Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • Translator: Galina Mitricheva Reviewer: Denise RQ

  • Most of us like food and enjoy eating as a very pleasurable experience.

  • But sometimes, this relationship with the food

  • becomes an anxiety-provoking one.

  • I would like to go deeper.

  • And I will start from my personal memories.

  • It happened in 1994,

  • my very first day working as a psychologist.

  • I, as a novice specialist, was sent to talk with a thin, curly, redhead girl.

  • She was very difficult to relate to, and she bearly spoke,

  • and she was angry, and I was angry at her.

  • And all team was annoyed with her as she was sick with anorexia.

  • After few months,

  • she was sent out of the hospital without any noticeable change.

  • And you know, I still remember her name,

  • and I remember my own helplessness while working with her.

  • And the question in my head, "Why it was so hard to treat her?"

  • Now, I have much more experience.

  • Through over 25 years of my career as a psychologist, psychotherapist

  • I have found an answer.

  • A very provocative answer.

  • The answer is that eating disorders are hard to treat

  • because actually they are not only about eating.

  • But if they are not about eating what they are about then?

  • In essence, it is difficult to treat

  • because it's not just a simple human behavior, eating,

  • it's [something else and it's hidden].

  • But before we go to these complex things

  • I would like first to just simply describe you quickly

  • what do we mean by the title eating disorders.

  • So it's an umbrella term for usually three mental illnesses.

  • First is anorexia.

  • Anorexia is characterized by a very low weight

  • and a huge fear of putting on weight.

  • It's the most severe eating disorder type

  • and with long-standing consequences,

  • and the highest mortality rate of any mental illnesses.

  • Next is bulimia.

  • Bulimia is characterized by a binging and purging behavior:

  • it's cycles of binging, guilty feelings,

  • and unhealthy compensatory behavior afterwards.

  • This unhealthy behavior could be laxative use, extreme sporting,

  • could be dieting, and it's there for one reason - the one goal -

  • just take the control, emotional and body control back.

  • The last one is the binge eating disorder.

  • Actually it's a very modern disease,

  • officially recognized as a mental illness only recently, namely 2013.

  • And it could be diagnosed in a person who in a very short period of time

  • swallows huge amount of food without being physically hungry

  • and who does it alone.

  • So after the swallowing of this amount of food,

  • the person feels disgusted with oneself.

  • I want to stress here that the binge eating disorder

  • is not the same as chaotic eating

  • or sometimes like when after holidays we all overeat

  • especially after Easter or Christmas, you know that.

  • But it's a repetitive pattern,

  • it's twice a week or three times a week.

  • So it's a very severe mental illness.

  • And because the person has no compensatory behavior,

  • it usually goes together with obesity, too.

  • And almost half of the patients who have

  • binge eating disorders are male.

  • So what is behind eating disorders?

  • As I have mentioned, you could notice that it has psychological and physical issues.

  • And they are tightly interconnected.

  • But despite a long history

  • of medical history on eating disorders and especially anorexia,

  • - it goes back to the end of the 17th century -

  • and zillion research on eating disorders and other types,

  • we still don't know how the psychology and biology is interconnected.

  • So I would turn to the psychology part first.

  • Eating disorder is very much about emotions.

  • And especially shame.

  • Shame and other emotions

  • could be controlled by starving, or eating, overeating food.

  • Because of this unbearable state, the person overeats

  • and this overeating could increase even an emotional turmoil afterwards.

  • Second, to have a mental illness means to have a stigma.

  • Especially in Lithuania.

  • And to have a stigma means, in eating disorders, to be a loser,

  • to be worse than your family members, than your friend, than a loved person,

  • and nobody wants to go to treatment

  • because nobody wants to be officially recognized as a failure.

  • It's so hard to treat eating disorders.

  • And this stigmatization holds the person from treatment,

  • and this stigmatization is even more difficult to bear by the male patients.

  • Because of this stigmatized image of the eating disorders as a female disease,

  • and you know this.

  • For many, many years,

  • the origins of eating disorders were thought to only be psychological ones.

  • And this lead to simplification of the understanding,

  • and this understanding lead to some ineffective treatment

  • that was to arrive.

  • But I want to stress here:

  • we have lots of myths about the psychological issues,

  • and one of them is that parents or the family are responsible

  • for children developing eating disorder symptoms,

  • or the social media and cultural attitudes are to be blamed for it.

  • I followed this particular misconception at the beginning of my career, too.

  • But not now.

  • However, there is more that just psychology,

  • and I would like to talk about it.

  • Sure, psychological and social attitudes have an influence

  • on the way we look at ourselves,

  • the way we judge others, their appearance.

  • But I want to stress that they don't cause eating disorder directly.

  • And there is a hidden biological mechanism to blame.

  • And as I have said,

  • biology and psychology become interconnected,

  • and all these factors could be divided into three main groups;

  • and I will explain this in detail.

  • The first group is so called the "predisposing factors".

  • These factors make us vulnerable to eating disorders,

  • and the evidence suggests now

  • that our body weight, our body shape

  • is determined by genes.

  • In some regions of our brain

  • we have signals,

  • we have neurochemicals

  • which send messages about hunger, about our appetite balance,

  • signals in our brain and other sides respond to it.

  • But what is interesting is that for eating disorders

  • patients seem that they can't recognize the signals

  • or moreover, patients with anorexia

  • are able to even ignore these signals,

  • and this is why they could starve longer,

  • and not recognize that they are hungry, and suffer all these consequences,

  • that's why it's more difficult to treat them also.

  • Genetics contributes to some psychological personality features

  • even before we start to develop the eating disorder.

  • Especially with anorexia.

  • In childhood, anorexic people had

  • this tendency to [inaudible]

  • high aggressiveness, obsessiveness, perfectionism,

  • and these trends tend to stay even after recovery.

  • So all I have mentioned here is about

  • these predisposing hidden factors,

  • and they are silent, we don't know what we have in our brain, in our genes.

  • Now we know that for eating disorders there is nothing specific:

  • our inheritability follows the same not-specific pattern;

  • many genetic factors are responsible for it,

  • like for depression, for schizophrenia.

  • It's why we have no specific medicines to treat eating disorders.

  • But all these biological factors are hidden, are secret,

  • until they are released

  • by a second group of factors; the triggering factors.

  • These triggering factors could be very simple.

  • it's all psychological or social factors.

  • It could be like a critique of your body shape,

  • or someone who said you are too fat,

  • or it could be an enormous stress of a job or could be stress at school,

  • particularly when ending school.

  • It could be dissatisfaction with oneself, and it could be losing a beloved one.

  • It could be psychological trauma - very much -

  • and it could be sexual abuse, for example.

  • And the social pressure to remain thin.

  • So it's about psychological factors which release like a bullet

  • these hidden biological mechanisms,

  • and they all push toward either binging either starving

  • and all the biological mechanisms that lay underneath.

  • So the last group - I said there are three groups of factors -

  • the last group is so called "maintaining factors",

  • and they are like anchors for eating disorders.

  • They make specifically harder to make the disorder go away

  • because of the physiological consequences of starving,

  • that become a vicious circle, and it's difficult to change habits.

  • And these factors could be psychological or social too.

  • One of the main psychological factors, you know, it's the compliments

  • a person gets from his environment when he loses weight,

  • "Oh, you look great!"

  • And the person goes, "OK, I reached a goal, I want to continue."

  • And that goes further and further and slowly, slowly it develops,

  • and the disease is maintained.

  • The message I want to leave you with is that eating disorders are hard to treat

  • because slowly, slowly, slowly these patterns

  • overtake the person's thoughts, actions, lifestyle,

  • and become the only way to define themselves.

  • It's the only way to feel the value of life.

  • Slowly, it becomes an identity.

  • And it's not a disease anymore, it's a new identity.

  • And getting better with treatment for such kind of person

  • means to lose one's identity.

  • And the patient asks, "If I will be treated who I will be then?"

  • It's very scary to go to the treatment. It's very scary.

  • You know, keeping this in mind and the illusions

  • the psychological security that the eating disorders provide,

  • I would like just to use the metaphor of the woolen sweater:

  • it keeps you warm but it starts to itch, and you want to take it off.

  • Bur it's cold, and you want to put the sweater on again.

  • But it keeps on itching and it's bad enough that you take it off again.

  • Or you need an alternative, and if you have no alternative,

  • you put this itching sweater on you again.

  • Yes, actually it takes a long ti,me to recover from eating disorders

  • and my practice shows that it took four,

  • five, seven, even twelve years

  • to recover from eating disorders completely.

  • And just to finish my talk:

  • what we do really seek by having eating disorders?

  • Consciously, we seek to improve our experience, our physical self,

  • but unconsciously, we do seek love, admiration,

  • we want to feel better than others.

  • Sometimes, eating disorder helps to deal

  • with aggression or sexual identity issues.

  • And it's why it's about our unstable emotional self.

  • Therefore, the opposite for eating disorders is not a normal eating

  • - you could guess already -

  • the opposite is self-acceptance and a high self-esteem.

  • High self-esteem will not let all these hidden mechanisms start working.

  • And it's why I ask you

  • make a difference and care about your emotional self

  • and direct toward more valuable goals in your life.

  • Thank you.

  • (Applause)

Translator: Galina Mitricheva Reviewer: Denise RQ

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it

B1

【TEDx】飲食失調。為什麼治療它們如此困難?| 伊洛娜-卡約基內|TEDx維爾紐斯 (【TEDx】Eating Disorders: Why is it so Hard to Treat Them? | Ilona Kajokiene | TEDxVilnius)

  • 26 2
    Amy.Lin posted on 2021/01/14
Video vocabulary