

  • under the influence of our emotions.

  • For example, our minds are seldom free of the influence of moods:

  • a kind of emotional weather that scouts over our mental horizons

  • normally without us having any understanding of where these moods have come from,

  • when they might lift,

  • or even that they exist.

  • However, these moods can have a decisive impact on our ideas.

  • We might in one mood consider ourselves fortunate

  • with a bright-lit future, and feel grateful to those around us.

  • And then, a few hours later, without anything in the outer world having changed,

  • another mood might lead us to a whole set of re-evaluation of almost everything about us.

  • Devilishly, part of what it means to be subject to a mood is not to realize that we are in its grip.

  • We simply feel that our friends, who we liked quite a lot yesterday, are no good.

  • And our job, which once offered us so much, is absurd.

  • Tiredness can be a particularly powerful agent that silently and invisibly perverts our judgement.

  • The 19th century skeptic, Friedrich Nietzsche, remarked,

  • "When we are tired, we are attacked by ideas we thought we'd conquered long ago."

  • Though crucially, it's extremely rare and counter intuitive to judge that it really might be tiredness

  • that's affecting our outlook rather than certain objective facts in the world.

  • We are keener to conclude that we've suddenly developed a deep resentment against humanity

  • that we urgently need to get to bed.

  • Lust can similarly play with our judgement,

  • leading us to see sensitivity, kindness, and a decent alternative to our current partner.

  • But there is, in truth, just an exceptionally beautiful profile

  • and perhaps not much else.

  • As the German skeptical philosopher, Arthur Schopenhauer, wryly concluded,

  • "Immediately after population, the devil's laughter can be heard."

  • Appreciating how flawed our minds are

  • forms the basis upon which the story on emotional skepticism is founded.

  • This skill, defined as a cautious awareness of the misleading power of our feelings on our judgement

  • Having surveyed the fragilities of our minds,

  • the Ancient Greek skeptical philosophers

  • recommended that we learn to develop an attitude of what they called "Epoche,"

  • translated as "reserve," or "suspension of judgement."

  • But where of our tendencies to error

  • we were never to rush into decisions.

  • We were to let our ideas settle

  • so that they could be re-evaluated at different points in time

  • and we were to be especially vigilant about the impact of sexual excitement and tiredness

  • on the formation of our plans.

  • For a range of historical reasons,

  • we've collectively been extremely reluctant to recognize the benefits of emotional skepticism.

  • The romantic movement of the 19th century

  • bequeathed us that beguiling would often distract solution

  • but it's our emotions that we always find us guides to the truth.

  • But we would've gone a long way to counteract the problems of our minds

  • if we sometimes do ourselves the honor of not listening to our feelings.

  • Instead, waiting for some unhelpful moods to pass

  • and accepting that we are at heart, highly viscous bags of saline solution

  • who stare out at reality via a highly unreliable and distorted pane of glass

  • and must therefore frequently suspend judgement, moderate our impulses,

  • watch over our diet, and strive to get to bed early.

It's easy to grow up with a sense that our feelings are reliable guides

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it