Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • Stop right here if you haven't seen A Star Is Born, because there are major spoilers

  • coming.

  • We're about to take a deep dive into the 2018 remake, directed by and starring Bradley Cooper,

  • featuring a star turn from Lady Gaga.

  • Let's break down the ending, and analyze the new movie's connections to older versions

  • of this classic Hollywood tale.

  • Modern motivations

  • In previous versions of A Star Is Born, the male lead succumbs not necessarily to his

  • addictions, but rather to his envy of his paramour.

  • In the 1937 and 1954 versions, the character of Norman Maine chooses to end his life by

  • walking out into the ocean, a poetic end for an artist at the end of his rope.

  • In the 1976 version of the story, the character dies in a reckless car accident.

  • In the 2018 version, Jackson and Ally work out their jealousy problems, which almost

  • makes you think that this time might be different.

  • Unlike the 1976 version, where the budding starlet catches the older musician in bed

  • with another woman, the new film never casts Jackson as a cheater.

  • It makes him out to be a better guy in general, portraying him as someone who's self-medicating

  • to cope with both a traumatic childhood and his development of tinnitus, a condition which

  • hinders his career.

  • Cooper's version underscores his character's deep personal problems.

  • As he said in an interview with FilmStruck, the scene at the Grammy Awards was one of

  • the first scenes he thought of when making the movie.

  • According to Cooper, Jack doesn't want to hijack Ally's speech out of malice.

  • He's trying to come from a place of support, and his demons just won't let him.

  • Fateful foreshadowing

  • If you're unfamiliar with the Star Is Born story, you may have missed some subtle clues

  • about Jackson's fate.

  • In the beginning of the movie, he drops Ally off at home and tells her...

  • \"Hey, I just want to take another look at you.\"

  • That line was inspired by past versions of the movie.

  • But in those versions, it's the last thing the musician says to his lover before he dies.

  • A exit-by-hanging is also foreshadowed when Jackson speaks to a counselor, revealing that

  • he once tried to hang himself from a ceiling fan when he was younger.

  • He only failed because the fan crashed down.

  • In another scene at the beginning of the movie, his car passes by a billboard covered in nooses,

  • as good a visual indicator as any that offing himself is on the musician's mind.

  • Guilty conscience

  • Ally's manager, Rez, tells a fresh-out-of-rehab Jackson that his personal problems will make

  • him nothing but a hindrance to his wife's career.

  • Rez also tells Jackson in no uncertain terms that he will relapse again.

  • When Rez refuses to let Ally take Jackson on tour with her, she cancels the whole thing,

  • but she doesn't tell Jackson why she bailed on her performances.

  • She doesn't know that Jackson already knows the real reason.

  • Essentially, Rez unwittingly creates a self-fulfilling prophecy when Jackson's guilt over the canceled

  • tour triggers the relapse that ends his life.

  • Brotherly love

  • In the 2018 film, Jackson says he took his father's voice – a line Bradley Cooper says

  • was inspired by a line in Bruce Springsteen's autobiography.

  • Jackson reveals early in the movie that he was orphaned at a young age, so his older

  • brother, Bobby raises him.

  • Shortly before ending his life, Jackson apologizes to Bobby for their decades-long problems,

  • blaming the sorry state of their relationship on himself and his addictions.

  • He also tells Bobby that he took his voice, acknowledging that Bobby is the only father

  • figure he recognizes.

  • Interestingly, Cooper really did take Elliott's voice in real life, pretty much literally.

  • Cooper developed his character's Elliott-inspired vocal performance before Elliott was signed

  • on for the movie.

  • When Cooper went to recruit Elliott for the project, he demonstrated some of his character

  • work, essentially parroting Elliott's voice right back to him.

  • \"Made me laugh to beat the band.

  • Parts anyway.\"

  • Elliott later said, \"I didn't have any tips at all, he already had it down.\"

  • \"We spent, you know, months and months, working on that voice.

  • I think I lowered it like, almost an octave.\"

  • \"Good.\"

  • Tip of the hat

  • In the final scene of A Star Is Born, Ally introduces herself as \"Ally Maine,\" using

  • Jackson's last name in public for the first time.

  • In another obvious homage to her late love, she sings a song he wrote for her, titled

  • \"I'll Never Love Again.\"

  • But that wasn't the only way she honored Jackson in the film's heart-wrenching closer.

  • Earlier in the movie, Jackson argues with Ally about the lack of authenticity in her

  • pop records and image, including her orange hair, which was largely influenced by Rez

  • and her label.

  • In the film's final scene, Ally's hair is brown, with her style finally hewing closer

  • to her authentic self.

  • Me through you

  • In the 1954 version of A Star Is Born, Judy Garland's Esther introduces herself as \"Mrs.

  • Norman Maine\" in her final scene after Norman's passing.

  • It's the same ending from the 1937 original, and the 2018 remake keeps the tradition going

  • by recreating the 1954 film's closing scene almost shot for shot.

  • Lady Gaga's Ally even takes the same stage at the Shrine Auditorium that Esther did for

  • her tribute performance.

  • Ally's tribute song also evokes the 1976 version, in which Barbra Streisand's Esther performs

  • her own song written by her late husband.

  • In this way, their husbands' legacies live on through the success of their true loves.

  • End of the beginning

  • The final shot of the film, in which the camera lingers on Ally Maine singing on stage alone,

  • is what Cooper has called \"the moment a star is born.\"

  • In an interview with CinemaBlend, he said,

  • \"Ally at the end of the movie is just starting.

  • What's she going to create is going to be even bigger than what we've seen prior.\"

  • Gaga has said that she rarely saw playback of the movie while it was being filmed, with

  • the exception of this final scene, when she was directed to look right at the camera.

  • Cooper knew then that it would be the last frame of the film, and Gaga could see why.

  • According to the star, the \"brilliant\" final moments are so memorable because they show

  • \"the human courage to persevere and to move forward.\"

  • It's a powerful theme, and timeless too, a good reason why they keep remaking this movie.

Stop right here if you haven't seen A Star Is Born, because there are major spoilers

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it