Placeholder Image

Subtitles section Play video

  • Our understanding of death has changed dramatically

  • in the last hundred years.

  • I'm wondering what happens when we die.

  • Alex: So, I have been on a journey

  • to try to answer that one impossible question,

  • and it's taken me to a lot of interesting places.

  • Questions drive our show,

  • and this one comes from a YouTube viewer from Norway.

  • - Woman: Do you hear me? - Yeah, you sound great.

  • About your question--

  • What is that one question that everyone wants to know

  • but no one has the answer to?

  • I've lost a lot of people.

  • Someone I know really closely

  • who's been like a mother figure to me

  • just got terminal cancer,

  • and she has, like, a couple weeks left now.

  • I don't wanna sit here and think that they just die sadly

  • and fall into emptiness.

  • I'm super terrified of dying.

  • So, I'm not trying to prove the afterlife. That's unknowable.

  • But what if modern science could reveal what we'll experience

  • in the final moments of our lives?

  • ( music playing )

  • More people are searching for what happens at the end of our lives,

  • so we're gonna figure that out.

  • You're gonna figure out what happens when we die?

  • Uh, I already have.

  • When Helle brought this question to me, I started digging,

  • and one thing that kept popping up was this video on a dog

  • that was brought back to life.

  • In 1926, a scientist came up with an experiment

  • that would redefine the way we would interpret the process of dying.

  • Dr. Sergei Brukhonenko drained dogs of blood,

  • and they died while connected

  • to his new machine the autojektor.

  • They stopped breathing and then their heartbeat ended.

  • They were believed to be completely dead.

  • Then the doctors waited.

  • After ten minutes without a heartbeat or breathing,

  • the autojektor cycled their bodies

  • with re-oxygenated arterial blood

  • and then the dogs came back to life.

  • And over time, they made a full recovery.

  • The dog experiment shows us that death was not just a moment in time,

  • but it was a long process.

  • So, that raised the question, if death is a process,

  • at what point do we truly die?

  • In the case of the dog,

  • that dog was actually never dead at all.

  • He had never died.

  • - What was he? - Allow me to explain.

  • That's a transition.

  • So what I have here are some custom

  • "Glad You Asked" tarot cards.

  • - Okay. - I picked these

  • because we tend to search for answers in the supernatural,

  • but there's still so much to be learned from science.

  • For most of human existence, life was thought to reside in two organs.

  • You had the heart and you had the lungs.

  • Do you have any idea why?

  • Those seem to be the ways that we can tell

  • if someone is dead from the outside--

  • - if they're breathing, if you can feel their heartbeat. - Exactly.

  • Alex: For thousands of years, we considered somebody dead

  • if they had no pulse and they weren't breathing.

  • But these signs can be misleading,

  • as people can actually recover from both.

  • This lead to fears of being buried alive.

  • Jean Jacques Winslow, a medical expert of his time,

  • stated that the safest way to define death

  • was putrefaction of the body, or decomposition.

  • But we still relied on that heart-lung definition.

  • Without signs of either, you're considered clinically dead.

  • In the last hundred years, that started to change.

  • In the '30s and '40s, two new machines

  • were commonly used to extend life.

  • We got the defibrillator that could restart the heart,

  • and the iron lung, followed by the respirator,

  • that could pump the lungs with air.

  • At around the same time,

  • we used another machine, the EEG,

  • to study electrical signals in the brain.

  • The brain will flatline within two to 20 seconds on an EEG

  • once the heart stops beating.

  • Alex: So, if each of these organs was not required

  • to be working all the time for you to be alive,

  • maybe we have to start thinking about death differently.

  • In 1978, President Carter mandated a commission

  • to study and define death.

  • He hoped to find a modern definition

  • which took into account recent medical advances.

  • In 1981, they published their report, "Defining Death."

  • This lead to the act that hospitals today use,

  • making the old definition of death obsolete.

  • The focus shifted over to this-- the brain.

  • This became the final indicator of whether you were alive or dead.

  • Now, there are levels to this--

  • the higher and the lower brain.

  • Most medical experts today say

  • that once you lose higher level brain functionality,

  • which is where logical thinking and personality reside,

  • you are considered dead.

  • You are dead even if

  • some of the lower level brain functions,

  • those controlled by the brain stem like breathing,

  • still persist.

  • So you can be brain dead, but still be breathing,

  • and have a heartbeat-- everything.

  • Totally. And that gets into kind of murky territory with how we define dead.

  • So, to answer what happens when we die,

  • we have to focus on one thing,

  • getting as close as possible to the final moments of life

  • to see what we feel and experience in those moments.

  • - To here. - The near-death experience.

  • ( music playing )

  • So I started researching NDEs.

  • They're in Medieval accounts

  • and as far back as the writings of Plato.

  • They're in the artwork of Bosch from 500 years ago.

  • They're seeing a bright light.

  • They're going through a tunnel.

  • They're hearing voices and communicating with the dead.

  • To help go through the research,

  • I'm getting Joss to help me dive in.

  • Hey, Joss.

  • - I need your help. - Okay.

  • So I've been looking into near-death experiences.

  • Maybe there's a medical reason

  • - why these things are happening. - Mm-hmm.

  • So, just kind of survey whatever research is out there

  • - on how legit these experiences are. - Yeah.

  • Alex: While Joss is looking at NDE experiments,

  • I'm getting some caffeine and researching the history,

  • the controversies, and cultural impact of near-death experiences.

  • First, history.

  • 1975, Dr. Raymond Moody publishes a book,

  • "Life After Life."

  • He coins the phrase "near-death experience."

  • Over the next two decades,

  • he's established as the preeminent expert on NDEs.

  • He proclaims the transformative effects of NDEs

  • and becomes the subject of this 1992 documentary.

  • Once they come back,

  • they tell us that they're totally transformed

  • and they have no more doubt whatsoever.

  • It's engrained into the public consciousness.

  • Even celebrities are saying they've had them.

  • It's just a lot of white light,

  • and you see people that have passed on and--

  • When you're in a coma for eight to ten days,

  • you're basically knocking on the door.

  • I was talking to my dad.

  • I sort of floated into this tunnel.

  • YouTube data shared with us

  • indicated that between 2017 and 2018,

  • views on videos related to death increased by 40%.

  • So clearly a lot of people have questions about death,

  • and one of the phenomena they're looking at is near-death experiences.

  • All right, that's enough internet.

  • I need to find an actual experiencer and talk to them.

  • I'm on my way to meet with Tony Cicoria.

  • He's an orthopedic surgeon

  • who in 1994 was struck by lightning

  • and experienced an NDE.

  • But something weird happened to Tony.

  • Tony became obsessed with music

  • and started to play it all the time,

  • and today he is a renowned composer.

  • ( playing piano )

  • Tony: It's 1994, I'm at a family gathering

  • and I tried to call my mom.

  • I took the phone away from my face.

  • I was gonna hang it back up,

  • and I heard this huge, loud crack.

  • And I saw this big flash of light come out of the phone

  • and hit me right in the face.

  • And it just threw me back like a ragdoll.

  • And I was confronted with myself

  • on the ground about ten feet away.

  • And, you know, the first thought

  • that popped into my head was, "Oh, ( bleep ), I'm dead!"

  • And I'm looking down at the ground

  • and I noticed that my legs were dissolving.

  • You're seeing your body on the ground.

  • - Yeah. - You're feeling yourself outside of your body,

  • but you still feel yourself walking and present.

  • Yeah. Yeah, that was really weird.

  • I was just a ball of energy.

  • And right about the time I realized

  • this is the greatest thing that could ever happen to anyone,

  • it was like somebody flipped a switch,

  • and, bam, I was back in that body.

  • And I was pissed.

  • Some circuits got fried, and some that got opened,

  • and I had access to parts of my brain

  • that I didn't know existed for me.

  • But then within a couple weeks, all of a sudden

  • I started to have this insatiable desire to hear piano music.

  • Being struck by lightning, having an NDE,

  • didn't give you instant super powers.

  • I wish it had given me super powers.

  • I was skeptical.

  • I was a scientist before I went into medicine.

  • I-- you know, I thought about things and, you know,

  • there has to be a structure to follow.

  • But I'm absolutely certain

  • that consciousness survives death

  • and that we keep going through the cycle.

  • It doesn't seem like you're afraid of dying today.

  • No. No.

  • And that's a blessing and a curse.

  • I think that there's a process that happens

  • as we approach death.

  • It's an incredible experience.

  • It's certainly not something to do

  • before it's time to do it,

  • but it also is something to not be afraid of.

  • Alex: That was great!

  • I'm about to speak with Dr. Pim van Lommel,

  • and he a scientist from the Netherlands

  • who's been tracking near-death experiences for years.

  • Alex: Hello, Dr. van Lommel.

  • Yes.

  • How would you define near-death experience?

  • I think there's a lot of studies out there

  • that have tried to prove that near-death experiences

  • and out-of-body experiences exist.

  • Have you heard of Dr. Parnia's AWARE study?

  • - So I asked you to look into this AWARE case. - Yes.

  • Joss: This was the largest scientific study

  • of near-death experiences.

  • I put a little model of their experimental method.

  • - You made this yourself? - Yeah, I spent a lot of time making this.

  • - Amazing. - You better like it.

  • So, this is a hospital room where patients were likely to experience cardiac arrest.

  • Medical professionals would be rushing in

  • and trying to resuscitate this person.

  • And in those rooms they installed a shelf

  • - near the ceiling - Oh.

  • and placed a picture on top of that shelf.

  • And the idea was that if someone was going through an out-of-body experience,

  • they often claim that they're looking at themselves from the top of the ceiling--

  • that they would be able to see this picture

  • and report back what they saw.

  • During this study period, around 2,000 patients

  • had cardiac arrests, but only one of them

  • was healthy enough to explain an out-of-body experience.

  • But they didn't have a shelf in his room!

  • So the study was inconclusive on out-of-body experiences,

  • since nobody could describe the picture on the shelf.

  • I spoke to a NDE experiencer.

  • His name is Tony Cicoria.

  • What does that tell you about how influential these experiences are?

  • This is definitely not what all of us experience at the end of life,

  • and I've been looking at this other case

  • that does tell you what might be happening

  • at the end of life for all of us.

  • A researcher up in Buffalo

  • has been looking at these cases for the past five years.

  • So you're going to Buffalo.

  • I'm going to Buffalo.

  • So after a long trip, we finally arrived over at Hospice Buffalo.

  • We're good? Thank you.

  • The thing that makes this facility so special,

  • is they've been cataloging the dreams

  • and end of life visions of patients.

  • So these patients will tell us what they're experiencing

  • at the very final moments of their lives.

  • Man: So can we just talk for a second?

  • We're just filming.

  • Woman: Oh.

  • - We can go this way to inpatient unit. - Okay.

  • ...there's little coves where people can hang.

  • There's an English garden out here,

  • so we actually push people in their beds outside.

  • - Hi. - Hi, Helen.

  • - Yes. Hi. - I'm Alex.

  • - Great to meet you. - Nice to meet you.

  • - How are you doing today? - I'm doing very well.

  • Christopher: You're a good Polish girl, I see.

  • Yes, I am. Polish and Serbian.

  • Christopher: Have you been having unusual dreams at all?

  • - No. No, nothing. - No, nothing.

  • It tends to come as people are closer to dying.

  • But she's too-- you're too healthy.

  • You've got time.

  • I did the first study that attempted to quantify

  • what happens to people at the end of life

  • by asking patients directly, you know,

  • "What is it you're experiencing?",

  • every day until death.

  • And, so attempted to put definition

  • around what people were feeling or experiencing as they were dying.

  • It went like fire around the world.

  • A doctor at a hospice in Buffalo

  • has been studying this for years.

  • Man: He and his team have documented 1,400 cases.

  • He says the dreams are comforting to the dying.

  • Christopher: "New York Times,"

  • "Huffington Post" a couple of times.

  • Ireland, China, India, you name it, been there.

  • - And it just keeps growing. - What did you start to discover

  • - when you were looking at the research? - Well, it was remarkable.

  • People were having these very intense experiences.

  • We call them dreams

  • because it's the only reference point we have.

  • But the thing we hear most common from patients is,

  • "No, no, you don't understand. This is different

  • than any other dream I had. This happened."

  • When I woke up I-- it was like they were there,

  • you know, all three of them together. And it was nice.

  • The vast majority of people, greater than 80% if you ask them, you know, for weeks--

  • - 80%? - Yeah, at least having one experience

  • that was distinct and different from normal dreaming.

  • Heightened acuity, clear thinking.

  • In fact, half the people said they weren't asleep.

  • And in terms of themes, far and away it was seeing the deceased,

  • some living a past meaningful experience.

  • I'm back in the service.

  • I'm at Fort Devens up in Massachusetts.

  • You know, when you dream, you kind of put things together and it's all a fog?

  • - Right. - That's not what happens.

  • This is recalled as though it's a lived event.

  • I was laying in bed

  • and people were walking very slowly by me.

  • My mom and dad were there.

  • My uncle.

  • Everybody I knew that was dead was there.

  • There's this kind of paradox where you're physically dying,

  • but inside you're very much alive and feeling.

  • You know, we all have wounds for having lived,

  • and they just seem to kind of get addressed.

  • I can't say that my mother and I got along all those years,

  • but we made up for it at the end.

  • Woman: Paul is my dad.

  • He was 82 when he passed away

  • about six and a half years ago.

  • There was this study going on

  • and we were looking into dreams and dying and so forth.

  • He, of course, said yes.

  • They were forming this company that were gonna oversee.

  • A new company.

  • And the guys are all young.

  • They're like I remember them, and I'm old.

  • And I'm trying to tell them,

  • "Guys, I've been here, I've done this,

  • - I'm not gonna do it again." - ( chuckles )

  • Do you think that he was okay with death when it finally came?

  • I think he had come to grips with death.

  • He took comfort in the dreams that he had.

  • I think sometimes in his dreams

  • he was kind of wrapping things up,

  • like getting closure with his buddies in the service.

  • He was not afraid.

  • You know, it was-- this was good.

  • Christopher: Dying's a process.

  • We tend to view death as that last gasp,

  • that grabbing of the chest, what have you.

  • Most dying is less dramatic.

  • It's quieter. It's gentler.

  • It's more natural.

  • Alex: Dr. Kerr's studies suggest

  • that the majority of the dying

  • may eventually have ELDBs.

  • In his 2014 study,

  • he found that more than 80% of his patients

  • had these vivid experiences.

  • This isn't just happening in America.

  • These stars represent a few of the areas

  • where ELDBs have been recognized.

  • A Swiss study found nine out of ten patients in palliative care

  • experienced these very real dreams and visions before dying.

  • Tony: What happens when you die is you will experience

  • absolute love and peace.

  • It's gonna be an earthshaking feeling and freedom.

  • Christopher: It tends to bring folks this comfort or closure.

  • They're made whole again.

  • So, of course, there's more research to be done.

  • But maybe our brains, faced with the specter of no longer existing,

  • are stepping in to prepare us at the end

  • by revealing what life was all about.

  • And if that's the case, we don't need to be afraid,

  • because if we're lucky, we'll be ready.

  • Helen: Everybody dies.

  • We just don't know where or when or how.

  • But I'm 92, so I think it's time for me to go.

  • This is a copper casket.

  • - Truly copper. - Wow, it's like memory foam.

  • ( laughs ) Sorry to laugh.

  • - Almost like a really soft mattress. - It's a mattress.

Our understanding of death has changed dramatically

Subtitles and vocabulary

Click the word to look it up Click the word to find further inforamtion about it