Subtitles section Play video
BILL WERDE: My name is Bill Werde.
I'm the Editorial Director for Billboard, Billboard Magazine,
billboard.com, billboard.biz.
And if I'm supposed to know anything, I'm supposed to know
a little bit about what goes on in the music business and
what goes on with music.
And so I thought today that since there was a cross
section of different cultural commerce leaders here in the
audience, that I'd put forth the theory that music--
the music industry-- is a little bit of the canary in
the coal mine, by virtue of file size, by virtue of the
ubiquitousness of music.
When the digital revolution happened, the music industry
was the first one to shit the bed.
[LAUGHTER]
In order to properly contextualize the conversation
that we're about to have, I promised I would try not to
swear too much.
That's one.
You guys can keep score.
In order to properly understand the conversations
that we're going to have here today over the next hour, I
want to take just three or four minutes and kind of take
you through the music business, where it's been,
where it is now, and where it's likely going.
This is a gratuitous slide in which I subtly remind you to
follow me on Twitter.
So starting shortly after World War II, people listened
to music on vinyl albums.
It was shortly after World War II, because after World War
II, Americans had the resources.
They had money, and they had the materials again.
And vinyl records started becoming very popular because
of this new craze called rock-and-roll music.
We fast forward.
We get to cassette albums, and suddenly
music is more portable.
It still sounds like crap, but it's more portable.
And you can see with each curve you get
a little bit higher.
Now this is the CD.
And you can see we're progressing through time.
And this period right here, this big giant spiral, that's
what the music business-- the recorded music
business, mind you--
likes to refer to as "awesome awesomeness." This is where
people are going out and repurchasing all the music
they already own at $17 a pop.
This is, at the peak of this moment, right-- that very,
very tip-top peak--
that's the teen pop explosion.
That's at the Backstreet Boys, Britney Spears, 'N Sync--
very good, an 'N Sync fan in the audience.
[LAUGHTER]
BILL WERDE: You can't be any happier at this moment in time
if you work in the recorded-music business,
because you've got these dying, passionate fans for
these boy bands, and Britney, and Christina.
And all they can do is go to a record store-- you remember
record stores--
and spend $18 to buy the album.
And then you know what happens right at that peak moment?
Napster happens.
And so here we are.
This is the sale of CDs, and you can kind of see the effect
that the digital revolution had on the sale of CDs.
It wasn't pretty.
I think, staying true to my role as the canary in the coal
mine, I'll tell you that there's a couple of things
that we all learned from the recorded-music business during
this period of time.
And the most important one, since we only have a little
bit of time here today, is that you
cannot fight the current.
One thing you may notice about all three of these cycles is
that once you hit your peak moment and you start going
down, you never start going back up again.
So you can either adapt and figure out awesome things you
can do with that current, or you can shit
the bed, number two.
That was ironic.
[LAUGHTER]
I got here late, and they told me that people laughed at Eric
Schmidt's jokes.
And that made me feel really good.
Because Eric Schmidt is a brilliant man, but he is not
Steve Martin.
So here we have digital album sales.
And we can see there's still a pretty big gulf.
And we can see that digital album sales didn't quite take
off the way some of these other formats took off.
The curve isn't as quick.
People are a little slow on the uptake.
But this is why I think the music business is actually
positioned to be a canary in the coal mine and not just a
bunch of people buried at the bottom.
Because when we add in track-equivalency sales--
so we take 10 tracks, and we consider that the
volume of an album.
Now suddenly, in 2010 and today, in fact, we've hit the
break-even point.
Now granted, it's a break-even point that's much lower than
where we were, where the music business was 10-12 years ago.
But it's a floor.
It's something you can build on.
Now that break-even point doesn't take into
consideration all the new ways people are making money since
the digital revolution began.
So you've got live music.
In the same 10-12 years that the recorded-music industry
has been in a free fall, live music has actually grown, and
grown pretty steadily with a couple of dips here or there.
People are making more money from touring.
People are making more money from merch.
And I think probably the biggest shift that has gone on
is that, once upon a time, people put out an album and
toured to support it.
And now, people put out music to support their tour.
Spotify--
services like Spotify, MOG, Vivo, YouTube.
What's interesting is that just a few years ago, iTunes
was basically responsible for 70%, 80%, 90% of a record
label's digital revenue.
And today, if you talk to someone at a record label,
what you'll find out is that digital revenue has become
roughly 40% to 50% of a typical label's revenue in
recorded music.
And of that 40% to 50%, as much as 40% or 50% is now not
coming from iTunes.
And that diversification is really important news-- really
good news--
for the health of the recorded-music business, and
for the health of everyone.
Competition is a good thing.
But if you want to talk about the power of YouTube and the
power of these platforms, I want to use a little example.
How many people, by a quick show of hands, know the song
"Gangnam Style?" So most of you.
I'm shocked, by the way, that so many of you haven't heard
the song, "Gangnam Style." But I will not publicly ridicule
you at this moment.
How many people here know the song "Whistle," by Flo Rida?
So decidedly fewer.
So what's interesting about this to me are these numbers.
"Whistle," by Flo Rida, was the number one song on FM
radio in all formats last week.
It was played almost 20,000 times.
That's 3,000 times a day in the United States.
That's amazing.
That's like a great, great song.
Psy's "Gangnam Style," in the last two months has been
played 220 million times, or 3.4 million times a day.
That is the opportunity that is created by the
democratizing platform such as YouTube.
You make a better product.
You make a better video.
You make something amazing.
People share it.
People see it.
Brand deals have gone up.
Pepsi, Coke, Chevrolet, Heineken--
all these labels that are spending all
this money on music.
Film and TV syncs have gone up--
Mad Men, Breaking Bad, X Factor, all these
shows that use music.
This is what's happened since recorded
music took its nosedive.
Kickstarter--
you're going to hear from Julia Nunes in just a moment,
but she put some great videos, some great songs, on YouTube.
Wound up with millions of people
checking out those videos.
Put up a Kickstarter campaign.
Wanted to raise $15,000.
Raised $75,000.
Pandora.
And at the center of all these is the artist with a different
kind of leverage point than the artist had before recorded
music hit the skids.
Because in the recorded music, in the old model, if you were
a really, really superstar artist, you might generate 20%
of the revenue that was created from
selling your albums.
And today, in a lot of these opportunities, the artist is
much more the partner.